What a Nightmare, Charlie Brown! (TV Short 1978) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A cheeky and surreal but ultimately solid exhibition of our favorite beagle
n-mo31 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It started as a plain old winter day with Charlie Brown being Charlie Brown and Snoopy being Snoopy. Ever the optimist, Charlie Brown thinks he can treat Snoopy as an ordinary dog. Ever the Walter Mitty, Snoopy refuses to act like a dog and pull the sled. So not surprisingly an attempt by Charlie Brown to demonstrate turns the roles around: Charlie ends up the victim and Snoopy, the triumphant blowhard.

Snoopy has long tended to be slightly different on screen from in print. In the comics his manlike antics are largely fantastical (and usually pulled back down to Earth pretty fast), only occasionally and with more than a little ambiguity crossing the line into the surreal. On TV and in the movies he seems to get away somewhat more often with acting like a literal playboy, and that's what happens here:

To celebrate his victory and to restore himself after a day in the snow, Snoopy whips up five pizzas, a chocolate milkshake and a large salad, polishing everything off in a matter of minutes. A nasty bout of indigestion combined with Charlie Brown's bitter comparisons of Snoopy's to the austerity of life as an arctic sled dog leads to twenty minutes of nightmare: Snoopy now IS a sled dog in the Arctic!

Like Buck in Jack London's 'Call of the Wild,' Snoopy is too civilized and too soft for his new role, only exaggeratedly so. But ever the able one, Snoopy finds his footing and manages to become the "Alpha Dog" of the pack.

Some disliked this one because it didn't fit Snoopy's personality. On the contrary I thought it perfect. Snoopy is a loyal dog to Charlie Brown but he won't be a squish: witness the numerous occasions on which Charlie Brown tries to put him in his place and Snoopy shuts Charlie Brown up by pretending to "hand in his collar."

Others disliked the idea of Snoopy being punished. Let's face it: he's kind of a cocky glutton sometimes (he certainly is here) and he's definitely got it made under the Browns' mostly patient ownership. A couple days in the real world to prove what he's really got? Well, he did! Well, almost.

Still one of my favorites. The animation is simple as any 'Peanuts' offering is but is highly expressive and there are a few hilarious/absurd sequences to punctuate the torturous horror. It ends on a positive, if cheeky, note. It isn't pure 'Hallmark' fluff but 'Peanuts' never is (the existence of Lucy Van Pelt should attest to that much). If you're the type to enjoy roller coasters and/or slightly offbeat humor, this is for you. Cheers!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sled Dog Snoopy
Better_Sith_Than_Sorry27 September 2022
A warning from the top: don't come to this Peanuts special looking for humor and a lot of laughs. This really doesn't have many, but that doesn't mean it's not worthwhile. It's more serious in tone, perhaps the most drama-like Peanuts episode to this point in time (1978).

The plot is simple: It's February, snow is on the ground, and Charlie Brown tries to get Snoopy to drag his sleigh, like an Arctic sled dog might; Snoopy is having none of it, and in fact it's Charlie who winds up pulling the sleigh. After this, Snoopy settles down to sleep and has a nightmare (thus the title of the special). His dream, which makes up the bulk of the episode, is that he is now somewhere in the Yukon and has been forcibly added to an unseen man's team of sled dogs.

Being a beagle, Snoopy struggles to adjust to this new kind of life, and it only gets worse because the other dogs not only don't accept him, but are outwardly hostile towards him. Yet he must somehow persevere under the harsh weather conditions, the relentless crack of the whip, and undernourishment. It really is the stuff of nightmares for a domesticated beagle!

There is one funny scene in the middle of the dream that has Snoopy in a saloon. But after that it's back to the sled team before things come to a final climax that wakes him from the nightmare. It's definitely a departure from the usual Peanuts fare, but again, that doesn't make it bad. If you can adjust your expectations you just might enjoy it for what it is.

7/10. A different kind of Peanut. But not bad at all. Would I watch again (Y/N)?: Yes.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Def a change of pace for the characters....
gazzo-216 December 2004
Warning: Spoilers
......Snoopy as a member of a husky team, stuck out in Alaska, etc, a much more brutal outlook for the strip than usual. I can remember Not liking this as much, mostly due to it being such a jarring switch from their 1950s suburbia setting. I don't think this one works as well as the other specials, as you don't really buy Snoopy as White Fang, ya know?

Strange this is, it's all just a bad dream brought on by snoopy eating too many pizzas, which kinda takes away from the whole premise. Why not have him be on a flight(somehow) in Alaska, he winds up lost and abandoned in the wilderness for real, etc? I think this might have worked, at least better.

At times this series went awry, this was one of those times.

** for trying something different.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Love the "Peanuts" Series But This One Stinks!
cairn613 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
With so many specials, films, and even a regular Saturday morning series, one can expect even the "Peanuts" series to mis-step on occasion. "What a Nightmare Charlie Brown" mis-steps...in a really big way. With a storyline based on Jack London's "Call of the Wild" involving Snoopy dreaming that he's been pressed into service as a sled dog by an unseen musher, what may work for a big solid dog named Buck, just does not work with an adored for his antics dog named Snoopy. Too mean spirited, too angry, and too far removed from the premise of the series...this one missed badly. The one saving grace is Snoopy's determination to make the best out of what he's been dealt, but even that is ruined by the dream sequence's brutal ending. 20 minutes of sheer punishment on a character known and loved for being the central comedic figure of the series is just wrong. Pass on this.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed