My Son Is Guilty (1939) User Reviews

If the police need information out of a suspect, just beat it out of 'em!

[planktonrules · 4/10 · 19 October 2020]

Police Officer Tim Kerry (Harry Carey) is a great cop...but he has a huge achilles heel...his son, Ritzy (Bruce Cabot). Ritzy is just no darn good and has just gotten out of prison but Tim thinks his son has seen the light and has changed. In fact, Tim helps Ritzy get a job...a job which he wants so he can help his gang with a robbery! About the only one who can see right through Ritzy is Barney (Glenn Ford)...a childhood acquaintance who knows he'll never change.

The acting is pretty good in this one though the film itself is yet another formulaic B-movie from Columbia. This doesn't mean it's bad...but it's also not particularly good because it's all pretty predictable. One of the few surprises is seeing Glenn Ford in one of his earliest roles (despite one reviewer saying it's Ford's first film, it isn't). The other is the message that cops sometimes just have to ignore civil rights and beat the truth out of suspects!! A decent time-passer that seems to promote occasional police brutality and not a lot more.

Ritzy is rotten.

[mark.waltz · 4/10 · 22 February 2020]

Hero Bruce Cabot from "King Kong" is nothing but shady in this late 30's crime drama about a cop's kid who couldn't stay on the right side of the law and ends up in prison. Immediately upon his release, he's snagged up by Hell's Kitchen female mob boss Wynne Gibson, working as a double agent for the mob at a precinct switchboard and doing mob related "errands" on his time off. Upset by the fact that old girlfriend Jacqueline Welles has taken up with good guy neighbor Glenn Ford (his film debut, Cabot gets in deeper and is involved in crimes that gets his best cop father Harry Carey shot and Ford's mother killed.

A decent cast tries to make this weak B script seem better than it is, but it's defeated by cliches that just manage to destroy what little credibility that the script has. The Nicholas Brothers do a brief dance bit, and veteran character actor Edgar Buchanan has a nice scene as the stereotypical friendly neighborhood bartender. Cabot goes into Cagney, Robinson, Raft and Bogart territory, but his character isn't well layered. On the total contrast is pop Carey, as good as gold and yet brave enough to stand up to the racket single handed. You'll most likely enjoy it (as it does fly by), but on the other hand, you'll also quickly forget about it.

Bad writing, editing, and direction - a triple threat

[AlsExGal · 4/10 · 13 August 2023]

Tim Kerry (Harry Carey), a beat cop in Hell's Kitchen, welcomes home his son Ritzy (Bruce Cabot) after he finishes his two year prison sentence. Ritzy tells his dad he'll go straight, and he may even mean it to some degree. But then his old gang gets in touch with him, now headed by the widow of the old gangleader, Claire Morelli (Wynne Gibson), and Ritzy decides to go for the easy money. Ritzy gets his dad to get him a job as a technician working on the police radio system so that he can get the radio to malfunction when the gang does a payroll robbery and thus give them time to get away before patrol cars can arrive or even know about the robbery. Ritzy does this in return for half of whatever the gang's take is. In a secondary plot, Ritzy is trying to take up where things left off with Julia, a girl from the neighborhood, but her budding relationship with a novelist, Barney (Glenn Ford) may get in the way.

This is not a boring film, because there are some good actors in it and because the plot is so simple that the plot holes and bad direction don't make it incomprehensible. Plus some of the plot holes are just howlingly funny. For example, the police are staking out a place prior to raiding it, and rather than have plain clothes officers acting nonchalantly or being out of sight there are half a dozen of them in uniform stuffed behind a staircase, and they are all visible. Who do they think they are fooling? After a robbery, cops are on stakeout again, this time in plain clothes, waiting for Ritzy to appear. When he does show up the police make their move. Why wait until now? Since in the previous scene they don't even seem to know who the robbers are, how did they find their hide-out to stake it out? Why did they not just arrest the rest of the robbers prior to this? Is Frank Drebbin of Police Squad the police commissioner?

Robbery scenes are alluded to and not shown taking place, because that would require time and resources. And Harry Carey, Wynne Gibson and Bruce Cabot must have fallen on very hard times for them to agree to star in this turkey. Do note the presence of a teenage looking Glenn Ford (he is actually 23) as the novelist in just his second credited film appearance and also Bruce Bennett as a member of the gang before going to Warner Brothers and becoming a serviceable supporting actor there.

I personally wouldn't bother with this one unless you want some laughs. In case you do, there are plenty of plot holes I did not mention in this review.

The Start of quite a climb

[bkoganbing · 2/10 · 31 October 2014]

I don't think that My Son Is Guilty would have been in any Oscar contention had it been released intact. But the editing department thoroughly butchered this film into incoherency. My Son Is Guilty was also Glenn Ford's debut film for Columbia Pictures, but fortunately for his career he wasn't the star.

Harry Carey stars in this film as your kindly neighborhood Irish cop in Hell's Kitchen in Manhattan. His bad seed of a son Bruce Cabot is getting out of jail after a 2 year rap.

Carey thinks a little kindness will reform him. But Cabot's got no such notions of turning straight. But he does let his father use his influence to get him a job in the police radio room where at a propitious moment the radios go bad when a gang Cabot is working with pull a large payroll holdup where a cop is killed.

Glenn Ford plays a friend from the neighborhood and rival to Cabot for Julie Bishop. Later on Cabot kills Glenn Ford's mother when she recognizes the fugitive.

The idea of any police department employing Cabot with a rapsheet in a police command center really boggles the mind. I was speechless at the mere concept.

My Son Is Guilty was also the first time that Glenn Ford worked with Edgar Buchanan whom he became great friends with and always tried to use in his films. Buchanan plays a bartender here.

Best performance in the film is that of Wynne Gibson as the widow of the former head of the gang Cabot works with and she's tough, smart, and beautiful. Too bad her performance was wasted in this film.

Glenn Ford made his feature film debut in Heaven With A Barbed Wire Fence the same year for 20th Century Fox. But Darryl Zanuck passed on signing him so Ford got a contract with Columbia. He'd have to work his way up in quality of pictures so My Son Is Guilty would be the start of quite a climb.

Harry Carey is a Good Cop With a Guilty Son

[glennstenb · 7/10 · 20 September 2021]

I have had fun reviewing a number of films here at IMDb and I try to stay consistent in what I look for or take note of in evaluating a picture. I find that reviewing a film adds a deeper appreciation for the film. I enjoy all motion pictures, from the finer tried and true greats and classics to lesser ones, including B-pictures like "My Son Is Guilty." I rarely bother to offer thoughts on the great films, or even most of the class-A features, as usually many --if not dozens-- of reviews have already been offered on them.

My overall enjoyment from viewing a film is what I am looking for when evaluating, or reviewing, a film. It really comes down to assigning a value as to how much I "enjoyed" the viewing. Yes, I may expect just a little more (or maybe considerably more) polish and sophistication from a big studio, high-budget picture with valued star players than I do from a smaller B-picture, but as far as enjoyment is concerned, I can get just about as much enjoyment from a B-picture as I can from an A-picture.

"My Son Is Guilty" is a good case in point. Sure, it is obvious from the production values and editing that it was made on a lower budget, but I absolutely and thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated this little film. I loved the sets and the players and the economical pacing. The story was indeed fanciful, what with Harry Carey being so singularly naive, but it is easy to get wrapped up in the program and all the disruption and reactions that the return to town of the bad son engendered. Bruce Cabot played the unredeemable son smoothly and convincingly. Seemingly many raters of this film have given it five stars, and some even fewer, but I happily give it seven because I got a lot of enjoyment from watching it.

son needs to be younger

[SnoopyStyle · 5/10 · 9 August 2023]

It's Hell's Kitchen. Tim Kerry (Harry Carey) is an honest cop trying to do good in the neighborhood while watching out for the bad apples. His son Ritzy (Bruce Cabot) is getting released after two years in prison. It's hard to stay on the straight and narrow.

This story would be more compelling if Ritzy is younger. He's in his mid-30's. He is who he is by this point. If he's a twenty year old, he would have his whole future ahead of him. It would be a more dire struggle to save the boy. As it is, I'm surprised that he is still coming home to his pop. I'm just not that into him and I stop caring about his drama. There is an early twenty-something Glenn Ford. He would be a better Ritzy.