Carmen (2006 TV Movie) User Reviews

Is that a flagstaff in your hand or are you just pleased to see me?

[Gyran · 10/10 · 16 October 2009]

This is my least favourite opera but I loved this very German take on Carmen that, visually, was very reminiscent of Cabaret. In the title role, Russian mezzo Marina Domashenko has a voice like warm treacle and a look that can kill, although, admittedly, it is not a very Spanish look.

My main problems with this opera are the characters of Don José and Micaela. Don José is usually a wimp and Michaela is a maudlin goody-goody. Not in this production. Adriane Queiroz is a very spirited Micaela who clearly sees Carmen as a rival for Don José's affection. Don José himself is excellently sung by Rolando Villazon. More to the point, this Don is no wimp. As played by Villazon, he is a violent and deranged man right from the start. His killing of Carmen is not the isolated act of a jealous lover, he precedes it by stabbing his Captain in Act II and by shooting Michaela in Act lll. I also enjoyed Alexander Vinogradov's performance as Escamillo. Vinogradov is a dapper, intelligent bullfighter, an interesting change from the usual dull, swaggering portrayal.

The body count in this production is higher than usual. Apart from the two extracurricular deaths already mentioned, we see a severely gored Escamillo being carried off at the end. Actually his mind was probably not on his work. When we see him in silhouette with Carmen before the bullfight he is carrying a flagstaff in front of him in such a way that makes him appear very pleased to see her. Also the production begins and ends with Don José's execution by firing squad, so that the entire opera becomes a flashback as he is dying. I have seen that idea several times in operas recently, this year at Glyndebourne's Macbeth, for example. It is becoming a bit of an operatic cliché but it works well enough in this production.

Daniel Barenboim, looking miserable, conducts from an almost horizontal position. I don't know if he was suffering from back trouble at the time. Anyway, there is nothing laid-back about his conducting and he drives the orchestra along thrillingly to make this the best Carmen I have heard musically and the most intriguing I have seen visually.

Not for all tastes, but the superb leads and music make it well worth watching

[TheLittleSongbird · 8/10 · 7 March 2012]

Carmen is one of my favourite operas and always has been. This 2006 production is quite interesting, though understandably not for all tastes. Those looking for a visually authentic production and fidelity to the libretto may want to look elsewhere like the 1984 and 1967 films. Those wanting superb leads and music will find much to enjoy. Of the many Carmens I've seen, this one is the darkest. And I don't just mean visually, with the dark austere updated backdrop. It is also the darkest dramatically as well, there is a higher body count than usual(in fact all four leads die here) and the whole production is like a flashback starting with Don Jose's on-stage execution. I personally would have preferred a more authentic look to it, but I did find this very interesting.

Bizet's music is just magnificent, and the orchestra play with Spanish flavour, and while I've found him much more enigmatic in the pit before Daniel Barenboim gives a very boisterous reading indeed. The chorus are strong, and the leads are fabulous. Alexander Vinogradov is intelligent and dapper as Escamillo, different to the more confident with plenty of swagger approach that I normally see, and has a good voice but I couldn't help thinking how young he looks, almost like a teenager. Norah Ansellem is a very convincing Micaela and gives real credibility to a I feel a flat character. Her singing is expressive if a tad too heavy on the vibrato. Frasquita, Mercedes, Morales and Zuniga are solid.

However, it is Marina Domaschenko and Rolando Villazon that really captivate. Domaschenko is incredible as Carmen, vocally dark and beautiful, and very compelling and seductive. Seeing and hearing her here and you'd completely understand why Don Jose fell in love with her in the first place. In this production, to my surprise and in some ways delight, Don Jose is the most well-drawn out character. Essentially here he is a desperate maniac, but there is a sympathetic quality as well. Villazon identifies completely with the role, the way the character is interpreted fits well with his hyper-energetic stage presence, but what makes Villazon so good here is that while the role plays to his strengths rather than another role that could be deemed too heavy for him(ie. Don Carlo), he doesn't look frenzied or sound over tensed.

All in all, there will be people who will dislike this production and understandably but I enjoyed it for the leads and one of the stronger depictions of Don Jose I've seen in the past twenty five years or so. 8/10 Bethany Cox