"Deadwood" A Lie Agreed Upon: Part I (TV Episode 2005) Poster

(TV Series)

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
"This camp can be forbidding to strangers."
Hey_Sweden21 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Seths' family (Anna Gunn of later 'Breaking Bad' fame & Josh Eriksson) are set to rejoin him in Deadwood, but they happen to arrive at a very bad time. Swearengen, on edge because of the precarious future of the camp, has been taunting Seth something fierce over his relationship with Alma, and a later confrontation had turned ugly & violent, with Dan, Sol, and Johnny also getting involved. Meanwhile, Cy reluctantly gives Joanie his blessing as she prepares to strike out on her own. (Some of the prostitutes who will be working for her were on the same stagecoach as Martha & William.)

This is quite a tense episode indeed, and it was likely inevitable that Seth & Al would come to blows at some point. But it is Powers Boothe as Cy who dominates the whole episode; he offers a real master class in subtle, restrained rage & menace. Even when he sends Joanies' prostitutes on their way, he makes the whole scene uncomfortable. (He vows that since Joanies' place, "Chez Ami", was funded with money that Eddie stole from him, that basically gives him the right to treat this new place as an investment.)

The whole cast is on fire in this episode, to be sure: Timothy Olyphant & Ian McShane are also great. Seth is really starting to take center stage now, and at the end it's extremely telling that even though he has welcomed Martha & William into his home, he'd rather be with Alma, to whom he's obviously become quite attached.

As I've said before, this series intrigued me from the start by casting some of the best character actors in Hollywood, and creating such a compelling ensemble. Some of the regular cast members get a boost in billing this second season, as they are included in the opening credits sequence. (It was wonderful to see veteran actress Alice Krige turn up in a small but interesting role; a future star, Sarah Paulson, plays the little girls' tutor.)

Eight out of 10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
worth it to watch Powers Boothe steal the whole episode
A_Different_Drummer8 January 2015
... which is no mean feat in a "western" that features such strong actors and piercing dialog.

In earlier reviews of Season 1 I flagged when McShane wrapped up entire scenes and walked away with them, gift-wrapped. I flagged when one of the Carradine brothers did a "Wild Bill" as good as or better than any of the full-length Hollywood spectacles that have been done on the man.

And in my review of the last episode of Season 1, I complimented Milch and his team for allowing Olyphant to reach his stride and "come from behind" to walk away with that one.

As a stand-alone dramatic episode, you could argue that this opener drags a mite, but that is to be expected in any episode with the words "Part I" in the title.

The treat however is watching Powers Boothe in action. If you check out the credits for the whole series, you will see that Boothe's agent negotiated a special credit for him at the end of the off-the-top roll. The reason he could do that is because Boothe isn't just any old TV actor, look him up on IMDb, he is a former A-lister from the feature side who was, we now know, kept in reserve for occasions just like this one.

Stunning to watch.
18 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed