(TV Series)

(1961)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Fourth Survivor out of 1, 800 + men?
theowinthrop14 October 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This episode is another of the interference of the supernatural in the lives of people involved in tragic events that appear fairly regularly on ONE STEP BEYOND. It actually rivals the stories about Lincoln's Assassination, Krackatoa, the San Francisco Earthquake, and the Titanic.

People recall the voyage of Hitler's mightiest battleship, SMS BISMARCK, in May 1941, in the most famous and fatal maiden/final voyages in the history of naval warfare. Hitler never had a really good grasp on naval strategy, and wasted a truly remarkable battleship on a cruise to see if Bismarck would be a good commerce raider. With the strength of her hull and plating, her firepower, and her speed, Bismarck should have been at the center of a might fleet of battleships and cruisers like the Tirpitz (wasted for most of the war in Norway's fjords), the Schleswig-Holstein, and whatever other large scale craft he could have gotten together. Then the Royal Navy might have had substantial problems. Instead it was accompanied for only two thirds of it's cruise by the battle cruiser Prinz Eugen. Still it did do one notable piece of damage: it sank H.M.S. Hood, Britain's largest and most famous battleship, off the coast of Iceland. Of the crew of 1,800, only three men survived that icy water (more lives were lost on the Hood and on the Bismarck when it was sunk than on the Titanic and Lusitania combined).

The story here is about how the crew of the Hood are given partial liberty just before the Bismarck leaves on it's cruise. We concentrate on three men: Johnny Watson (Mark Eden), Breed (Terry Palmer), and Robin Hughes (Richard Gale). These three men are seamen on Hood, and go to their homes for their leave. But when they are all at home, Watson and Breed and their families hear the news on the radio that the Hood has been sunk with all hands. Naturally they both check into this, and find it is still in port at Scapa Flow. Hughes does not hear this news, but receives better information about his future. Apparently he is going to live to be very old. Then news comes that leaves have been canceled because of the Bismarck leaving port. All three men go back to their ship, Watson and Breed both nervous about the peculiar false radio report of the disaster. They mention it to Hughes, who is surprised. They reach the gangplank to board Hood, when a naval officer approaches and tells Hughes that he is being reassigned to a land office. He turns to his two mates, and they look like they've seen the angel of death just stamp their documents. Never-the-less they board the doomed vessel.

Here comes the surprise: At the end of the episode we are told that only three sailors survived the icy waters off Iceland when Hood was sunk. But John Newland introduces us to the real Robin Hughes. Hughes, an actor by profession, verifies that in reality he was an unofficial fourth survivor of the Hood's crew, as he was not supposed to be on board at the last moment before it left port on it's fatal cruise. How true this is I can't vouch for it. I have looked over Philip's career, and he was in several nautical films (including A NIGHT TO REMEMBER). But whether or not he actually was a member of the Hood's crew, and was luckily chosen to avoid that final cruise at the last minute is something I cannot answer. Good story though.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Mariner's intuition
Goingbegging5 October 2021
Three jolly sailors are aiming to make the most of their week's leave before joining the prestige battlecruiser HMS Hood on its dramatic mission to sink the Bismarck. But two of them are finding it hard to summon much jollity as they start to pick up intuitive signals of disaster ahead.

Johnny is listening to the radio news when he hears them announcing the loss of Hood - apparently impossible, as she couldn't have been refuelled in time to go out on operations. George's mother is suffering repeated dreams about a telegram with the fatal news. Only Robin feels untroubled, attending a séance where they foresee a long life for him.

This forecast is confirmed at the railway tearoom, as an old fortune-teller reads Robin's palm. But as she starts on George's, the train's whistle blows, and they have to rush off - leaving the old lady aghast at the future she has just seen for him. As they start to board the ship, Robin is suddenly told that he is being sent elsewhere on a course, and has to say good-bye to his shipmates.

As for what happened to Hood, that has gone down in history, so there's not much of a story to spoil here. Robin (Hughes) lives on to become a famous actor, and pops-up here as the guest of our narrator John Newland, looking very naval with his 'full set' neatly trimmed. Curiously his story directly matches that of another actor who had been a Hood crewman taken off the ship at the last moment - none other than the great Jon Pertwee.

Just for good measure, Robin Hughes explains that his Welsh blood has endowed him with Celtic intuition, and we end on some anecdotes about premonitions in his family life.

Just one quibble. George's mother mentions 'The First War', which they would actually have referred to as 'The Last War' until a good few years on from this 1941 story.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Tribute to HMS Hood
jr-565-263668 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this episode when it first aired and it was such a vivid episode that I still remember the details 57 years later. Three sailors from the battle-cruiser HMS Hood are on leave during WWII when they hear a radio report that their ship has been sunk. Checking with the watch officer, they find their ship is still in port at Scapa Flow undergoing refit. They later see a newspaper headline stating HMS Hood has been sunk.

Certain now they are seeing their future, the three sailors are suddenly recalled back to their ship for an urgent mission. However, one sailor receives orders immediately sending him to officer training and he bids a sad farewell to his shipmates.

At the end of the episode, Robert Newland introduces the sailor who missed the voyage to the audience, Robin Hughes. Then a reserve naval commander in the Royal Navy, he confirms the story as true. At the end of the episode, film footage of the mighty HMS Hood in her glory days is shown as a tribute to her heroic loss.

As every schoolboy of that time (1961) knew, HMS Hood was the pride and joy of England and served as the flagship of the Royal Navy. Her last voyage was in pursuit of the infamous German battleship Bismarck. HMS Hood was sunk by Bismarck when a shell hit her magazine, causing her to explode. There were only three survivors. As the HMS Hood's "fourth survivor", Robin Hughes was also a noted actor at the time who died in Los Angeles in 1989.

Episodes for the last season (1960-1961) of this series were filmed in England. Robert Newland convinced the producers to move filming there and to feature supernatural incidents that took place in England in the hope of improving ratings there. This was one of those episodes and one of the best and most memorable of this series.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed