Big Town Czar (1939) Poster

(1939)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Not a really, really big "shew".
mark.waltz23 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This racket drama from the late 30's it's just another monster film about someone who thought they were a big shot, but really was just an obnoxious bully. As played by Barton MacLane (one of the oddest choices to ever play leads), he's charmless and humorless, and not commanding enough outside of his Broderick Crawford like barking to warrant respect. His parents, Esther Dale and Oscar O'Shea, argue every time he comes around, with Dale wanting nothing to do with her son (obviously a copy of Marjorie Main in "Dead End") and O'Shea weak and defeated by life.

Old girlfriend Eve Arden (underused in a far too serious role) warns him to leave his brother Tom Brown alone, but Brown is far too impressed with big brother's life to stay away, especially since his brother can get him work as a prize fighter. Eventually the rackets get involved in manipulating the fights Brown is involved in, and tragic circumstances puts MacLane on the run. Efforts to give his character a conscience aren't fully believable because there's not enough backstory, and Brown seems far too young to be his brother, while MacLane is closer in age to Dale and O'Shea.

Programmers like this, obviously meant to show that crime doesn't pay, came out at least one feature a week during the 1930's and 40's, but not everybody could be a Bogart or a Cagney or a Raft or a Robinson. MacLane was great in supporting roles, and he puts in all the effort here, but there is not much sympathy for him. The fact that the film is far too bent on the criminal elements and never has any lighthearted moments makes it a bit dark, even though it fortunately avoids being dull. But it's basically just another "we've seen this before, and better" blip on the screen of film history, the type of film you'll forget about 15 minutes after it's done. Ed Sullivan, who wrote the story, provides a bit of narration with all of the energy of a gangster's stogie.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
The Rise And Fall Of A Big Shot
bkoganbing2 April 2008
Big Town Czar is a B picture gangster film with the sole distinction of having been written by Ed Sullivan who at that time was not the host of America's most successful television variety show. Instead he was a newspaper gossip columnist, one of the rivals to the number one New York columnist Walter Winchell.

Barton MacLane plays the lead and we first see him pulling a palace coup against racketeer Walter Woolf King with sidekick Frank Jenks. He's on top of the world now, but he's got a kid brother in Tom Brown who wants to leave college and follow him into the rackets. That's a prospect that will break his parents, Oscar O'Shea and Esther Dale's hearts. It's not sitting well with his girlfriend Eve Arden either.

I'm guessing the original story that Sullivan wrote is better than how it was translated to the screen. The characters seem poorly motivated, a lot of their actions make no sense. Brown comes off as such a punk, I can't believe that MacLane just didn't slap some sense into him.

Ed Sullivan wrote himself and played himself in the film. He also narrates portions and while it's a good ten years earlier than I remember him from television in the Fifties, he looks about the same.

The cast from Barton MacLane, Eve Arden on down just go through their paces and collect a check. Sullivan looks the most animated of the lot and that's saying something if you remember him from television.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
The Gangster's Mistake
Mike-7641 January 2017
Phil Daley muscles in on his own boss taking over the NYC's number's racket and is enjoying the high life. His younger brother Danny quits college when he sees how his brother lives and becomes one of his agents. Danny decides to get into the fight racket by telling Chuck Hardy, championship contender, to take a dive. When Hardy loses the fight, rival gang leader Mike Luger loses a fortune and decides to get revenge on the Daleys.

This is a film without much purpose or reasoning. Barton MacLane's character is a jerk but at the same time, he is really given the blame and anger of everyone he encounters due to his brother's idiotic actions. The characters just seem to be going through the motions and the audience is just left thinking that there are a lot better stories that drive home the point that crime doesn't pay.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed