"Combat!" The Medal (TV Episode 1963) Poster

(TV Series)

(1963)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The Real Hero
claudio_carvalho19 June 2017
While crossing a cemetery, Lt. Hanley, Sgt. Saunders and their squad are surprised by a German tank and a heavy machine gun. They retreat but Privates D'Amato and Wharton, who are close friends, stay near the tank. D'Amato heads to the tank, kills the German soldiers and uses the machine gun to kill the German squad alone. However he is killed by the German commander that flees. When Wharton sees his friend dead, he goes crazy and discharges the machine gun on the German bodies. Lt. Hanley mistakenly gives the credit for killing the enemies to Wharton and recommends him to the Silver Star. Wharton does not tell the truth, but when the German commander is arrested, he is assigned to go with Sgt Saunders to deliver the prisoner to the intelligence. When Saunders leave the German with Wharton, he waits the right moment to blackmail the American soldier. But Saunders overhears the conversation and is suspicious of what Wharton can do to keep the medal.

"The Medal" is one of the best episodes of "Combat!" with another storyline of moral dilemma. The need of a hero to be an example to the squad and the need of a medal of a private with unrequited love to show to his former girlfriend are the ingredients of this story. The conclusion is moralist but works perfectly well. My vote is nine.

Title (Brazil): "A Medalha" ("The Medal")
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Truth Will Set You Free
jmarchese17 July 2014
"The Medal" imparts a fine lesson on the value of honesty, virtue, and human dignity.

Private Wharton (excellently played by Frank Gorshin) is best friends with Private Vincent D'Amato (excellently played by Joseph Campanella.) After being pinned down by a German tank, D'Amato decides to take on the tank using a sound strategy. In the process, he accomplishes a great deal but is severely wounded. After receiving a dear John letter, Private Wharton's ethics and morals go astray and he decides to take advantage of D'Amato's situation. When German Lieutenant Kohr (played by Ed Knight) is captured, the tables turn for Wharton and he must face his reality. In the end, Private Wharton pulls Saunders out of a bad jam and atones for his previous conduct.

I'm critical of the opening sequence in that the Germans would have nailed the right flank of the Americans instead of hiding in the bush. In addition, Director Stanley should have made the ambush appear much more real letting the Americans advance several more yards before allowing the Germans to open up on them. And why fire the 88 caliber cannon first giving 95 % of the Americans time to take significant cover ? In all fairness however, the opening combat sequence is still one of the most memorable in the history of the Combat TV series.

Character development throughout the episode is excellent. D'Amato has the most memorable scene; his facial expressions are priceless! Wharton intones some great verbiage in the ending sequence. Saunders has a sarcastic sequence with Wharton that reminds me of a typical Dragnet Sergeant Joe Friday aside.

Casting did a fine job in choosing Campanella and Gorshin; they both made the difference.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Right place at the wrong time
nickenchuggets26 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I've said it before but it should be repeated here: Combat is a series that has a great focus on bravery and what it means to be a hero in many of its episodes. In this installment, we see how some people can be tempted by the prestige that comes with being a hero, and how it can make them do something immoral. The Medal begins with Saunders and the squad under fire from a German tank. A soldier named Wharton (Frank Gorshin) and his squadmate D'Amato are tasked with clearing the way. D'Amato kills the German soldier manning the machine gun on the tank's turret and swings it around, gunning down a large amount of Germans in the process. Unfortunately, D'Amato is killed during the assault, headed by a German lieutenant. By the time Saunders reaches the tank, he (incorrectly) thinks that Wharton was the one responsible for taking out that enemy formation. Lieutenant Hanley recommends Wharton for an award (a silver star) due to "his" heroic actions, and even though Wharton knows they are making a mistake, he doesn't speak up. This is because he thinks receiving a medal will make his girlfriend back home think he's a war hero. Later on, Wharton and Saunders get an unexpected surprise when Lieutenant Kohrs, the same German officer responsible for leading the men who killed D'Amato, is captured and brought to the squad. Saunders immediately recognizes him. He decides to take Kohrs, along with Wharton, on a walk to a deserted street filled with abandoned houses and shops. After Saunders leaves Wharton alone with Kohrs for a bit, the German tries to convince Wharton to shoot himself in the leg so that he can get sent home. Wharton starts to consider his options, but Saunders reenters the room unexpectedly. Saunders gets rude with Wharton because he now seems aware of the fact that he is taking credit for something a dead comrade has done, but redeems himself a moment later when Kohrs tries to escape and Wharton shoots him. As Saunders and Wharton try to leave the area, they are ambushed by a platoon of Germans, and Saunders falls into some barbed wire. Badly wounded and unable to stand up, Wharton risks his life to go back and help him to safety. In spite of Wharton's deception earlier, the whole squad now knows he is a legitimate hero. Out of all the Combat episodes I have seen so far, I have to say this is probably the first that is not that amazing. I still enjoyed it, but I really hated to see Saunders disrespect Wharton towards the end like that. I really shouldn't say this, but it felt justified when he tripped into the barbed wire for mocking a serviceman just as courageous as he is. The captured German trying to tell Wharton it's a good idea to injure himself so he gets a free ride home might have been an interesting twist, but it didn't end up happening. Wharton might have thought it was a good idea at first, but ultimately, he chooses to stay on the battlefield to prove prestige isn't all he cares about. I say this episode is mediocre mainly because of how the gunfight between D'Amato and the Germans plays out early in the episode. D'Amato is able to effortlessly mow down scores of nazis because they're apparently too stupid to fire back from a covered position. They just literally run straight for him. It doesn't make much sense when you consider how US troops held German ones in such high regard due to their fighting skill. In any case, The Medal may not be one of this show's best, but it does show how winning awards isn't a measure of someone's bravery.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Frank shines
lor_5 August 2023
A very strong story benefits from top-notch casting of Frank Gorshin and Joseph Campanella in this "Combat!" episode.

An exciting battle has the Americans being mowed down by a German machine gun placement with a heroic effort by Joseph to take out the deadly gun, and then an entire squad of Germans charging forward, before he's taken out. His buddy Frank is too late to save him, and when he comes out of a coma he dies before he can speak.

The squad hails Gorshin as the hero and he fails to correct them. Rick decides to put Gorshin up for a Silver Star, but Vic disagrees that one man be singled out for honors.

Taking credit for something he didn't do provides Gorshin with a plum dramatic role and he's up to the occasion.

A well-telegraphed twist has an Italian officer captured, who witnessed the machine gun incident, and is ready to blackmail Frank for some suspenseful time as the inevitable other shoe waits to be dropped.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed