Blackmail (1939) Poster

(1939)

User Reviews

Review this title
28 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
MGM Tries to Imitiate WB and Succeeds…Mostly
LeonLouisRicci10 April 2014
Here's to You Mr. Robinson. Even when Slightly Miscast and Upstaged by the Villain Edward G. managed to put Verve and Gusto in any Role. Here he goes from Family Man to a Rage Filled, Revenge Seeking Psycho Hell Bent on Saving His Family and Fortune from a Slimy and Totally Repugnant former "Friend".

There are some Minor Cringe-Inducements mostly at the Beginning with some Comedy Relief and Smarmy Family Stuff, but Once the Blackmailer Shows Up Things Kick into Overdrive and there are some Very Effective Chain Gang Scenes and a Suspenseful Escape.

The Oil Fires are Realistic and this is one of the Few Times that MGM tried to be Gritty and Deliver a Message. They were Aping Warner Brothers and did a Pretty Good Imitation.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Pretty Gritty
howdymax11 April 2002
All chain gang movies take us on a journey. We start with a nice guy, usually innocent, being brutalized on a chain gang until he becomes a seething mass of controlled rage out for vengeance. This movie is no exception.

Edward G Robinson has been victimized before so his situation here is no real surprise. The surprise is the object of his rage. A total psychopath named Ramey, played by non other than Gene Lockhart of all people. The casting director in this movie was a genius. Who would have ever thought of this perennial nice guy as a villain. Crybaby Bobs Watson does his bit as EGR's kid Hank. Big Boy Williams is his loyal affable self. It is no wonder he stayed busy for decades. Only Ruth Hussy drops the ball in this one. She just doesn't seem gritty enough for this kind of melodrama.

It may sound crazy, but there is something comforting about the savage routine of a chain gang when compared to the terror of escaping and becoming a fugitive. You would think that every police force in the country has nothing to do but search for this guy.

I won't get into the ending - it's a little hard to swallow, but I think it's worth waiting for. Just remember, this takes place long before the Miranda decision. This is a little programmer that gets lost between "I Was a Fugitive From a Chaingang" and "Cool Hand Luke", but as chain gang movies go, this is a winner.
17 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Robinson Upstaged!
telegonus10 May 2002
Tough guy Edward G. Robinson, who normally dominates every movie he's in, is upstaged in this one, a good, unambitious actioner, first by raging oil well fires, then by the sly performance of Gene Lockhart, as a particularly loathsome, scheming villain, complete with a baby talking Down East accent. The movie is otherwise unexceptional though very skillfully made at MGM, and features an innocent Robinson on the run from the law for a crime he did not commit. As his sidekick, Guinn Williams is presented as so moronic one wonders how he can hold down any job, much less function as E.G.'s second in command in such a dangerous profession as putting out oil well fires, but the ways of Hollywood are sometimes mysterious. The capable Ruth Hussey is wasted in the boring and irritating role of the wife, from whom we want the movie to get away as quickly as possible. Robinson at first seems out of place in the Oklahoma oil fields but is so robust as the hard-driving entrepeneur hero that this is easily forgiven, and besides, he always excelled at playing fearless men.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Man Wronged.
nycritic12 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Edward G. Robinson departs from his more notorious bad-guy roles to play the wronged man in BLACKMAIL, a film that is something of a distant relative of what would come to be THE FUGITIVE which would star Harrison Ford more than sixty years later.

John Ingram is a man who is trying to support his wife (played by Ruth Hussey right before her second-tier stardom) until his past comes in the form of William Rainey (Gene Lockhart) who not only is aware of Ingram's past in a chain-gang from which he escaped, but was also the man responsible for getting him there in the first place. He comes with a proposal to "clear Ingram's name" but this in turn lands Ingram back in the chain-gang with one motive: escape and revenge.

A simple story, one which never tries to go beyond it's apparent B-movie status despite the actors involved in it, BLACKMAIL does not seem like an MGM product but more Warner Bros. The sparse scenes, the unglamorous vibe throughout, the grittiness that pervades throughout add to its credence. Though some plot inconsistencies are present, it's a quick moving story and gets to the point pretty fast without asking too much analysis.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Another fugitive from a chain gang
bkoganbing8 April 2014
Almost 30 years before John Wayne did his tribute film to Earl 'Red' Adair the famous fighter of oil fires, Edward G. Robinson starred as a man with an oil fighting company, married to Ruth Hussey and with a son in little Bobs Watson. But in Black mail he's a fugitive from a chain gang being convicted of a robbery he didn't commit and escaping. Robinson keeps a low profile, as low as he can, but it isn't the law that spots him.

No it's Gene Lockhart and he knows him from when the robbery was committed. It was when both were in the navy and Lockhart was the real thief, but got scared and the money from the ship's purser which he stole in Robinson's bunk.

Now the scurvy little sneak develops a new scheme after first ingratiating himself with Robinson asking for a job and then rats him out with an exchange for a confession. You have to see how this works and I can't believe Robinson fell for it, but Lockhart gets control of an oil well that Robinson has a lease on and Robinson goes back to the chain gang.

Gene Lockhart made a career of playing all kinds of rat roles, but he really tops himself in Blackmail. You will love seeing how he gets his in the end.

The chain gang scenes are copied well from the classic film from Robinson's home studio of Warner Brothers. Chain gangs are as bad as they were when Paul Muni was serving on them and he too was framed for the crime he was sentenced for by circumstance. There's also a nice supporting part for Guinn Williams as Robinson's lunkhead assistant who has a good heart and actually proves valuable to him.

Fans of Robinson will like Blackmail it holds up well after almost 75 years.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Vengeance
Jim Tritten7 April 2002
Poor title for what is a movie patterned on "I Was A Fugitive From A Chain Gang." It would appear that some of the shots were either taken from that masterpiece or re-done virtually identically with new cast. Edward G. Robinson is presented in the Paul Muni role but this time the hero has been willfully framed -- not wrongfully convicted. This framing is necessary for the rest of the story line and the plot unfolds as believable. Gene Lockhart steals the show in his portrayal of the villain. Robinson never looks as gaunt as Muni and is less convincing as someone who has suffered on the chain gang. Watching Robinson's rotund body run through the swamps just doesn't hack it. If given a choice, see the Muni movie but this one will serve for those who prefer a different ending. A better title might have been "Vengeance."
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great start, great end - boring middle.
David-24011 January 2000
This film starts with a bang - literally. It also ends with a bang. You see Edward G is an oil-fire fighter in Oklahoma - and he's doing really well. Great job (if a little dangerous), great house, great wife, great kid. Trouble is he is actually a fugitive from a chain gang - and his past is about to catch up with him. A shame it does really because the scenes of Eddy walking fearlessly into fire-balls are unforgettable. A story about the lives of oil-fire-fighters would have been a lot more interesting than the rather dull blackmail leading to a return to chain gang stuff. The chain gang scenes never live up to those of the masterpiece "I am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang" - but I wouldn't be surprised if Hitler got a few ideas on his slave labor camps from this film. Were the chain gangs of the thirties really this brutal? If so there were a few "war criminals" in the Southern USA.

Anyway the film drifts back to oil fires at the end - and the climax is really spectacular. It is enhanced by Ed's magnificent performance, and an unforgettable snivelling evil performance from Gene Lockhart. Both rise above the ordinary material. Also impressive is Guinn Williams, but the very talented Ruth Hussey is given little to do but look worried, and Bobs Watson is VILE as the cry-baby son. All in all good MGM entertainment, with some great sequences.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Satisfying chain gang story with Edward G. Robinson sans Warner Bros.
vincentlynch-moonoi9 April 2014
Warning: Spoilers
I think this film -- MGM instead of Warner Bros. (I assume he was out on loan?) is one of Edward G. Robinson's better films, although definitely not one of his best. Frankly, as much as I liked Robinson, the Warner pics of this genre began to meld together after a while. MGM gave this film a slightly different feel, and for me, it worked.

As I child traveling in the south, I remember seeing chain gangs, but I never realized how depressing their lives were. This film shows you that.

Some feel this film has an unreal story line. Yes, it does. Just about as unreal as most of the Warner-type gangster films. But here it's done up with slightly better production values and some decent acting. Edward G. Robinson is fine as the wrongfully convicted oil man. Ruth Hussey, an often underestimated actress, is fine here as the wife. Gene Lockhart is surprisingly effective as the blackmailing villain. Thank god...we got through one film with child actor Bobs Watkins WITHOUT a crying scene (but I kept waiting for it). I never saw the attraction to sidekick Guinn Williams...and still don't.

Some have criticized the ending. I thought it was satisfactory...perhaps could have been handled a bit better...but was as plausible as most Hollywood endings of the day.

A rather satisfying film. Perhaps not quite a "A" picture, but better than your typical "B" picture.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Chain gang part 2
nickenchuggets1 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This is probably going to be the first instance of me talking about a film that has the exact same title as one I reviewed already. I liked that movie when I watched it, but it's not really as memorable as this due to the lack of Edward G Robinson. However, as you'll soon find out, just because it's memorable doesn't mean it's on par with most other Robinson projects. Here, he plays a man who has a job that really isn't portrayed often in movies whatsoever: fighting oil fires. John Ingram (Robinson) carries out this hazardous work in order to make sure he can have a place to live, along with his wife. The dangerous job pays well, and John eventually has enough money to purchase his own well, hoping to find a large oil reserve. Shortly after, William Ramey (Gene Lockhart) shows up at John's house after undoing the lock by himself. Ramey is someone who used to know John many years ago, and knows an ugly secret that he wants to keep buried. Unbeknownst to most people, John used to be in a chain gang because of his supposed involvement in a robbery. Ramey essentially forces John to give him a good deal or else he will tell the cops about his past. John remains convinced Ramey is all talk and will back off, but Ramey pushes on the deal anyway. John agrees to the deal because he thinks it will make his criminal past disappear, but he's wrong. Soon after, cops come to his house with a warrant, and with astounding speed, he goes from being innocent to incarcerated in a matter of hours. After being imprisoned, John is told by outside sources that not only has Ramey framed him, but he bought John's well too. Meanwhile, John undergoes harsh physical labor reminiscent of what he did years earlier. He eventually manages to escape and elude the police, even though all of them are looking for him. After making it back to his wife's house, John manages to track down Ramey and confronts him near a burning oil well. He starts thrashing and beating him, threatening to burn him alive, but Robinson is mobbed by bystanders. Ramey ends up admitting that he was the one who committed the robbery years ago that John was wrongfully convicted of in the first place, and John's reputation is restored. Now I know what most people will be thinking here, and they're right. This movie is basically a copy of Paul Muni's "I Am a Fugitive From a Chain Gang", since both of them have men being punished over crimes they didn't do. I find it strange Robinson would want to star in something so similar to Muni's film, considering he hated him. The casting is also kind of awkward. I typically say all Robinson movies are worth seeing, but he doesn't really fit the lead role of this film. Taking into account his mild obesity, it was quite ridiculous to see him running through a swamp in order to escape from prison guards (just like Muni) later in the film. Gene Lockhart plays a convincing bad guy, but his smug and in-your-face demeanor really started to get on my nerves. He obviously takes pleasure in sending Robinson to prison for a second time and doesn't care what underhanded tactics he has to use. Overall, this movie is, in my view, a rare mediocrity from Robinson and I expected more from him. Had I not watched Chain Gang last year, I probably would have liked this more, but it will always be a ripoff of that to me.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I Was A Fugitive from a Chain Gang - Twice
blanche-230 May 2015
Edward G. Robinson here is a victim of "Blackmail," a 1939 film starring Robinson, Ruth Hussey, and Gene Lockhart.

Ingram (Robinson, his wife (Hussey) and his son (Bobs Watson, known as the "Crybaby of Hollywood") live in Oklahoma, where Ingram fights oil fires He's considered one of the best. But he has a secret - nine years earlier, under another name, he was on a chain gang for something he didn't do, and he escaped.

All is well until William Ramey (Lockhart), someone from his past, shows up and blackmails him, using the promise of getting Ingram cleared, since it was he who committed the crime. However, he double crosses Ingram, who ends up back on a chain gang.

Ingram decides that this time, he will do his full sentence. Things happen to change his mind.

Gritty drama with Robinson suffering as only he can. Like Bogart, he could be mean as dirt or a sympathetic character. Here he's tough, caring, and sympathetic. Ruth Hussey gives a lovely performance as his wife, and I admit that Bobs Watson was so pathetic when he cried that I cried. He became a Methodist minister but kept acting as well.

Though the acting is effective, this is a routine drama. The actors keep you involved.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Enjoyable B picture - mild spoilers
id24721 November 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Fun Edward G Robinson vehicle to pass the time with, in which he plays a respectable family man, John Ingram, an oil industry fire fighter, with a dark secret, only to be blackmailed by his original nemesis, sent back to a chain gang prison for a crime he didn't commit, and eventually escaping once more, seeking vengeance.

Gene Lockart steals the film as Robinson's enemy, Bill Ramey, a slimy piece of work on a mission to ruin Ingram's life, and if you add hideous performances from Guin Williams, as a moronic family friend called Moose, yes I kid you not, and Bobs Watson playing the most nauseating brat of all time, as Ingrams son, you have the perfect B movie.

Loved the boiled egg and toast gag in the opening sequence!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Out of the frying pan and into a chain-gang
sol-kay29 November 2005
**SPOILERS** Having made a success of himself in the fire-fighting business in Oklahoma putting out oil well fires John Ingram,Edward G. Robinson,had it all. A booming business at the hight of the great depression a beautiful wife and darling nine-year-old son Helen & Hank, Ruth Hussey & Bobs Watson,who thought the world of him and the respect and admiration of the entire community. John he also had something that could destroy everything he achieved and worked for the last nine years, a dark and mysterious past.

Being convicted of breaking into the safe of his employer and having the stolen money found under his mattress John Ingram, who's real name is John Harrington,was sent to work on a prison chain-gang for five years. Escaping from prison John made his way to Oklahoma and started a new life and now with his old friend Bill Ramey, Gene Lochart, showing up on the scene that new life,as well as his freedom,is about to end. John giving Bill a job on his oil well to keep him quite about his past doesn't at all seem to work when Bill starts to put the squeeze on him for money and demands $25,000.00 to keep his mouth shut. John not having that much cash agrees to give Bill $5,000.00, his entire life savings, when Bill reveals the truth about the robbery that put John away and caused him to become a fugitive from the law. He was the man who broke into the safe and hid the stolen cash under John's mattress.

Having the $5,000.00 bank check sent to Bill's hotel and Bill having his confession sent by mail to the local police department would free John from being hunted by the police. It will also give Bill, a homeless vagabond, the security of living out his last years after he serves out the five year sentence that John was straddled with. As you would expect Bill doubled-crossed his friend and had him put back behind bars and his oil well taken over by Bill who used the blackmail money, that John gave him, to buy him out while he was doing his time with the chain-gang.

Determined at first to do his five years and then get back to his wife and child, as well as his fire-fighting business, John realizes that he has nothing to come back to with Bill buying him out and throwing his wife and son out of their home and on the street. Getting letters from Helen about how fine everything is John knows that things are a lot worse then the news he's been getting from her when he has a talk with his lawyer and co-owner of his business Moose McCarthy,Guinn "Big Bill" Williams. "Big Bill" broke the bad news about the raw deal John got both here in the chain-gang and at home due to the sleazy actions of his "friend" Bill Ramey.

Breaking out of jail with fellow prisoner Diggs(John Wray), who ends up getting shot and killed, John makes his way back home to Oklahoma. John's determined to settle the score with that lowlife Bill Ramey and get him to confess his sins, or better yet, and crimes that sent him away not once but twice to serve hard time in a southern chain-gang for crimes that he didn't commit.

Edward G. Robinson, in a good-guy role for once, is very good as the maligned and wrongly convicted John Ingram. The ending of the movie, even though very contrived and predictable, is very effective and rewarding to both John and his family, as well as the movie audience. John beats a confession out of Bill Ramey by forcing him to face the hell that he faces and faced every time he went to work putting out dangerous oil well fires.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
I say watch "I Was a Fugitive From a Chain Gang" instead...
planktonrules17 January 2015
Back in the mid-1930s, Warner Brothers came out with a shockingly brutal and absorbing drama about the evils of chain gangs. Paul Muni's performance and the script for "I Was a Fugitive From a Chain Gang" were superb and the film has held up great over the years. Because of this, films like "Blackmail" seem incredibly bland and pale in comparison.

When this MGM film begins, John Ingram (Edward G. Robinson) is a successful and well respected man whose job it is to put out oil fires. Unfortunately, he's also a fugitive from some Southern chain gang-- an innocent man who couldn't prove this but managed to escape. Since then, assuming a new identity, he's gone on to make a productive life and a nice family. However, when a scumbag (Gene Lockhart) comes to town, Ingram is in trouble. While he's just asking for a job, this guy is a crook and is the guy who is actually responsible for the crime Ingram was arrested for years ago.

So far, while the plot is hard to believe, it is worth seeing. What happens next, however, sure strains credibility way past the breaking point. The scum-bag EASILY convinces Ingram that he is willing to own up to his crime but only if he gets a huge payoff. In other words, he'll admit to the crime but escape--leaving evidence that will clear Ingram's name. Not at all surprisingly (since he IS a crook), he tricks Ingram and it's Ingram who is sent to prison. Duh.

For the rest of the film, Robinson spends his time in prison. However, the chain gang is run by a bunch of brutes (though they are FAR less brutal than the guys in the earlier film) and eventually he realizes he must escape in order to ever see his family again.

So why does this film earn a 5? Well, it is entertaining but it breaks absolutely no new ground and pretty much neuters the old plot. The chain gang, while unpleasant, doesn't seem all that bad and instead of this form of imprisonment being indicted, the film actually is all about capturing the real baddie and sending him to prison where he rightfully belongs. Amazingly poor considering the material.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mother of mercy! Is this the end of John Ingram?
utgard149 April 2014
Edward G. Robinson is rather implausibly cast as an oil-field firefighter named John Ingram who is even more implausibly married to beautiful Ruth Hussey. Turns out Eddie G. has a big secret in his past: he's a fugitive from a chain gang. Slimy Gene Lockhart shows up and tries to blackmail him. When that doesn't work, Lockhart cooks up a plan to steal Eddie's business and send him back to the chain gang.

Excellent work by Gene Lockhart. I've seen him in lots of movies, usually playing very similar roles in a very similar manner. But here he's playing a hobo shakedown artist -- with an accent, no less! He gives the best performance in the film, though Eddie Robinson is solid, as usual. Ruth Hussey is lovely and plays the courageous wife well. Guinn Williams plays Robinson's annoying friend. Some nice footage of the oil firefighters. The chain gang parts are a little reminiscent of a certain classic Paul Muni film. Diminutive Robinson's escape scene is lots of fun to watch, though. Look at him go! An enjoyable movie that fans of Robinson will enjoy. It's not one of his best but it's good entertainment.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Formidable adversaries
jarrodmcdonald-120 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
As far as Edward G. Robinson flicks go, this one isn't too bad. It's clear that the actor, freelancing at this point of his career, and MGM the studio behind the production, were eager to capitalize on the types of crime films he had done earlier in the decade at Warner Brothers. In some ways it's an uneven effort, because they are trying to balance the grit of a Warners picture with the gloss of an MGM picture.

At the beginning of the film we learn that Robinson is a family man with a secret. He was a fugitive from justice years ago who had changed his name, married a good woman (Ruth Hussey) and had a child (Bobs Watson).

During the last nine years, he has established a successful business putting out oil fires with his partner (Guinn Williams). He has become rather prosperous and lives in a fine home surrounded by a white picket fence in a fine community- probably Carvel U. S. A. Where the Hardys live just a few doors down. In short, he has a lot to lose if his secret were ever to come out. And it definitely does.

A shady character from his past (Gene Lockhart) shows up at his home one day looking for a handout. But this sleaze bucket does not just want a sandwich and a few bucks. His greedy black heart wants it all- money, Robinson's business, ownership of a profitable oil well, and respect from the local townsfolk.

Of course Robinson has no intention of giving Lockhart what he wants and tries to make some sort of deal to get rid of him. But Lockhart has carefully considered every angle before arriving on Robinson's doorstep, and he is able to outfox him. Lockhart goes from threatening exposure, to outright blackmail, to totally destroying Robinson's life in a few days.

There are some interesting dramatic scenes that occur as a result of what happens. Especially the part where the police show up to arrest Robinson, since they now know his true identity and his past criminal record. Robinson realizes he's been tricked by Lockhart, but he cannot deny that he never finished a prison sentence (for a crime he didn't commit, naturally)...and that he must own up to things like a man.

One of the film's more poignant moments involves him saying goodbye to his young son. The boy is told that pop is going way for awhile on business, not that pop is going back to finish out a prison sentence. We're supposed to feel sorry for Robinson, and for his family- which we do. And we are also supposed to feel angry, like he is, that a miscarriage of justice occurred and Lockhart shouldn't have the upper hand.

Soon Robinson is back in a striped uniform, having been put to work on a chain gang. The middle portion of the film shows him trying to adjust, and his being somewhat despondent at how his life has taken a U-turn. When he receives a visit from his old pal Williams, he learns what Lockhart has been doing with their business and is also told that his wife had to sell her nice home and move to a smaller place on the wrong side of the tracks.

This sets up the dramatic last act. Robinson manages to escape from the chain gang and heads home.

The big finale has him confronting Lockhart, this time on the edge of an oilfield where a fire is burning out of control. The explosions caused by the blaze mirror the inner explosions that are going on inside Robinson. His turmoil has given way to rage, and he doesn't hold back.

While the script goes a bit over the top, Robinson and Lockhart both turn in fine performances here. We believe they are formidable adversaries, and it is very satisfying when Lockhart finally confesses the truth, that he is the one who should have gone to prison, not Robinson.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The first thing that you need to know about BLACKMAIL . . .
tadpole-596-9182567 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
. . . is that there are tons and tons of movies and TV episodes with this title, and the 1939 MGM offering with Edward G. Robinson is NOT the one directed by "Fred Hitchcock" (as NORTH BY NORTHWEST actress Eva Marie Saint referred to "Hitch" during "THE OSCARS 2018"). Ms. Saint was NOT in Hitchcock's 1929 Blackmail, at which time she would have been extremely early in her career. I have a colleague who wrote an exceptionally cogent concise explication of THIS version of BLACKMAIL, from 1939, making full use of his many college degrees. I happened to be on hand to lend my street smarts to the exhausting proof-reading process through which all of my associate's musings are subjected. Trust me, the final product was so moving it probably made more than one angel weep. However, the bots running the show here put whatever High and Mighty criteria under which they operate ahead of the public good, denying you the wonderful insights offered therein. Since they never specify or give any clue or inkling as to what goes into their decision-making process (if any), I have not shared a single one of these cogent observations in this space (no one dares make the same mistake twice). However, our coast-to-coast network of film pundits with be distributing (at our great expense) individual printed copies of the original 1939 BLACKMAIL review at EVERY Major League Baseball park Opening Day, 2018, to all of the fans (that is, to each and every one) who has an interest in this film.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A GOOD NOT GREAT ROBINSON YARN...!
masonfisk11 October 2019
Edward G. Robinson stars in this 1939 film about a man being haunted by a past sin. An oil fire is raging & the nearest outfit to handle it is called in which is run by Robinson & company. A success in his trade & a consummate family man, his life is turned upside down when a figure from his past shows up at his door looking for a handout. It turns out Robinson was involved in a crime years before & instead of facing the consequences, he changed his name & started a new life for himself but when the beggar offers to accept the blame for the committed misdeed, Robinson is put into a tough position to clear his name (the man says he'll give Robinson a written confession of the crime in exchange for some money & a stake in Robinson's oil well). When the man reneges on his confession, Robinson is thrown in jail to stew. Running a brief running time, this typical Warner Bros. crime flick is slightly undone by its busy plotting but the crisp direction (the montages are killer) & pros in front of the camera makes the flaws imminently forgivable.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
some questionable details
SnoopyStyle19 September 2020
John R. Ingram (Edward G. Robinson) is a family man and a fireman specializing in dangerous oil field fires. He starts to gain some success until Bill Ramey (Gene Lockhart) from his past returns into his life. John escaped from prison chain gang with a new name and a new life. His wife Helen (Ruth Hussey) does know the truth. John gives Bill a job and Bill reveals that he did the robbery which sent John to prison. He wants $25k to confess to the crime but he pulls a trick on John.

The problem is that it doesn't make sense for John to trust Bill. The confession isn't worth that much anyways if he's paying for that land. The whole deal is rushed. The blackmail needs more time to develop. The chain gang is pretty good. I like the details of declaring every movement that the prisoners make. The escape is a little easy. It may be better if the guards aren't as close and he needs to take the guard's gun. If he had the gun, he would hunt down Ramey right there and then. That's the best ending for this movie. Going home is a weak detour. On the positive side, I love the fires. They look powerful. Quite frankly, going into the fire would be a great ending also. That would be a terrific turn. None of the confessions are worth the paper they're written on. On the other hand, I like the general plot. It's a good movie if one ignores some of the details.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Great performances helps this B picture disguised as an A.
mark.waltz7 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
If it wasn't for the presence of Edward G. Robinson, this crime drama definitely would have been a little programmer if it wasn't for the lead. On loan to MGM from Warner Brothers, he still basically in a Warner Brothers type film, so he easily could have stayed at his home studio. But the MGM gloss makes it look far more prestigious than it is, even though the plotline is the type of programmer that Warner Brothers had been releasing as either bottom of the bill second features or as solo features in neighborhood theaters for years. Robinson shares the glory with Gene Lockhart whose performance nearly tops his much acclaimed role as Stephen Douglas in "Abe Lincoln in Illinois".

Usually playing blowhard businessmen who somehow manage to get away with immoral business deals or scams, as well as frustrated husbands and fathers dealing with ungrateful children, Lockhart is an unlikely criminal who manages to frame happily married old friend Robinson which sentences EGR to a chain gang. Robinson escapes and seeks revenge, and Lockhart truly expresses fright in an unforgettable way that could be considered punishment enough. Ruth Hussey, as Robinson's wife, is lively and beautiful, but overshadowed by the two men. Still gritty and realistic in showing the hideous conditions of the chain gang, but nothing can beat how WB did it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good But Not Excellent
tom3605214 April 2014
Warning: Spoilers
My review does contain a spoiler.

If a man broke out of prison by striking a guard and risking the lives of others, wouldn't he be tried for that infraction when caught even if he was found to be innocent of the original crime? I think a better and more credible scenario would be for the main character to be inadvertently set free by some accidents in the prison such as a fire or storm or a train wreck during as prison transfer...

A number of prisoners broke free in the accident so the police would be looking for quite a few escapees and not just one man, making it a bit easier for Ingram to get through. Also, later on he would not be in trouble for planning and initiating the escape and attacking a guard.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Chain Gang" knock-off, but with some good parts
HotToastyRag16 October 2019
Imagine if Hollywood said to itself, "Let's make another version of I Am a Fugitive of a Chain Gang, but let's make it corny." You wouldn't want to see it unless the star was someone you really loved, would you? Well, Hollywood cast Edward G. Robinson, one of the most likable actors ever, to ensure you would go see it!

Eddie G always gives a good performance, so believe me, the script is at fault for the movie not being as great as its predecessor. Eddie G starts the movie as a wealthy, respected pillar of the community who owns a business that puts out oil-related fires. He has a wife, Ruth Hussey, and an adorable little boy, Bobs Watson. When a drifter comes to the house asking for a sandwich, everything changes.

The drifter is Gene Lockhart, in a very sleezy, slimy, villainous role. It's a lot of fun to see him in the part, especially since I'm used to seeing him as Bob Cratchit and Judge Harper at Christmastime. He's just as slimy as Eddie G is likable. It turns out Gene knows something about Eddie G's past, and he has the power to send him to prison. To find out any more, you'll have to rent the movie. Parts of it are good, like the prison scenes, which are ridiculously similar to Paul Muni's version, and the family scenes. Little Bobs Watson can cry at the drop of a hat, and he's never in a movie where he's not forced to do it at least once. If he were my little boy, I'd spoil him rotten!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Film Classic
whpratt128 November 2005
This was a great film in 1939 because the audiences loved Edward G. Robinson who was a great actor and will be admired for many many generations to come. In this picture, Robinson plays John R. Ingram, who has a past that he is trying to hide from along with his wife, Ruth Hussey. John Ingram is a very successful troubleshooter for fires at Oil Rigs and has become very famous, wealthy and happy with his wife and young son. Everything seems to fall apart when Gene Lockhart, (Bill Ramey) knocks on the kitchen door and asks for a sandwich and starts a real storm in the Ingram household. Ingram decides to drill for his own oil and at the same time gets deeply involved with Bill Ramey. If you never knew what a chain gang is, this picture will show you what happened years ago on a chain gang. Enjoy a great classic film starring Edward G. Robinson, who was accepted into the hearts and homes of America and even put on a United States Postage Stamp.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Oil Wells and Swampy Tales
davidcarniglia19 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Ex-con John Ingram (Edward G. Robinson) has reinvented himself as a oil rig firefighter. Pretty dangerous stuff; but even more damaging is that he can't escape his past. We start off with a pretty funny scene; there's an office fire, but Ingram's assistant, Moose (Guinn Williams) studiously ignores it. Anyway, he meets up later with John, (and wife Helen, played by Ruth Hussey) as they have an emergency call: a major fire. On site, the crew rigs explosives to blow the air supply away from the fire, which smothers it.

That does it. A newsreel truck rolls up; some more cutesy stuff plays out. Then the family visits their own derrick site. A vagrant breaks into their house, saying he's looking for John. He's no ordinary bum, he's Bill (Gene Lockhart), an excon too. John begins by telling him "You can stop sizing me up for a shakedown". Johnny's hit-up twice now for a robbery he wasn't involved in--the subsequent frame-up sent him to the pen in the first place. So, to buy Bill off, he gives the guy a job. he tells Helen that that's all there is to it.

Unfortunately, or intentionally, Bill slips up on the job. Moose knows that he's trouble. For one thing, the guy's drinking; but the big deal is that he confides to John that he, not John, actually pulled the infamous caper nine years ago. His excuse for not coming correct was that he never thought Johnny would be convicted. The blackmail, $25k (an immense sum then, of course), would ensure that Bill could clear him; we learn that Johnny is still on the lamb. No payoff, no confession. That's pretty clever. "I pay you $25,000 for doing your time!" Well, hey, Bill will sign a statement for the dough--a square deal, right?

Not exactly. The devil is indeed in the details, as they agree to mail each other what they want: Johnny sends the check, Bill sends the confession. But Johnny didn't know that Bill's letter won't arrive--he mails it without a valid stamp. So, just like that, cops show up at Johnny's, with a warrant. The cops do check out Bill for his confession, but of course, he gets it returned back from the post office. So, Johnny's nailed again for that pesky burglary, and the escape. It's chain gang time.

Kind of tear jerker stuff with the wife, kid, and Moose. I don't get that Moose thinks they have to keep up the blackmail payments; Bill never gave Johnny the confession, isn't the deal off? Anyway, this chain gang stuff is as wretched as it sounds. They recycle the shackles off a dead prisoner to put on Johnny. The guard Rawlings (Arthur Hohl) has it in for John, because the escape was on his watch. The convicts live in cages, work in swamps...basically die slowly. Johnny keeps getting these nice letters from Helen. One day Moose shows up, pretending to be his lawyer.

"It's bad all right" he admits. But why are they still paying Bill? Anyway, Johnny almost drowns a guard, which means even more brutal treatment. The guard goes a bit too far reading up a photo Helen has sent. Her letter says that Bill, who's taken over the Ingram well, is selling out. That does it for Johnny--time for another break-out. The next time Moose visits, Johnny enlists him in the escape plot. With the tool that Johnny and his buddy get their hands on, they get free of their chains. The actual escape works as pretty good drama. Johnny makes it, but barely.

It gets intense when he has to give some wary officers a ride in his getaway car. They ID him after a bit, but not until he stops and stows away in a waiting truck (literally hanging underneath it). That's surprisingly convenient, as he can drop off when it's safe. Under the nose of the cops, he sneaks back home. Helen is up to the task, doing what she can for him. He admits that he's let her down. She thinks they can "start all over"; but he knows that won't work. Unless... remember that confession?

Johnny's skulking around in the alleys near his house; the cops are lurking and prowling up and down. Meanwhile, there's a big well fire: can Moose handle it? Well, he splits the scene, as Bill won't sell him the well. Like the Creature From the Black Lagoon, Johnny emerges from the roadside to confront Bill. Johnny's set the fire to lure the jerk there so he can threaten him. Bill is desperate, blubbering. He'll do anything..."I did the robbery... I'll tell the cops you're innocent!!" He does just that. Great denouement. The last task is merely to put out the fire. The end.

This is a bit too long--inevitably so, because there's really two stories. The oil business, and the chain gang deal. Obviously Johnny's the connection between the two; but dramatically, the two settings are more or less autonomous. Each has its own characters (both have Johnny, naturally) and plot. Also, there's sort of a domestic subplot within the non-prisoner settings. We get a lot more family stuff here than in the average crime drama. Some of it is quite good, as Hussey is excellent as the faithful wife and protective mother. Bobs Watson is a very good child actor; but there's just too many of these home-front scenes.

I still don't understand why Bill can plausibly blackmail Johnny. The ending would work without the blackmail anyway. The movie might've been more thematically cohesive if we see Johnny escape the first time. In that case, we'd already have a look at this other side of Johnny, so that the long interlude--when he's back on the chain gang--doesn't seem like such an abrupt switch. In fact, the firefighting scenes, which are exciting, give this the flavor of an action-adventure story rather than a crime drama.

Despite some mixing of genres and plots, Blackmail is entertaining and effective. 7/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Blackmailed
guswhovian2 October 2020
Oil well firefighter John R. Ingram (Edward G. Robinson) is actually a escaped convict from a chain gang who was falsely accused. Soon, William Ramey (Gene Lockhart), the real perpetrator of the crime, turns up and blackmails Ingram into giving up his oil well.

Blackmail is MGM doing a Warner Brothers film, looking rather cheap in places. Honestly, a film like this wouldn't have been produced when Irving Thalberg was alive. It starts out interestingly - movies about oil well firefighters is an unusual topic - but gets rather silly when Robinson is sent back to the chain gang. It's all rather like I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang. There were some impressive special effects in the opening sequence.

Robinson gives a sturdy performance, while Ruth Hussey and Guinn Williams are good in support. The best performance goes to Gene Lockhart in an offbeat role as the blackmailer. Overall, it's an entertaining film, but nothing special.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Must For Robinson Fans
januszlvii22 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Blackmail is a great Edward G. Robinson movie. Here for a change he is the hero .His character John Ingram is a family man, married to Helen ( Ruth Warwick), who puts out oil fires. Spoilers ahead: He is put into a chain gang because of a frame job by very dishonest character named Ramey ( Gene Lockhart). Does Robinson win out? Of course, but how he does it is different then most other movies I have ever seen. If you are a Robinson fan, Blackmail is a must see. Easy 10/10 stars.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed