Tidy Endings (TV Movie 1988) Poster

(1988 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The bond of shared love is never tidy.
mark.waltz10 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The long time ex-spouse and widower of a recently deceased person get together to share final details of an estate, share memories, shout out resentments and finally come together to express their grief. This isn't two men or two women expressing regrets for a love they both shared for the same person, but a woman, the ex-wife, and a man, the lover of that spouse who died of an AIDS related illness. The woman is the outwardly strong Stockard Channing, desperately miserable inside with regret, and the man is Harvey Fierstein, bitter about the red tape yet consumed by the last moments of his lover's life.

When Fierstein explodes at Channing that her efforts to become his friend will not work, you know it's just a matter of time before the softness in his heart opens up the floodgates of emotions and creates a bond between the two. After all, it's very apparent that even in death, both people still loved the deceased, and that love is not likely to die just because the person did. The two stage trained actors really go out of their way to get into The souls of these grieving people, and in a short hour, so much emotion is revealed.

Based on one act of Fierstein's play "Safe Sex", this TV movie came out at approximately the same time that the movie version of "Torch Song Trilogy" did. While that film did deal with the grief of loss in the gay community, it didn't touch on HIV so in some senses, this film is much more profound considering the time in which it was released. Fierstein may not represent the average gay man with his over-the-top persona, but when he tones it down and speaks in a soft voice, it's as if the deceased have returned as angels to speak through him, and that makes this quite special and for those of us who never forget our losses, it still gives us a sense of comfort.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Short, but profound.
bluedionysus7 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Seeking to watch (and own) everything Stockard Channing has ever starred or appeared in, I went into TIDY ENDINGS not knowing three things: that, 1) this was HBO's first gay-themed TV movie, 2) it was based on a play, and 3) it was so damned short - 53 minutes long, to be precise. Even so, TIDY ENDINGS almost feels like a feature-length film, since it explores such painfully realistic scenarios, jam-packed with intellectual and emotional information, wonderfully written, and superlatively performed. Not so needlessly painful, however, that one does not want to watch the picture again immediately after viewing.

The play was written by Harvey Fierstein (who also adapted it to the small screen), and, in addition, stars as Arthur, the romantic partner of Collin, who has just passed away from an AIDS-related illness. The thing is, Collin (unseen throughout) has also left behind an ex-wife, Marion (Channing), and a young son. Complications arise (and resurface) between the woman and the boyfriend in the wake of their beloved's death.

At first, things are mostly about Collin's material possessions - his will stipulating that loft he and Arthur shared be sold and the money be divided between boyfriend and ex-wife. However, both individuals deeply loved this man, and thoughts, feelings, memories, arguments, compliments, attacks, and such, ensue - finally "tidied up" (as we hope) with discovered affinities and gestures of appreciation and forgiveness.

More than anything, the film covers a range of hard, all-too-human topics that most TV work tends to avoid - esp. before and around that time. There are, indeed, tidy endings here - in a modest sense, in a sense of relief. However, an enlightened awareness of the harsh realities of life is never lost nor out of focus. This isn't Hollywood stuff.

Needless to say, Channing plays the confused, devastated, down-to-earth mother to perfection. Mixed feelings abound within her, because life isn't clear-cut. Still, Marion proves herself to be a wise and compassionate human being - and, ultimately, something of a tragic figure. Not a single note played by the great actress comes across as insincere.

Fierstein more than holds his own, too - and why wouldn't he? He wrote the play, and was obviously close to the material. It hasn't been an easy gig for the character of Arthur, yet Fierstein, as a writer, refuses to take sides between the lover and the ex-wife. Everyone suffers in these kinds of situations.

Some may claim that TIDY ENDINGS is dated, in both style and content, but that's nonsense. This is a scenario that could just as easily take place today as in 1988. As for style, why would (or even should) the past be like the present? The camera-work is quite beautiful and intriguing. And Stockard looks utterly ravishing as a classy blonde.

Short, yes, but well worthwhile.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Powerful and emotional
luckie-119 September 2004
The one thing that Marion (Stockard Channing) and Arthur (Harvey Fierstein) ever had in common - her ex-husband and his lover - has been lost to them both. Arthur is gay and lost his lover Collin because of AIDS. Though he is gone, the pain of his death from AIDS lingers on and he realizes that the spectra of AIDS will haunt him forever. Now the two people he loved must come to terms with his absence and each other. They are thrown into a battle by the loss, both needing a scapegoat for his death. Eventually, they discover strength, love and friendship from each other. This an incredible movie that is fabulous, well-written, well-acted, and extremely moving. Harvey Fierstein did an incredibly job of writing and acting in this movie and Stockard Channing is, as always, amazing.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Please release Tidy Endings on DVD
sammyraygordon12 September 2007
I love this movie so much and I have ever since I watched it multiple times on HBO in the 1980's. The acting in it is so wonderful, the characters are created in a way that you are drawn into their lives and you become part of the story and feel what they are feeling.

Please, either play this on HBO again and notify interested parties, or better than that, bring this film out on DVD. It is such a shame that it has sat on a shelf all these years and denied the viewing of thousands of people that this film could help.

I rank this film up there with all of the gay classics. I think you have my point by now so I will stop hounding you. Just Please put this film on DVD, you would make a few bucks, and a lot of loyal fans happy. Thanks
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed