The Battle of Gettysburg (1955) User Reviews

An odd but effective retelling of history.

[planktonrules · 7/10 · 7 April 2013]

I noticed something very strange about this film when I looked on IMDb--it was nominated in two different categories for an Oscar (Best Short, Two Reels and Best Documentary Short). It is very odd that it was nominated twice--that's for sure.

Leslie Nielsen narrates this odd retelling of history. I say odd because no live actors are used in the film...none! It was filmed at Gettysburg and the sound effects of war and the narration were all supplemented with pictures of the battlefield as well as statues and art (such as from the Gettysburg Cyclorama) from this national battlefield memorial and the nearby country. While this may sound pretty dumb, it worked pretty well--mostly because the sound effects and storytelling were very compelling. A highly unusual film that will likely appeal mostly to Civil War buffs and history teachers. See it for yourself and let me know what you think.

The NAKED GUN guy gives short shrift to critical thinking . . .

[oscaralbert · 8/10 · 13 July 2015]

. . . as he narrates THE BATTLE OF GETTYSBURG. He never says that one side was fighting to make sure that Oprah, Tiger, and LeBron would be born into slavery, or that the other was suffering and dying to guarantee that Michaels Jackson, Jordan, and Tyson would not share the same fate. I don't believe that Leslie Nielsen ever says the word "Black" here. Instead, we get a tediously endless recitation naming dead rich White guys who moved bunches of dirt poor pawns and their horses around a small Pennsylvania village for three days during the War to Free the Slaves. Never does Nielsen say that the Southern Rebel Leaders thought that they could get away with their lazy racism (making Black slaves do all their work) in perpetuity because then, like today, they had 90% of America's military bases and 95% of our military officers (since career military men hate the cold). As Gen. Abner Doubleday's Farm System produced more and more Union officers, the South's sneaky head-start in the War quickly was erased. By the end of the War, the Rebels' military "geniuses" such as High Treason traitor Robert E. Lee had lost most of the battles in the South, as well as Gettysburg, the main one fought in the North. Mr. Nielsen never ponders what sort of Reparations are due from all the future Billionaires, such as the half dozen listed above, to the descendants of the 150,000 White Northerners slaughtered to ensure their Free Future. Since nothing is "free," if not Now, When?

A bare-bones view of Gettysburg

[SimonJack · 6/10 · 19 April 2024]

This is a no-frills, no-thrills and no-action short documentary about The Battle of Gettysburg in the American Civil War. The July 1-3, 1863 battle was considered a key battle in the war. It was the largest and bloodiest by far. More than 165,000 Union and Confederate troops were engaged. And it had more than 50,000 casualties.

MGM sent a crew to, Pennsylvania, to film the Gettysburg National Military Park. Dore Schary wrote the script for this dry documentary. It uses voice over and background war sounds. Leslie Nielsen tells the story of the battle as the camera moves from one place to another.

This is a bare-bones documentary that won't appeal to many people. But what I especially like and credit the film industry for, is its shooting of real places of history for posterity. This 30-minute short picture did get two Oscar nominations.

Those who like history, scenic places and travel should enjoy this brief glimpse of Gettysburg. Of course nothing beats going there when one can.

A marvelous look at one of the most important turning points in American history

[llltdesq · 10/10 · 6 July 2001]

Shot on location at the battlesite, this short, which was nominated for two Academy Awards, uses visuals from what is now a national landmark and monument to tell the story of a critical moment in American history. Visually arresting and impressive, the cinematography is incredible for a short. The narration doesn't always flow, but it doesn't have to. This shows periodically on Turner Classic Movies and almost certainly will be run in March for the "31 Days of Oscar" festival they run each year. Most recommended.

Fun Short

[Michael_Elliott · 13 February 2009]

Battle of Gettysburg, The (1955)

*** (out of 4)

Oscar-nominated short was filmed at the Gettysburg National Military Park with Leslie Nielsen narrating the story of the famous battle. This is a rather interesting short because it runs a full 30-minutes, which wasn't too normal for the day. Another interesting aspect is that MGM decided to film this in a 2.35:1 ratio, which makes for some beautiful scenes. The final interesting thing is that they decided to make the movie without the use of a single actor. Instead we just get various shots of the actual battlefield mixed in with paintings of the battle and other photos. This was a strange way to present the documentary but for the most part it works just fine even though it does start to feel a bit long towards the end. What I enjoyed the best were the helicopter shots, which give us a grand view of the entire field where the battle was fought.

Who needs actors when you've got statues!

[Squonk · 5/10 · 25 October 2000]

This bizarre little educational short attempts to tell the story of the battle of Gettysburg without a single live actor appearing on screen. Leslie Nielsen narrates as we are treated to footage of empty fields, cannons, and statues of Civil War Heroes. Some sequences are quite informative, though a long way from being entertaining. This is probably a film better suited to Civil War enthusiasts than the average viewer.

Filmed Tribute To Shrine Of Martyrdom In Blue & Gray.

[redryan64 · 10/10 · 18 February 2012]

PERHAPS AS A FORSHADOWING of the technique which would prove to be most successful for PBS Documentarians, such as Ken Burns: this MGM Short Subject made fine use of inanimate images in its storying. Whereas, there are no still photos in use, they do accomplish the same sort of objective. They do so with clever manipulation of the movie camera in varying angles to Civil WEar statues, Paintings and to the Gettysburg Battlefield, itself.

WE MUST CONFESS that this was one movie short of which we had absolutely no knowledge. It was truly a pleasant surprise to have viewed it on the tube the other evening. The venue was Turner Classic Movies, of course; where there so many cinematic treasures stored, even in their in between programming. This includes their informative TCM Original Productions; as well as their seemingly endless supply of these vintage one, two and three reelers.

PANARAMIC VIEWS OF the huge Gettysburg Battlefield are inter-cut with closeup shots of the multitude of sculptures, which are numerous and strewn about all through the National Memorial. This cinematic work is complemented by the work of the narrator. It is the fine voice of Mr. Leslie Nielson, which provides all of the audio portion of the story. This was during a period when he was a sort of light Leading Man; being long before his success in AIRPLANE, "POLICE SQUAD" and the NAKED GUN Movies.

OUR EXPERIENCE IN viewing it was a very emotionally charged and captivating half-hour; which was very well spent. This short's script, editing and beautiful Technicolor filming would seem to be the next best thing to actually paying a visit to Gettysburg in person.

WE BELIEVE THAT this should be part of a required curriculum for all of our school kids throughout our nation. Until such time, make sure that you view it, yourself.

BETTER YET, PLAN your vacation trip right now; including to this hallowed ground in Pennsylvania.

Would've driven me, and probably you, batty and restless in school

[StevePulaski · 4/10 · 8 October 2015]

Imagine the dry, didactic verbiage of your fourth grade history textbook come to life, set to still images of the illustrations within the book that occasionally cut to shots of famous memorial statues and on-location pans of Gettysburg, and you have The Battle of Gettysburg. If you recall those days in high school history class, where the teacher would lecture you about history you've already memorized and regurgitated enough times to be able to author a textbook about the events and your experiences learning said material, The Battle of Gettysburg might trigger post-traumatic stress disorder that even the glorious colors and wide-angle camera lens of early CinemaScope, nor Leslie Nielsen's soothing narration, couldn't cure. The approach director Herman Hoffman and writer Dore Schary take is one of incredibly redundant, historical prose, that lacks any kind of emotional attachment to the battle and the noteworthy figures that were involved, let alone sacrificed, in Gettysburg. Shockingly dry and almost unbearably long at thirty minutes, it's stunning to see such acclaim for a short that would've probably drove kids batty and restless if shown in schools.

Narrated by: Leslie Nielsen. Directed by: Herman Hoffman.

Military Overview

[Ron Oliver · 10/10 · 17 April 2006]

An MGM Short Subject.

THE BATTLE OF GETTYSBURG in 1863 was a turning point in America's history.

This short film, narrated by Leslie Nielsen, relates the story of the great pivotal battle during the War Between The States. Dispassionate & evenhanded, it deals with its subject in a noncontroversial manner. Touching upon each of the major aspects of the days of engagement, the film ends with Abraham Lincoln's beautiful Gettysburg Address.

***************************

Often overlooked or neglected today, the one and two-reel short subjects were useful to the Studios as important training grounds for new or burgeoning talents, both in front & behind the camera. The dynamics for creating a successful short subject was completely different from that of a feature length film, something akin to writing a topnotch short story rather than a novel. Economical to produce in terms of both budget & schedule and capable of portraying a wide range of material, short subjects were the perfect complement to the Studios' feature films.