User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Great detail from cast and crew.
Anonymous_Maxine27 January 2005
The Making of Sands of Iwo Jima goes into great detail about who starred in the movie and who some of the main crew members were, presumably because so little on set footage exists. A surprising number of the original cast appear in interviews in this short documentary to talk about their experiences making the movie. Leonard Maltin also goes into detail about the military atmosphere at the time the movie was released, giving valuable insight into its relevance. It seems that in the late 1940s the Marine Corps itself was in danger of being eliminated, seen as unnecessary because of other organizations like the Army. In fact, one of the reasons that Wayne did the movie was to help the Marines. They were badly in need of a PR boost at the time and they certainly got it from this film, which was tremendously popular and successful.

There are interesting tidbits revealed by one of the men who appeared in the film about John Wayne's acting, such as the way he always hesitates slightly when he's making so he can get himself four or five feet of film. This guy turned himself into a star in more ways than just his acting skills! His son also makes an appearance in this documentary, talking about his father and his own relations to some of the men involved with the film.

We also learn in this documentary that a lot of Sands of Iwo Jima was filmed at Camp Pendleton in San Diego, the extensive beach of which was used for many of the battle scenes. There are details revealed about methods used by the special effects team to achieve the appearance of full scale battle, which is actually one of the weak parts of the film, although was great for 1949.

Some interesting facts are revealed as well, such as the fact that lots of Marines were enlisted from Camp Pendleton to appear in the film, and the original flag and three of the original six guys who erected the flag on Mt. Surabachi also appear in the film, which garnered John Wayne his first Oscar nomination.

The film ultimately became sort of a recruiting film for the Marines, who evidently capitalized on the movie's popularity. One of the few things that I didn't like about this documentary was that it ended with a dramatic slow motion American flag waving in the wind and filling the whole screen. Not that I have anything against the flag, obviously, but it overemphasizes a point that is already very strongly made. There's no need to smack the viewer over the head with the patriotism that the movie and this documentary celebrate. All in all, though, this is an entertaining and informative documentary.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This supplemental short documentary . . .
oscaralbert10 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
. . . features several cast members from the feature film being retroactively examined, SANDS OF IWO JIMA. Some of them appear amazingly young, considering the 58-year span between SANDS filming and its 2007 DVD release (which included this "extra"). Richard Jaeckel (Frank Flynn) is particularly young and chipper looking, making one ponder whether he was a precociously mature six-year-old when he played his part in SANDS, or whether he's the living embodiment of novelist Oscar Wilde's Dorian Gray. It turns out that if you can read the fine print in the credits at the end of this celebratory exercise, and if you had the elite education necessary to decipher Roman Numerals ("MCMXCIII," in this case--which should be simplified to MXMIII, as far as I'm concerned), this mislabeled "Making of" ACTUALLY was 14 years old by the time Republic Pictures and Artisan Video slapped it on the 2007 SANDS release. ("Film Historian" Leonard Maltin's appearance is hardly a useful clue, given the truism, "Old critics never die, they just get lost in translation.")
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed