Ahead of the broadcast of the tenth and final episode of the first series presenter Gail Porter tweeted the news that she will not be involved with a second series if one is commissioned. She explained that the production company Tern Television, who have offices in Scotland and Northern Ireland, have pitched the idea of a second series being shot at haunted locations in Ireland and would likely have an Irish presenter. Chris Fleming is pencilled in to feature in a potential second series but it is unclear if Ryan O'Neill and Evelyn Hollow would be part of the series or if they too would be replaced by Irish experts.
On 28th March 2023, Warner Bros. Discovery UK & Ireland announced the commission of a number of TV programmes, including confirming the commissioning of Tern Television to produce Spooked: Ireland. The 10-episode series will be presented by Irish model, presenter and podcaster Vogue Williams and will see Chris Fleming and a team of paranormal experts investigate sites in Ireland. Spooked: Ireland will premiere on the Really TV channel in the UK in September 2023.