So You Want to Throw a Party (1950) User Reviews

An okay short....but a great finale!

[planktonrules · 7/10 · 15 October 2017]

Mrs. McDoakes (Phyllis Coates) insists that she and Joe throw a dinner party. The problem is Joe is exhausted and in no condition to invite anyone over for anything. Not surprisingly, he makes a mess of things and the party turns out to be a bust. It's a shame, as most of the folks are creditors and they are hoping to make friends with these people so they won't have their things repossessed. After a game of Post Office, where all the guys take turns mauling Mrs. McDoakes, Joe has had enough. What's next? See the film.

This is a decent installment in the long series. However, the silly ending really makes this one worth seeing. Very clever and a bit of a surprise!

Can't Have A Party Without Mr. Shmoocumber

[boblipton · 6/10 · 12 July 2020]

Phyllis Coates insist she and George O'Hanlon throw a party, so a bunch of people show up to stare awkwardly at each other, just like every party I've thrown, in this episode of the Warner Brothers comedy short series.

It's not among the best of the series, but like all of them it has its moments of surreal absurdity, as it straddles the worlds of situation comedy and slapstick. O'Hanlon playsit big, and Miss Coates is strident. The various shlubs who show up for the party as are motley a bunch of middle-class White people as I've ever seen.

A Primer for those new converts to Mc Doaksiaism

[redryan64 · 10/10 · 11 February 2016]

HIGHLY ENERGETIC, REALLY well paced and constructed in a sort of comically logic manner, we have just screened this one for the very first time. It is the team of Mr.George O'Hanlon and Miss Phyllis Coates used at their very best. Each is used in the best way and are on the screen together for just the right amount of time.

THE WRITER/DIRECTOR, Mr. Richard L. Bare, makes good use of the proved top laugh getting element of the building and returning to gags that are introduced early on; only to be revisited in incrementally funnier stages 2 or 3 times. The unraveling bow tie gag and his mixing up two very different lists is a good example of this category.

IT WAS APPLYING this category of gag as their stock in trade by the production and star of THE JACK BENNY PROGRAM for so many years.

SO MUCH OF the storyline and the subsequent laughs generated are the result of what we like to refer to as "the Old Switcheroo." This is the proper classification or both Joe's mixing up sleeping pills for aspirin, as well as his giving his secretary the wrong list of people to contact (one being the list that Alice wrote, the others being his creditors-that's business people he owes monthly payments to you, Schultz).

THERE IS EVEN a certain balance and symmetry in the short's wind-up. During the party, these "adults" played "Post Office", with poor Alice being the favourite of the guys (showing good taste). So it was that the movie's ending was reached by the delivery of a special delivery letter by a Letter Carrier (Ralph J. Sanford), who unceremoniously kisses Joe on his cheek!

DO YOU GET it, Schultz? No, no! It's not "Sealed With A Kiss!"

Decent McDoakes Short

[Michael_Elliott · 17 April 2010]

So You Want to Throw a Party (1950)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Decent entry in the series has Joe McDoakes (George O'Hanlon) and his wife Alice (Phyllis Coates) throwing a party but poor Joe accidentally takes some sleeping pills and ends up inviting the wrong people over. So who does he invite over? The creditors he owes money to. The series had a few low points, many high points and a few entries that were in the middle and this here is one of them. If you're not familiar with the series then you might find this one mildly entertaining but fans will probably find much of the writing to be somewhat lazy. There's a long-running gag with Joe's tie that's never funny yet it gets played out at least three times. We also have another gag about the party being dead that doesn't really work. The best parts of the film are the early minutes when we see Joe accidentally taking the sleeping pills and the aftermath from doing it. As usual both O'Hanlon and Coates fit in their roles just fine and they both end up doing a lot more than the screenplay offers.