Beijing Besieged by Waste (2012) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
One part of China's pollution problem
DennisLittrell16 November 2017
This is not as good as Jiuliang Wang's more recent "Plastic China" (2016) (see my review), but it is very interesting nonetheless. And it covers more ground, as it were; in fact, Wang visited hundreds of trash dumps, landfills, pig sties, high rise construction sites, polluted rivers and streams, etc. in and around Beijing during the filming.

He shows truckloads of human waste poured into ponds, and trucks dumping huge loads of trash, especially plastic trash onto piles and piles of trash in which men, women and children make their meagre living. I was particularly grossed out by how the penned-in pigs are fed their swill (primarily semi-liquid garbage from restaurants). According to Wang, sometimes the oil from the restaurant garbage is filtered out and resold for human consumption.

Of course, what Wang shows in this film could be filmed in many other cities of the world. The point here is that Beijing is a particularly polluted city. The ground water is polluted, the air is polluted and apparently some of the food is polluted.

The reason I believe that "Plastic China" is a better film is because it focuses more closely and revealingly on the people working the trash. This film is more impersonal and not as well- focused. Additionally, in the six years of so between these two films, Wang has become both a better cinemaphotographer and more aware of the viewer's needs.

--Dennis Littrell, author of "The World Is Not as We Think It Is"
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Ascetic Portrait of City Drowning in Waste
knutwimberger20 October 2016
Beijing Besieged by Waste by Wang Jiuliang: The film director traveled 15k km over two years in 16k km2 large Beijing municipality to film and photograph the city's shameful waste management and the downside of capitalist consumerism within a totalitarian regime.

Main ideas shown in the film > solid waste being manually scavenged > swill oil production > Beijing is a city built on solid waste land fills > consumption accelerates and nobody cares about the consequences

Conclusions: > China is still a deeply unequal country, more so than other developed nations > automated production must be balanced with automated solid waste recycling - manual waste segregation can never keep up with the speed of highly efficient production powered by robots and assembly lines > it would be necessary to balance the movie with the situation in other nations e.g. Germany has dealt so far only with 1/3 of its solid waste dumps and most industrialized nations experienced similar periods of waste mismanagement during the 20th century 60-80ies, when consumption started to increase after WWII - China is not to be blamed, but to be supported to deal with these challenges
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A necessary documentary
aswarp200712 April 2016
It was really in need that someone had the courage to speak up and show the reality outside of the fancy touristy areas. If the Chinese government does not smash him, this director has a really bright future. You will be able to observe anything from illegal dumps, to people living among trash, or animals eating plastic. One can assume where those cows are going to end... probably at some restaurant's table downtown, at a barbecue, or inside some vacuum packed snack. This is not a problem in China only, though. It's a widespread sickness of cities worldwide, from Africa to America and even the old heart of Europe. PRC just experiences one of the toughest, since their cities host the most number of souls in the planet... and not precisely the most organized, open or civilized. Watch this documentary and help to spread the word.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed