User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Classic Is A Work That Is Much Admired And Never Seen
boblipton18 May 2019
When a politician comes by the house to solicit Chic Sales' vote for congressman, Chic tells him what happened to his son, crippled in the war, using the words of Irving Bacheller's poem, which the opening titles declare is a post-War classic. I suppose that it's the First World War that refers to. By the time I was in school, a quarter of a century had passed, 'Post-War' meant after the Second World War, and I never heard of this poem until now. Sales' delivery lacks the tempo we associate with recited poetry, although there's no doubt where the line breaks occur.

Mr. Sales was 53 when this movie came out, and was one of the experts at playing old.. He hit the movies in the 1920s, first with Christie, but became MGM's resident Rural Coot in the 1930s available to play Civil War veterans and grandfathers. He died in 1936, aged 51.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful, charming and very moving.
AFTRA-226 February 2002
A wonderful performance by Chic Sale. A very moving and charming interpretation of a slightly maudlin poem. Though only 48 at the time, Sale's elderly farmer is a delight to watch. Let me also say I enjoyed the scenery. It appears to have been probably shot in the San Gabriel Valley.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Whisperin Bill is Not Even Remembered Correctly by Its Fans
steve-974-6981359 November 2011
Three stars because this short is about the only time you will ever see a movie about a city slicker who wanders upon a friendly countrified farmer with an armed and mentally challenged son without it turning into a horror flick.

Whisperin Bill was written by a guy, Irving Bacheller, who did tons for American literature, but his writings, and this poem, are a very small part of his legacy.

Bacheller had a long, varied and distinguished career. Yes, he wrote some books that were popular at the time, but his body of work can only be described nowadays as "obscure." He comes to light every couple of years when a college student will say "Hey, who is the guy this building is named after? However, the list of foreign authors he introduced to America was impressive. Also, he was the champion of the struggling Stephen Crane. Bacheller was able to do that because he started the first newspaper syndicate.

He did not write Whisperin Bill during the Civil War. He was two when the war started and seven when it ended. Most likely, he penned the poem during or after his time as a war correspondent in France during World War I.

Will Rogers could be folksy and talk like us common folk. That's because he was. Bacheller was never considered "folksy." His poem is a clumsy attempt to talk like us poor uneducated souls.

Well, shut my mouth and call me taterhead, but I ain't buying it.

Forget this short and forget the poem that inspired it. If Bacheller is to be remembered, it should be for the remarkable way he transformed American media.

Sho nuf.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fair Short
Michael_Elliott16 November 2009
Whisperin' Bill (1933)

** (out of 4)

Decent short from MGM has a Congressman visiting an elderly farmer (Charles 'Chic" Sale) and asking for his vote. The farmer then wants to make sure the man knows his son and begins to tell him the famous "Whisperin' Bill" poem. This short certainly has its heart in the right place but I must say that it really didn't hit me as I'm sure it was meaning to. I had to look up the actual poem, which was apparently a very famous one released shortly after the Civil War. The poem is certainly brought up to date in this film but it just didn't work for me. I think the biggest problem is the rather bland and lackluster direction, which results in a pretty tame looking film that falls flat in terms of anything interesting on the technical level. It appears even the supporting actors is falling asleep as he's walking around without much to do and the scenery didn't work either. Sale's does a pretty good job as he really digs into the poem and turns in a fine performance but his soul alone isn't enough to make the short work.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed