If a competition is hot dogs and you refuse to use hot dogs in the dessert round, that should be an automatic disqualification. I can see forgetting an item but to go and and say, "I refuse to use this item." should be a nono. So if a competitor in a future contest refuses to stick by the theme, they should be not be kicked out. Chopped needs to be more consistent with their rules.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews