Noose for a Lady (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Dennis discovers whodunit
wilvram10 May 2014
John Hallam is poisoned and wife Margaret tried and sentenced to death for the crime. There's only seven days left to the execution when her cousin Simon Gale (Dennis Price) a colonial official from Uganda turns up unexpectedly and assisted by Margaret's stepdaughter Jill (Rona Anderson) endeavours to prove her innocence. He learns that Hallam was a sadist and blackmailer, not for money, but to torment his victims and that several of his acquaintances have something to hide. They include Upcott (Charles Lloyd Pack) whose wife has disappeared in mysterious circumstances and a major (Colin Tapley) responsible for the unnecessary death of troops under his command during the war. Local poacher Jonas Rigg (Robert Brown) has an important clue to the killer, but is himself poisoned before he can talk. And Margaret's time is running out...

Based on Gerald Verner's book of the same name, which in turn was the novelisation of his radio serial, it's no great surprise to find this, like so many other British films of its type, has an abundance of dialogue. There are also very few exterior shots, but it is gripping, with a considerable amount of tension. It's an archetypal 'whodunit' with a host of characters whom act in a suspicious manner or have some dark secret. There's the time-honoured gathering of all the suspects in a locked room: "One of you is the murderer". It's done with considerable power and effect though. Dennis Price, in the period after he had ceased to be a major star and before becoming a much admired character actor is good in the lead, as is Rona Anderson, who will always have a special place in the hearts of fans of British B movies of the era. Veteran character actress Esma Cannon is spiteful spinster Miss Ginch and popular opera singer Ian Wallace pops up in a small role as the pub landlord. Hardly seen since its original release, it's certainly worth watching, so well done to those DVD companies who are giving these modest but enjoyable films a new lease of life.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
comments on my experience with this film
ratdog7113 May 2002
I saw this movie once as a child and it has always escaped me . For a long time i thought i just imagined it , that it never existed , then i saw it again some 20 years later . Its not a great film by any means but i think it attains classic status solely on the dialogue and filming techniques . I mean how can you not like a grainy black and white film with poor lighting and extreme closeups with dialogue like ."Ive called you all here because the killer is amongst you, here in this room " " the killer is...." then the light goes out and there is a shot ... and then ... well you will have to see this movie to find out how it ends.. its a classic.. If any one has seen ths recently please let me know...I will be forever in your debt....
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
reasonable murder mystery
malcolmgsw31 July 2016
Dennis Price once again plays detective in this entertaining murder mystery.He plays a relation of a murdered man who finds that the man's wife has been convicted of murder and is facing execution.He joins forces with the murdered man's stepdaughter to track down the real murderer.The problem is that the local poacher who saw the murderer creep away from the house is himself murdered.Then Charles Lloyd Pack who looks as if he has an important clue has a stoke and dies in hospital.So with time ticking away all the usual suspects are assembled together,and believe it or not they include Esme Cannon..I have to say that the identity of the murderer is cleverly disguised,I did not guess write and was put off the scent by some very effective red herrings.So although essential a supporting feature the cast writing and direction make this into a very effective low budget thriller.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dennis Price and Esma Cannon
drednm25 May 2014
NOOSE FOR A LADY is a stylish British murder mystery that starts with a woman being convicted and sentenced for the murder of her husband. She has seven days until sentence is carried out. Then arrives a cousin (Dennis Price) from colonial Uganda who is determined to find the real killer. He goes to the quaint little English village she lives in and starts snooping. There's the worried step-daughter (Rona Anderson) who teams up with him to examine the various suspects. It seems everyone in town had a motive and chance to kill the mean old man. Story ends with the now clichéd gathering of all the suspects and the statement, "Someone in this room is the killer." No major stars in this little Brit thriller but everyone is quite good. Ronald Howard is the local doctor, Charles Lloyd Pack the quirky local trinket collector, Alison Leggatt and Melissa Stribling the lady and niece with a secret, Colin Tapley the fussy major, and Esma Cannon as Miss Ginch the town gossip. Great fun and a surprise ending. Plus with Dennis Price and Esma Cannon, what's not to like?
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
What Are Police And Defense Counsel For?
boblipton9 February 2020
Pamela Alan is to hang for murdering her husband. Cousin Dennis Price comes in from Uganda and proposes to find the real murderer with the help of Rona Anderson, Miss Alan's stepdaughter.

Wolf Rilla's first feature feature after toiling for a decade in the BBC's television division is a rather straightforward mystery in which Price proposes to prove that the British justice system has gotten it all wrong with the skeptical help of police sergeant George Merritt. This includes all the traditional appurtenances of such stories, including the scene where he gathers all the suspects together. He has little trouble accumulating two additional corpses and several people with some excellent motives and opportunities. This makes one wonder what the police and the defense had been doing.

Rilla handwaves this away, and deals with the endless talking and the help of Walter J. Harvey's gracefully moving camera. The result is a good, if unexceptional murder movie although I suspected the actual murderer about halfway through. There were enough decent red herrings to keep me in doubt until the revelation.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An historically necessary film
jromanbaker26 March 2020
This is a neat thriller. The acting is good, and what's more important is that it is 1953 and Capital Punishment is the focus of the film. It was good to show back then that there were innocent men and women being executed in this country. On the surface it does not attack the system, but in one essential way it does. If an innocent person is executed, then it puts to shame the whole concept of murder by state murder. Also 1953 was one of the most appalling years in UK judicial history. Homosexual men were rounded up as never before and imprisoned, and state execution was considered ' normal ' by most so-called decent people. It was a brave act to make this film and to make a basically indifferent public aware that the wrong person could be caught and hanged. The Craig/Bentley case posed many questions, but it took Ruth Ellis to realise that Capital Punishment was a crime in itself. In the more enlightened Sixties both Homosexuality and Capital punishment showed many in the public that new laws were needed and death by execution was abolished and homosexuality was partly decriminalised. This film was a step forward, and the anguish on the condemned woman's face speaks volumes. For this alone and her acting it is worth seeing, and to reflect on how much was wrong back in the Fifties. Wolf Rilla keeps the pace going, and all within one hour and sixteen minutes. Not great, but necessary.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A delightful and tense whodunit.
geoffm6029521 August 2019
Dennis Price plays the urbane and English gentleman on leave from colonial Uganda where he is a district commissioner. However, when he goes to visit his cousin in a quaint English village, he finds to his horror that she is in prison, waiting to be hanged for poisoning her husband. The storyline is very much in the same mould of an Agatha Christie crime novel, with Price playing the sleuth, investigating all the potential suspects in the village. I enjoyed this low budget film as the acting is first rate and the dialogue is convincing, albeit somewhat dated for today's audiences. The ending of the film is rather theatrical and staged, as Price gathers all the suspects in one room stating that one of them is the murderer. However, despite this cliched scene, it's a film that is well worth watching just to see the incomparable Dennis Price in a role where he doesn't play the villain.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Poison two birds with one stone."
DoorsofDylan23 December 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Staying overnight in Manchester with a friend in order to see an excellent staging of Let the Right One In, we decided to watch some TV before leaving the hotel for the theater. Finding a film on Talking Pictures was about to begin, we got ready to meet the lady.

View on the film:

Made at a time when capital punishment was still taking place in the UK, Rex Rienits holds this adaptation of Gerald Verner's novel with one hand on a compact murder mystery, and the other on a critical stance towards the death penalty, via a tightly coiled ticking time bomb fueling the need for Gale (played with a real charm by Dennis Price) to solve the case, before the wrongly convicted Margaret is killed.

Whilst proceedings are handled in a slightly dry, stage-bound manner, Rienits clearly uses Gale's wrong assumptions on the identity of the killer, to subtly give the audience a false perception in the dialogue of who the murderer is, who gets revealed by Rienits with a cup of tea.

Making his first theatrical feature film after working at the BBC for a number of years, director Wolf Rilla & Stolen Assignment (1955-also reviewed) cinematographer Walter J. Harvey boil up an elegant mystery atmosphere of overlapping dissolves and stylish close-ups on Gale, who frees Margaret from the shadow of the noose.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Formulaic whodunnit
johnshephard-8368221 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Promising, but ultimately disappointing, village-set Agatha Christie-style murder mystery with Dennis Price in the role of the amateur sleuth trying to uncover clues that will spare his cousin from imminent execution for the murder of her husband. Price's investigations not only meet with no objections from the geriatric local bobby - who actively encourages him to nose about - he is also assisted by doctors who divulge confidential patient information to this complete stranger, and villagers with long-hidden dark secrets who readily confess them to him under the slightest duress of his urbane questions. We even get the final Poirot-style gathering of the suspects in the living room, in which he unmasks the killer, having uncovered evidence that the original police inquiry bafflingly failed to find. Afterwards, Price declares his love for a woman he has known for three days, and it all ends happily ever after. Standard fare for its day, and watchable if you overlook the implausibility of it all.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ticks the boxes
Leofwine_draca20 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
NOOSE FOR A LADY is a rather typical murder mystery of the era, one that goes through the motions while perhaps lacking the kind of gravitas that the best of the genre tends to have. What is nice is seeing Dennis Price playing a good guy rather than the usual caddish or sleazy characters he essayed during this era (and beyond). He plays the cousin of a condemned woman, fresh from hunting criminals in Uganda, who visits a number of suspects as he tries to solve the murder case that could see his own flesh and blood led to the gallows. A well-judged supporting cast allows for nice performances from Esma Cannon, a shifty Charles Lloyd Pack and farmer Robert Brown, and it certainly succeeds as a box-ticking enterprise.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A neat thriller
martinepstein3 June 2019
A really neat little thriller, the story plays fair and the killer comes as a real surprise. The cast work well together and Dennis Price is a reliable lead as the solver of the crime. Well worth 90 minutes of your time.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
RUBBISH TITLE FOR A VERY GOOD FILM
francespen26 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The title could have put many off but if they had stuck with it they would not have been disappointed - I wasn't. We do have to remember when it was set so need to ignore the fact most of the folk were upper middle class and looked down on others like Rigg. Dennis Price was believable as the cousin of the accused having shrugged off his cad image, though not sure he could have got away with some of his actions nowadays, he was very bullying towards Vanessa and Upcott, he caused his stroke and the sergeant just stood there. John Hallam would nowadays be classed as a sociopath and it would have been interesting to know how he found out all those secrets. The big surprise for me was having the lovely Esma Cannon as a vicious, nasty gossip who had abandoned her sister who had fallen by the wayside. She certainly was cast against type as she normally played timid little souls always being bullied by Peggy Mount. Very Miss Marple/Hercule Poirot ending with the 'usual' suspects gathered in one room. I have to admit it did come to me who had done it part the way through. I did guess what Upcott's secret was and Vanessa and her aunts. Nothing to do with the film or course but Simon Gale bigging up Uganda does now seem out of place, but back then it was OK if you were white and in a good job like he was. You felt you ought to warn him to make the most of it.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed