"Gunsmoke" One Killer on Ice (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Don't Mess with Matt Dillon!
wdavidreynolds5 January 2021
John Drew Barrymore--son of John Barrymore, nephew of Lionel and Ethel Barrymore, and father of Drew Barrymore--provides a memorable, standout performance in this intriguing episode.

Barrymore plays a bounty hunter named Anderson. Anderson arrives in Dodge City slightly injured and seeking consultation with Marshal Dillon. A visit to Doc Adams takes care of his injury, and he makes his way to the Long Branch Saloon to wait for Matt's return from a trip out of town.

Anderson is a charismatic fellow, and he tends to endear himself to everyone he meets. By the time the Marshal returns to Dodge, Anderson has spent time at the Long Branch buying drinks for others and spinning yarns. When two cowboys make trouble in the saloon, Anderson runs them off.

Upon meeting with Anderson, Dillon learns he and his partner have tracked a notorious outlaw named Gabe Sturney to an area in Kansas north of Dodge City. Sturney has a $5,000 bounty on his head. Anderson's problem is that Sturney is in an area where there may be other members of his gang present, and there may be some resistance to arresting Sturney. Anderson asks Matt to accompany him to find and presumably arrest Sturney. Matt agrees, but it is clear he does not trust Anderson.

As Matt--and the viewer--will learn, the situation is not quite as clear as Anderson has led everyone to believe. As Anderson will learn, it does not pay to deceive Matt Dillon.

Barrymore's story is somewhat legendary in Hollywood. As a member of the Barrymore family, he began his career as a highly regarded actor with a promising future. His mother, actress Delores Costello, tried to prevent the young Barrymore from becoming involved in performing, but Barrymore had other ideas. Unfortunately, his rebellious nature led to a number of spectacular failures involving various acting projects.

Like his father, Barrymore experienced substance abuse problems throughout much of his life. Those problems led to numerous arrests for various offenses. As he aged, Barrymore became increasingly reclusive. Despite some compelling performances, his acting career floundered. His acting prowess is evident in his performance in this episode. He would appear once more in a Gunsmoke episode in the first installment of Season 11.

Dennis Hopper appears in this episode as the impetuous Billy Kimbro. Hopper certainly had his own troubled acting career history, but was ultimately more successful than Barrymore. While his time on screen in this episode is limited, his talent shines through.

This episode is also notable because it was directed by Joseph H. Lewis, who is often regarded as one of the more underrated, overlooked directors in Hollywood history. Although many of his films were low-budget affairs, he had a distinctive, innovative style. A number of more famous, prominent directors have praised his work, including Martin Scorsese. Most of Lewis's film work was done before 1960. After experiencing some health issues, he deliberately slowed his pace and took on several television directorial jobs. While he only directed two episodes of Gunsmoke (Lewis also directed another Season 10 episode, "Thursday's Child," which starred Jean Arthur), he directed over 50 episodes of The Rifleman.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Another "EPIC" Episode
lrrap29 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Again, a well-scripted tale with so many intriguing dialogue scenes, plot twists, location shooting (including a mini"road trip" feel between Matt and Anderson) that you can't believe it was all contained within a 50-minute running time. That's a sign of a well-crafted script and expert direction.

John Barrymore, Jr. Is not the most convincing actor...at least not initially. But there's an intensity and focus to his presence that really seems to grow as the story progresses, especially in his scenes with James Arness. And the script keeps you guessing as to the character's true motives. Again, the signs of effective direction and writing.

However, considering the cunning and boldness of Anderson (Barrymore) in pursuit of the $5K reward, you would hope he would have covered all his "bases" in the set-up, ie: made sure that Sturney's gun would not be found fully-loaded...which means that the bullets found in the partner's corpse would have been from ANDERSON's (not Sturney's) gun. But then again, I guess ya' can't think of everything...!

An observation: Anderson's story about his horse farm and his shady activities to earn enough money to go back and buy it strongly resemble Sterling Hayden's story in the classic "Asphalt Jungle" from 1950. Too bad it didn't work out for either of them, because AT HEART their goal was a noble one.

Also-- the Festus/Doc "PIE" scene was really funny; now THAT's the way to do these "comic relief" bits...whimsical, subtle, and absolutely spot-on in performance (and I loved the director's touch in that restaurant scene.. with the cowboys riding by on horseback out in the darkened street. SO MUCH could be accomplished in glorious B&W by an imaginative director and cinematographer).

ALSO-- Dennis Hopper's death scene was very realistic; THAT's how a body reacts when being shot. (Director' Lewis' touch again? Most likely).

LR.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Gunsmoke and its great storylines and Guest actors
jdarcy_199918 July 2020
Very rock solid storyline, as always with Gunsmoke back then - with John Drew Barrymore (Drew's father and John Barrymore's son) and Dennis Hopper on board. One reason I love Gunsmoke is that it never lets you down story-wise and the guest actors bridge the golden age of tv and movies, as well as the stars of decades ahead.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A bounty hunter claims his' Pappy was a gambling man'.
kfo94944 February 2013
Warning: Spoilers
A bounty hunter named Anderson rides into Dodge with the news that he knows where one of the most wanted man in Kansas is located. He tells Matt that the wanted man, Gabe Sturney, is outside Dodge with his partner. He would like Matt to tag along so that him and his partner can take Sturney into custody and get the $5000.

Matt and Anderson stop for the evening at a stagecoach rest area run by Owney Dales and his daughter Helena. It just so happens that Helena is seeing Sturney's brother Billy and runs off to tell him. Billy and a few friends shoot into the rest area trying to kill Anderson and Matt. But Matt and Anderson get the upper hand and end up killing two of the men, including Billy, and then continue the trek to where Sturney and Anderson's partner are located. Helena is heart broken.

When Anderson takes Matt to the location where the outlaw is located, Matt finds out that Sturney and Anderson's partner are located in an ice house and both are dead. Anderson tells Matt that Sturney killed his partner and then he had to kill Sturney. Anderson made Matt all the way to the outback location to identify a body and Matt is none to happy. But Matt is required by the law to give Anderson the money.

When Anderson writes a detailed description of what happened at the killing of Sturney, things do not set right with the Marshal. Matt believes that Anderson is not telling the correct details of the killing. Matt is bound to find out the truth when he starts looking into the actions of that night.

Other than the guest cast there really is not much remarkable about this episode. It was a nice story but the part at the rest stop seemed a little more like filler than part of the story. Anyway, it was a nice watch and we got to see some nice acting.
7 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Long Complicated and Convoluted.
president-8941526 December 2023
Gunsmoke is my favorite Western. I like it especially because everybody and his mother were guest stars. This episode left me feeling like they were doing everything they could to let Barrymore prove he could act and act he did, quiet well I might add.

But there seemed to be a lot of "filler" at any point I thought it would end he would get his bounty and ride into the sunset. But being a Barrymore he had to prove he could act.

Matt Dillon is too smart a guy to fall for Barrymore's shenanigans, I got the impression that the writers were falling all over themselves to "make" Barrymore interesting.

Of all the guest characters, Barrymore ranks among my least favorite, but I'll give hmi this, he could act.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Could have ended better....
YoungHorse4528 November 2022
Many episodes of Gunsmoke end in an unsatisfying way, I suppose that's in order to present things more like "life as it is" rather than "life as we would like it to be". A perfect example of this is the episode where Matt is taking a man to be hanged and we all get to liking the man before he arrives to be hung. In the end the man is hanged anyway and the ending is very sad. I can't remember the name of the episode. I gave that as an example.

This episode should have ended the same way, with the bad guy getting away with the money. But instead they came up with a deus ex machina at the end and ruined the ending.

I would have given the episode an eight, but because of the cheap ending I gave it a six.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed