"Studio One" Abraham Lincoln (TV Episode 1952) Poster

(TV Series)

(1952)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
James Dean and Abraham Lincoln are Melted Into Thin Air
wes-connors27 February 2009
In 1860, Abraham Lincoln (Robert Pastene) considers an offer to run for President of the United States, from the fledgling Republican Party. It's not smooth sailing for Mr. Lincoln, who is an anti-slavery Unionist. After praying to the Lord, Lincoln decides he must lead the country. Alas, the new war-hating President is unable to prevent the country from taking up arms. Lincoln struggles to end the Civil War honorably. Ultimately victorious, Lincoln saves the Union, and frees the country's slaves. You should know how it ends…

James Dean has a small, but pivotal role. Appearing late in the hour, Mr. Dean is "William Scott", a Union soldier court-martialed for falling asleep on guard. Lincoln is a empathetic Commander-in-Chief; he pardons Dean, and shakes his remorseful hand. Later, Lincoln's fate is artfully woven with the character played by Dean - and, this is where playwright John Drinkwater gives the story some originality, and depth.

Dean's performance is good, albeit lip-biting. Mr. Pastene makes a fine Lincoln, managing to avoid hitting any microphones with the exaggerated hats he is given to wear. And, his remarkably level-headed wife, Judith Evelyn (as Mary Lincoln), recites "Our revels now are ended…" from Shakespeare's "The Tempest" very nicely. Of course, the Lincolns had to be fans of William Shakespeare.

As of this posting, IMDb doesn't list the teleplay's cast: Judith Evelyn (as Mary Lincoln), Robert Pastene (as Abraham Lincoln) Harry Townes (as Hook), Betty Low (as Mrs. Stowe), Noel Leslie (as Jennings), Frank Overton (as Samuel Stone), Jean Adair (as Susan Deddington), Charles Egelston (as William Seward), Robert McQueeney as James Macintosh), Katherine Raht (as Mrs. Otherly), Harold McGee (as Timothy Cuffney), John Buckwater (as Clerk), James Dean (as William Scott), and Anthony Grey (as Elias Price).

****** Abraham Lincoln (5/26/52) Paul Nickell ~ Robert Pastene, Judith Evelyn, James Dean
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The dialog is the problem with this one...
planktonrules26 September 2014
This episode of "Studio One" is an impressive looking biography of Abraham Lincoln from the time he accepted the Republican nomination in 1960 until just before he left to go to Ford's Theater...and to his death. For a TV production, it has very nice costumes and the folks who made it must have worked hard to make this all look good. However, it also has a HUGE problem--the dialog. Again and again, Mr. and Mrs. Lincoln (as well as others) talk as if they are talking for history books or for some omniscient eye--recording everything for posterity. So, instead of sounding human, which they certainly were, they speechify--talking AT the audience and making grand statements that sound more fake than a TV infomercial. The net result is a rather dull film which SHOULD have been much more interesting-- after all, it IS Abraham Lincoln we are talking about--not just some ordinary shmoe!

If you do watch it, and I DON'T recommend it as history SHOULD be exciting and realistic, look for James Dean in a small part as a soldier who falls asleep while on guard duty.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed