"Combat!" No Trumpets, No Drums (TV Episode 1963) Poster

(TV Series)

(1963)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Falling Apart
claudio_carvalho5 July 2017
While fighting the Germans in a village, Caje feels movement in house and throws a grenade, killing an innocent Frenchman. The inconsolable Caje falls apart for his unforgiving act despite Saunders' advice. Caje neglects his duties and decides to seek out the family of the deceased villager that lived in a boat. Saunders meets Caje in the boat and out of the blue, the girl Micheline arrives. They learn that she is the daughter of the man and now is orphan. Caje dedicates his leave to play with Micheline and soon they are connected to each other. But Sgt. Saunders and the Germans bring Caje back to the reality of the war.

"No Trumpets, No Drums" is a heartbreaking episode of "Combat!". The dramatic situation of Caje, feeling guilty for the death of an innocent civilian, makes one of the saddest episodes of this first season when he meets the sweet Micheline that now is orphan. But the episode is realistically well resolved. My vote is nine.

Title (Brazil): "Nenhuma Trombeta, Nenhum Tambor" ("No Trumpets, No Drums")
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Superb Screen Writing, Acting, & Directing In A Combat Episode
jmarchese1 August 2014
"No Trumpets, No Drums" is a story of great sadness involving war orphan Micheline (brilliantly played by Andrea Darvi.) Caje is on a roll beating up Germans every step of the way when he accidentally kills another Frenchman. He immediately goes into shock and cannot stop blaming himself. Sergeant Saunders does a terrific job of trying to mitigate circumstances surrounding the death. But Caje is still going through guilt and feels he must spend time with Micheline, the Frenchman's daughter, to help her through it all. Ironically, this is one episode where total truth is not warranted, somewhat awkward.

Dialog between Saunders and Caje is terrific, a testament to great screen writing by Ed Lakso. Dialog & interaction between Caje and Micheline is also outstanding. The 3 actors take over the show big time; you hardly notice any of the others. Pierre Jalbert should have gotten an Emmy nomination for this one. In real life you could tell he has a way with children.

Heavy artillery and combat scenes are prolific and outstanding, a tribute to the great special effects of coordinator A.D. Flowers.

Richard Donner directed a real gem in his only Combat credit. Scenes are very graphic and almost seem as though they could tell the story without words.

"No Trumpets, No Drums" is an emotionally moving episode guaranteed to touch anyone with a heart. And extremely well done! Great way to end the first season of the Combat series.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"If you don't stop taking this personally you're gonna destroy yourself"
nickenchuggets14 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Once again, I find myself writing about another episode of Combat when, earlier today, I wanted to review something else I have a lot of feelings for. I have to do this though because this episode is so brilliantly made that I can't put off discussing it for even one day. In this extremely riveting episode, we are finally afforded the opportunity to see Caje, the squad's only French speaking member, becoming the main focus. The episode begins with the squad embroiled in a large and chaotic gun battle set in a town. The fighting is savage. House to house, and room by room. In the heat of the moment, Caje throws a grenade through the window of a house, only to find there are no Germans in there. A french civilian gets in the way of the explosion and is killed. Saunders and some other men later find Caje in a state of shock over what he has done, and he has the telltale, unfocused gaze of a soldier who's seen too many things he didn't want to. Because Caje has accidentally killed someone the same ethnicity as him, it weighs him down heavily, but this isn't even the tip of the iceberg. Later, Caje comes to a houseboat docked in a river where he finds a bottle of alcohol and a kind of music box that features a miniature couple dancing. He tries to relax here for a while until Saunders shows up. Saunders, at first, attempts to sympathize with what Caje is having to deal with, since he knows how difficult this can be. He's had many people serving under him get killed, but tells Caje he can't put the blame on himself or it's going to destroy him inside. Shortly after, a young girl enters the houseboat, and Saunders recognizes her as the daughter of the man whom Caje killed earlier. Micheline, as she is called, has no idea what happened to her father, but she knows her mother was killed. Caje talks to her in french, and Saunders suggests Caje does the unthinkable and tell her what happened to her dad. He does, but doesn't say he was the one who killed him. It's still an incredibly difficult moment for the both of them. This starts a caring, but in the long run very destructive, relationship between Caje and Micheline (Andrea Darvi). Caje feels like it's his responsibility to make sure nothing happens to her, and it begins to interfere with his duties as a soldier. Hanley tells Saunders that he better get Caje to start obeying orders again instead of trying to comfort Micheline, or else he's going to face charges. Meanwhile, Caje spends as much time with Micheline as possible, almost like there is no war. Eventually, Saunders has had enough and he does something he didn't want to have to do. He tells Caje the squad can't wait any longer and they need him back at the front to fend off an imminent german attack. An old man has been found who is willing to take care of Micheline (for a price). As expected, Caje doesn't like the idea of leaving her in the care of someone who only wants money and not Micheline herself, so he tries to resist giving her up. Micheline is pried from his arms forcibly and given to the other guy, and Saunders lets Caje know getting this attached to her is his own fault. Back in the town, Caje has a small amount of time to feel sorry for himself before the attack starts, but Saunders, frustrated and out of compassion by this point, plainly tells him if anything happens to Micheline, he won't know about it. His only job is to stay behind Saunders and listen to orders, nothing else. The attack comes, and the squad fights just as hard as they did in the beginning of the episode. After reinforcements come up to drive the germans back, Caje unexpectedly gets his wish and sees that Saunders has retrieved Micheline for him. He still has to leave her in the care of the old man, but at least he got to say goodbye to her. Caje is also told that if he wasn't in the village, she could have died. This is it, the perfect Combat episode. I certainly didn't expect this level of quality from an episode so late into the season (the last episode of season 1 as a matter of fact), but it's a testament to how well written a lot of these shows are. There are so many different reasons to praise this episode. I really liked seeing Saunders undergo so much change in just one episode. He starts out understanding what Caje is going through, but quickly loses his patience when he realizes he can't get over what he did. The battle scenes at the beginning and end are greatly directed and really make you feel as if you're in a warzone. Unsurprisingly however, the best thing about the episode is how it portrays Caje, who for the first time, finally has an episode dedicated to just him. Pierre Jalbert shines bright in this episode, and his heartbreaking (and happy) interactions with Micheline steal the show. It's also worth noting I think this is the angriest Saunders has ever been in the show so far, and at someone who isn't Kirby, no less. During the scene where the squad is fighting in the town, and Caje wants to go back and save Micheline, Saunders hits him not once, but twice. Overall, I was really in awe of how great this episode turned out to be. Season 1 of this great show sure went out with a bang.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great episode
jayjerry7 April 2007
"No Trumpets, No Drums" is an involving story in which Caje (Pierre Jalbert) accidentally kills a French villager. Being of French descent himself, he's overwhelmed by feelings of guilt and grief. When he learns the villager left behind a young daughter, Caje takes her under his wing and develops a bond with her. Their scenes together are heart-wrenching. Jalbert is superb (and he looks rather a lot like Bruce Springsteen!), and Vic Morrow matches him as the voice of reason, Sgt. Saunders. Richard Donner does a fine job at the helm, with some impressive staging and camera movement. I haven't seen too many episodes of the series, but surely this ranks among the best. If not, I can't wait to see the best!
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The damages of the war on a touching storyline over distraught Caje!!
elo-equipamentos29 July 2023
On latest episodes the writers try put some compelling stories to relief the tension over war on the audience aiming for bring to the show how the characters face so brutality without any distress, o fine rerouting that pleased me and improving the offer.

A French small city are in strong attack of the allied against the Germans, on the fierce fight on any building , any corner or any house, meanwhile Caje tries kill a German soldier inside the empty house throwing a grenade killing accidently a French civilian man inside, hence Caje stays extremely distraught, blaming yourself to killed his own people, Sgt. Saunders has a hard task to overcame the damage, actually Caje has been forgot his assignment on Squad, letting Lt. Hanley upset.

Later he discovers the man living for fishing in a boat neaby, inside there Caje sees an old portrait where such man appears side by side with his wife and a little children, suddenly a little girl appears, Caje figures out thatshe is the daughter, the little Micheline told to him that her mother was killed by the Germans and asking for her father, Caje becomes attached with Micheline for all means.

In the meantime Lt. Hanley received orders that must drop out the city, leaving behind all French citizen at mercy of chance, Caje denies leave the town, advised by Sgt. Saunders that it wasn't a proper reason to dealing for the matter, it's a wartime, then came up a ultimate order that the squad must keeping there against the Germans on outskirts coming from to take the city, Caje gave another chance of atonement.

Touching episode of the damages of the war, wherever is utterly unpredictable, the little one Andrea Darvi as Micheline had a solid performance, together the soulful Pierre Jalbert they lift the episode into high level, worthwhile a look.

Thanks for reading.

Resume:

First watch: 2023 / How many: 1 / Source: DVD / Rating: 8.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sensitive approach
lor_12 July 2023
When Caje (Pierre Jalbert) accidentally kills a Frenchman during a battle with the Germans, he's consumed with guilt and needs to move on somehow, as he & his fellow platoon members still have a war to be fought.

Vic is faced with the dilemma of what to do when one of his soldiers has ceased to function in this personalized little story about the effect of war. In a highly dramatic scene, Caje tries to comfort the dead man's young daughter, but must tell her about her father's passing, making for a strong moment directed by future A-list filmmaker Richard Donner.

A rather maudlin segment of the usually action-oriented series, it provides a reflective side of the war's stories, while reinforcing the difficulties Vic has holding his little band of men together.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Caje Match
DrPhilmreview4 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This has to be Pierre Jalbert's best episode in the series. In this Caje accidentally kills a French civilian and is awash in guilt. Now some lesser shows might have made it turn out the dead man was really a German collaborator and got Caje off the hook that way, but not "Combat!".

Instead Caje discovers the man had a now orphaned daughter. He neglects his duty and sees only the duty of making it up to the girl and befriending her. It's Saunders job to get him back to being himself, the best man to put on point and a valuable member of the squad. The scenes between an increasingly frustrated Saunders and a mixed up Caje are very good.

Pierre Jalbert gets a lot to do in this episode playing guilt, shock, disillusionment and more. He does not fail or over do anything (though I thought the episode itself spent a little too much time with scenes of him trying to amuse the girl). It's a part that is usually reserved for whoever the week's big name guest star is.

It's too bad Jambert didn't get more opportunities in the series to do more real acting like this. He proved he could do it and that made for a very good episode..
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed