Palais royal! (2005) Poster

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Both funny and serious, but a bit too vulgar
guy-bellinger23 December 2005
When you look at the actress playing Armelle, an ordinary speech therapist inadvertently married to a prince, when you consider her shapeless body, her unappealing face, her unbecoming clothing style you just can't believe she is the same Valérie Lemercier who found the energy necessary to write this story, to convince producers to give her enough money to make this lavish-looking movie, to allow her to film it in three different countries, with a stellar cast, including Catherine Deneuve in a royal but self-mocking role, and, to crown it all, featuring herself as the leading lady...! But when the ugly duckling starts rebelling against the silly etiquette that stifles her and against the falseness masked by fairy tale appearances, slowly blossoming into a slick, elegant, attractive, self-assertive young lady, you suddenly realize that Valérie Lemercier is not cast against type. Just like real life humorist Valérie Lemercier, Armelle has become go ahead, dynamic and capable, refusing to be manipulated, commenting on her social environment with biting humor.

"Palais Royal!", her third work as a director, is a comedy, but there is more to it than that. It is also - and most of all- a sharp satire of life at court, denouncing its silly etiquette as well as all the meanness, the falseness and the hidden vulgarity inherent in such regimes.In great part inspired by the doomed destiny of Diana, princess of Wales, the film makes the viewer understand better the Via Dolorosa Diana had to go through before her untimely death. But, thanks to comedy, Lemercier does it avoiding the heavy-handed pathos of a soap.

The actors are all excellent. I will single out a few, like Catherine Deneuve, perfect as the callous queen, Lambert Wilson as the new king not exactly killing himself at his royal task, Michel Aumont as the would-be dignified chief of protocol and Michel Vuillermoz as pathetic prince Alban, ruled out from the throne for "testicule reasons".

The only shortcoming I would deplore is the excessive vulgarity Lemercier indulges in. Of course she means to expose this defect among people who have exquisite manners while on official duty and who let themselves go as soon as they are away from the limelight, but this viewer feels that she derives pleasure in being graphic. Such complacency slightly reduces the impact of the satire. Billy Wilder and Ernst Lubitsch who have often been accused of the same leaning for vulgarity knew where to draw the line though.

Whatever, all in all, a film well worth seeing.
18 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Elaborate,, sometimes vulgar and slapstick, but mostly fluffy comedy
Chris Knipp12 March 2006
PALAIS ROYAL!

The opening night movie of a well-attended film series tends to be something lightweight and a bit glitzy that's designed to be a deliberate crowd-pleaser, and the gala opener of the 2006 Rendez-Vous with French Cinema Today at Lincoln Center -- a film featuring Catherine Deneuve as a haughty queen mother -- is an elaborate, sometimes vulgar and slapstick, but mostly fluffy comedy about a principality like Monaco or Luxembourg and the things that happen when its ruler suddenly dies. The late king's spoiled second son ascends to the throne bypassing his more serious, well-educated older brother because the latter isn't married. Arnaud's do-gooder wife (played by the writer/director, French comic Valérie Lemercier, a popular French comedienne more known in the US for starring in Claire Denis's well received and serious sexual adventure Friday Night/Vendredi soir).

Lemercier's character gradually turns into an ambitious new princess like Lady Di, and along with general laugh-manufacture, the film constitutes a satire on such behavior and the packaging and promoting of modern-day high-visibility "royals." There is no faulting the actors, and Deneuve is as droll as she's elegant, Lambert Wilson is stylish as the lazy new king, Michel Aumont is imposing as the chief of protocol and Michel Vuillermoz is appealing as the sad elder prince. But though Palais Royal! moves as rapidly as a comedy should, it's a bit hard to be interested in this theme at a time when people are starving and being tortured and real social gaps are between rich and poor, with a feudal aristocracy no longer a real issue.

We begin with future king, wife, and two best friends on a shopping spree in London, and there is nothing to like about these spoiled people – which of course is the point; and the French are good at doing grumpy, obnoxious snobs (Pierre Bakri in last year's Look at Me/Comme une image is a splendid example) – but this makes it hard to stay interested in these folks. It's also hard to read the subtitles, and I couldn't follow the fast "comic" dialogue. Probably only the French people in Alice Tully Hall were able to find that dialogue consistently funny, and only some of THEM. Clearly there was a lot of word-play that the subtitles, when one could read them, obviously was struggling to convey.

The glitzy fluff was there, there was fluency in the flow of the action, there was a satirical point of view, there were highly regarded actors. If it was hard to sit through this and make it to the wine and cheese and French celebrities, but since I was gearing up to watch all fifteen handpicked new French films in a row it still seemed like a pretty soft job.

(Rendez-Vous with French Cinema 2006 opening night presentation, March 2006; Palais Royal! opened in Paris November 23, 2005.)
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Royals behaving badly
marissas759 February 2007
Warning: Spoilers
"Palais Royal," a French satirical comedy about modern-day royalty, is the product of one woman who wears three hats: writer/director/star Valérie Lemercier. She's written herself a pretty good role—a frumpy mom named Armelle, who, due to a legal loophole, becomes queen of a European country—and shows off an appealing comic talent. However, the movie itself is neither as sharp nor as funny as it wants to be, coming off as fluff rather than meaningful satire.

In the movie, Armelle's husband Arnaud (Lambert Wilson) just happens to be the younger son of a monarch, and he inherits the throne after his father dies. The new Princess Armelle is at first bumbling and naïve, but when she discovers that Arnaud is cheating on her, she decides to take revenge, embarrassing her husband in private and getting a glamorous makeover to win over the public. Lemercier is successful as both the dowdy and chic Armelle —she knows how to write a character for herself.

Armelle's story has obvious parallels to Princess Diana's—not least of which is that Armelle dies in tragic circumstances when she is at the peak of her popularity. (This isn't really a spoiler: the film begins with Armelle's funeral, then flashes back.) "Palais Royal" wants us to see this as its final satirical coup; however, it comes across as a desperate way to end the movie. Instead of letting all the comic sub-plots play out logically, Lemercier just kills off her main character.

Most unforgivably, the movie wastes Catherine Deneuve, who plays Queen Mother Eugénia. Deneuve looks elegant as always but doesn't have much to do except act disapproving and haughty. At one point it looks like "Palais Royal" will focus on the "Devil Wears Prada"-ish relationship between Eugénia and Armelle, but it drops this angle in favor of Armelle's revenge on Arnaud. Thus begins a lot of practical jokes and slapstick humor, including a few attempts at the old pie-in the-face gag. Intermittently amusing, but also quite easily forgettable.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lady Di a la francaise
drobadan27 July 2006
A great reinvention of the story of life and death of lady Diana Spencer. It takes place in imaginary French-speaking country of Western Europe. after the accidental death of the king his younger son has to take his place which makes his wife - a speech therapist Armelle, the potential queen. The current queen, francophone re-incarnation of Queen Elizabeth II (minus UGLY part), played by magnificent Catherine Deneuve, is not sure that this plain-looking awkward woman can bear the royal duties with dignity and clearly doesn't care about her. After series of misadventures, Armelle feels like she doesn't fit in the royal world and when she discovers her husband adultery, she decides to take revenge. She'll show them all who is the real queen of hearts! This comedy makes you laugh and cry. Catherine Deneuve looks stunning and parades in a real fashion show of outfits, wearing them with truly royal grace. The parallels with Lady Di story are in-your-face, but rather charming, because they are put in the continental French-speaking milieu.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
hilarious but flawed
myriamlenys11 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The movie tells the story of Armelle, who lives a quiet and useful life until the day her husband (who has royal blood) suddenly becomes first in line to inherit the throne. This is an unexpected development, as the prince has an older brother who was considered the more logical candidate. Armelle's life becomes, if not hell, at least purgatory : she has to give up her job, fritter away her energy on meaningless ceremonies and look ravishing every single moment of the day, even when suffering from jet lag or culture shock. No help is to be expected from her husband, who was spoiled rotten by his mother, the coldly vicious queen Eugenia.

Poor Armelle is mocked, judged, betrayed and humiliated wherever she goes. Will she remain a victim - or will she find the confidence and the means to fight back ?

There is much to like in this comedy. Lemercier clearly did her homework and much of the satire or parody is spot-on, complete with fine sartorial details concerning royal fashion do's and don't's. Her own performance as Armelle is excellent, too. The movie also asks a number of astute questions about our continuing fascination with royalty and about media phenomena such as "people's princesses".

A number of the outdoor scenes were shot in my own city, Mechelen (which you may know as Malines). The city, and especially its splendid cathedral, looks good enough to eat. (Thank you Mrs. Lemercier and remember, you're always welcome !) In real life, of course, Mechelen has often been visited by kings and queens, which adds a nice layer of meta to the movie.

Sadly the movie is marred by some vulgar jokes and lazy plot twists. The ending, too, might have benefited from some tighter editing and better writing.

A pleasant movie, but sadly not a masterpiece.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A bit long, but witty
XeniaGuberman14 September 2007
This is, of course, a comedy. So, let's talk funny: three testicles theme, the whole Deneuve character, the opening London sequence, personal trainer guy - very funny. The whole thing is a bit long, but quite enjoyable. I'm just wondering if they also ridicule the Belge (the only French-speaking continental people with royalty), as it goes along, but I don't know French enough to catch the nuances. One interesting quality - since it is a poke at the English, the humour is very held-back (not the usual French buffonade), easily the "English gentlemen"-like comic routine, perfectly in line with stuff like the "Stiff upper lip". I guess it is THE stylistic gimmick used here, apart from the obvious Diana satire, to our delight.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A huge disappointment
languedoc-586-83602824 August 2019
Reviewer destinationssecretes sums it up well: vulgar and rogue. And pedestrian... Deneuve is excellent though. Lemercier can be pretty funny if directed well, that is obviously here, not by her own self...
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Makes up in performance and comic mischief what it lacks in visuals and verisimilitude
n-mo12 March 2019
Palais royal! is a fun little satire of royal courtly life loosely based on the tragic tale of Charles and Diana. Valérie Lemercier casts herself in the titular role of Armelle, the improbable and frumpy orthophonist wife of royal Prince Arnaud (Lambert Wilson) of some fictional generic Francophone European kingdom. Suddenly her father-in-law dies, and her brother-in-law Alban - Arnaud's elder - is rudely passed over for want of children, as required by the kingdom's fundamental laws. Arnaud becomes king regnant and Armelle queen consort, and much to her consternation their happy and privileged but marginal life gives way to the full and taxing burdens of official duties and, of course, nasty courtly intrigues. When she realizes just how close to home these intrigues hit, Armelle transforms almost overnight, subtly planting traps exposing the two-facedness of those around her (including her two-timing husband as well as the vicious Queen Mother incarnated by Catherine Deneuve), all the while endearing herself to the people.

As Guy Bellinger says, her antics are a bit vulgar in and of themselves and this tempers the satire somewhat. And her metamorphosis is just a bit rapid. Nevertheless, even with the vulgarity I think they've managed to capture - albeit somewhat unintentionally - the full spectrum of Lady Di's own flaws, antics and resentments in an analogous, less beautiful and less glamorous but every bit as much energetic leading lady. The interiors of the royal couple's living spaces did, I must opine, leave much to be desired: at some points I felt I was looking at a flyer for a new subdivision of North American McMansions. The substance was a bit thin aganst the backdrop of what I know about royal protocol and life in general, although I didn't see any one thing I would deem "inaccurate" - just perhaps a bit reductionist or incomplete.

It's entertaining, however, and worth seeing for the performances. If you don't sympathize with the characters despite their obvious flaws, though, it will be difficult to sit through to the end (which does, I feel, come a bit quick).
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The worst movie ever in the whole galaxy
destinationssecretes28 December 2006
Awful, awful, and awful ! Even worse than " Brice of Nice" ... Even worse than " Arbres" ... Not even a glimpse of interest ! Vulgar, rogue, ... The only consolation I had was to see it on a DVD . Wasting ten dollars for such a crap in a theater would have been just unbearable !!!!!! I you want to see a Valerie Lemercier at her best, pass your way on Palais Royal and try to find the one and only " The Visitors" DVD one of my funniest movies! Actually, speaking of "Palais Royal", I really don't understand how such good actors like Denis Podalydes or Valerie Lemercier herself have accepted to play in such a movie. Oh, sorry, I was forgetting : Valerie Lemercier is the Director ! As a lesson, good actors don't always mean good film makers.

MutantMutton
6 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Royal Flush
writers_reign25 December 2005
Those of us who found the much-vaunted albeit slightly dubious charm of Princess Diana terminally elusive will revel in this delicious satire in which writer-director Valerie Lemercier captures perfectly that faux demureness and all too real touch of the retard about Diana. Lemercier, who is much more lovely and desirable than Diana ever was, is right on the nose with her characterisation developing it naturally from the gauche, naive speech therapist who lucked into a Prince (Lambert Wilson)who, as the second son - shades of 'Bertie' aka George the Sixth - had no realistic claim to the throne but did have an elder brother who might be a Prince but would never make sperm Count so that when the King dies unexpectedly Wilson finds himself the new reigning Monarch and Lemercier by extension becomes Queen. Ever-so-slowly the moth becomes a social butterfly and Lemercier's genius is that she can makes us wince/reach for the sick-bag as Armelle is incapable of passing a Black child or a Senior Citizen without summoning the photographers and posing winsomely, yet sympathize with her rebellion against Royal protocol/chastisement as personified and practiced by Catherine Deneuve's Queen and Michel Aumont's Brother-in-law. The scene where Armelle gets a custard pie in the kisser will resonate with all those who longed to hurl just such a missile at the 'Queen of Hearts' as will many other scenes. By now, of course, I've lost half my readers but I urge the other half to seek out this gem as soon as possible.
16 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
a great comedy
singletonscrib2 January 2006
First of all, I am a huge fan of Valérie Lemercier! She's been entertaining us for nearly 20 years and she's still surprising us yet. "Palais Royal !" is her third work as a director, and it is the funniest. Her previous two efforts were good, but with this one, she proves herself as a great writer.

The storyline is very simple : After the King dies, her husband (played by the always classy Lambert Wilson) is destined to take the crown, and her to become part of a world she doesn't really know of. As you can see, the plot is very basic, but what shows Lemercier's cleverness is her ability to laugh at the clichés and the explore every little details of her characters. Her screenplay is full of subtle jokes and plays of words - some can regret that a few jokes are a bit... vulgar, but always very funny if you can understand the double meanings.

As for the actors, we have a royal cast here: Queen Catherine Deneuve (who's never been so funny), the sarcastic Michel Aumont and the hilarious Gilbert Melki, among others (all are very good). Last but not least, Valerie Lemercier shows us one more time she's a gifted actress by handling all the versatility of her character.

"Palais Royal !" is the best French comedy of the year !
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
All credits go to Valérie Lemercier for having directed one of French cinema's best comedy films in recent times
FilmCriticLalitRao8 May 2013
If a list of the most underrated personalities of French cinema is drawn,Valérie Lemercier would easily figure in it with veteran director Patrice Leconte. About Valérie Lemercier it can be said that she never ceases to amuse critics and viewers in equal measure. Watching her films as an actress as well as a director, one get the feeling that she is not as dumb as she prefers to get depicted. She proves this assertion in her film "Palais Royal". Most people view comedy as a frivolous activity which does not interest serious people. This fallacy is vigorously challenged by leading French actress/director Valérie Lemercier as she establishes that comedy is a highly serious business which can be an enormous aid too in getting key issues heard by a large section of the society. As a comedy film, "Palais Royal" is an innocuous assault on the whims and fancies of a royal family whose members suffer from numerous ethical as well as moral weaknesses. Audiences get to see how the members of a royal family are normal human beings with decent share of vices as well as virtues. Although the film might have been covertly influenced by the travails of the English royal family, incidents and situations portrayed in this film are products of an original scenario.Lastly, apart from Lambert Wilson and Valérie Lemercier, actors such as Mathilde Seigner, Gilbert Melki and Catherine Deneuve do give proper attention to their roles.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed