Mrs Sidhu Investigates (2023– ) User Reviews

Amusing cosy mystery

[sabbiemv · 8/10 · 10 October 2023]

I was a bit worried about watching this as even though I'd been looking forward to it when I first spotted it on IMDB I'd seen some very bad reviews.

However I'm a big fan of both Meera Syal and Craig Parkinson so I ploughed on with episode one regardless.

It was a gentle cosy mystery with some giggle moments. Light hearted and entertaining which is exactly what you want in a cosy mystery.

I do love crime drama and police procedurals but they can be a bit too bloody and disturbing. On the other hand cosy mysteries can be a bit flat so I was pleasantly surprised with this one.

My other half enjoyed this too and he reckons he's more discerning in his tastes than I am (I beg to differ...) Looking forward to watching more.

Really good!

[sunflower-176-611522 · 9/10 · 16 October 2023]

I don't know why it is, but I rarely ever watching American murder mystery anymore. The British Australian, New Zealand, and South African murder mysteries are the best, and they also tend to just a wee bit of humor now due to the fact that Mrs. Sidhu is a caterer, and her stuff looks really good. You might get hungry while you watch this but nonetheless it's good.! Her relationship with her son is also pretty entertaining. Acorn has some really good mystery shows and this is a good addition to the list. The actress playing Mrs. Sidhu is good and very believable. Don't remember the last time I watched an American murder mystery, other than the simple ones on the Hallmark Channel.

Wonderful, entertaining series.

[Sleepin_Dragon · 9/10 · 1 January 2024]

Mr Sidhu is a wonderful chef, and a good businesswoman, but her talents run deeper, solving murders to be precise. She teams up with the reluctant DCI Burton, and helps him solve various crimes.

A truly wonderful, refreshing and intriguing set of mysteries, if you haven't already check out the various radio plays that were done some years ago, well worth a listen.

Cosy, evening telly, nothing heavy, no bad language, no gore, just good old fashioned murder. Each episode features a level of humour, the squabbling between Mrs Sidhu and Burton is joyful.

Aside from her relationship with Burton, I am loving how she interacts with her son, Tez, he's a good lad at heart, but a bit lazy, a bit of a waster.

I enjoyed each of the four mysteries, my only hope is that a second series is commissioned, as yet there's no news.

I would never have pictures Meera Syal and Craig Parkinson as a crime solving duo, but they work together incredibly well, they bounce off one another so well, how nice to see Parkinson in a lighter drama, he's brilliant.

Meera Syal, such a wonderful, talented actress, nice to see her leading her own show, she's been around for so long, but time has been so kind to her, she's wonderful.

More please.

9/10.

Excellent new show!

[allietexascutie · 10/10 · 27 September 2023]

I love the female lead. She is an amazing actress and brings an entertaining, intellectual and enlightening point of view to the detective genre. I also like the dynamic between she and her son. He's a terrific actor and he plays a realistic character of a young man of that age. A delightful dynamic between the two. I also like that the stories are not predictable. Neither my husband or myself were able to pick out the killer. I like detective Mint too. She brings an emphatic tone to the police. I hope to feel more for the detective inspector.....I sense the writers want us to slowly warm up to him. The show is extremely well written and I am looking forward to more episodes.

Great Programme

[clare-m-smith · 10/10 · 5 October 2023]

I was drawn to the programme because I've always been a fan of the lead actress and actor, they do work really well together so I was not disappointed. It's a nice, funny programme with a good sense of humour and I really hope they decide to bring out a season 2, I hate it when they get you hooked and then cancel it! Of course It's all been done before but they made it feel fresh with enough twists to keep you guessing... Meera Syal is her usual, wonderful self, she gives off a lovely, warm vibe which contrasts well with Craig Parkinson's gruff persona which he does so well. Fingers crossed for season 2 :-)

Captivating & Quirky

[dlc1952 · 10/10 · 10 October 2023]

Such fun- a perfect lite quirky mystery series with beautiful locals and great actors. So much awful depressing stuff in the world we all live in these days- nice to take a "time-out" with a mug of tea and this lonely show! Hoping for a 2nd and many more series. Even found myself laughing- Mrs. Sidhu played to perfection- the perfect Auntie. I really enjoy that each episode is movie length- 1 1/2 hrs. I so often find myself disappointed when things wrap up to quickly at 45 mins. Please keep these coming- the show is not dark, blood & violence packed - there are enough of those already. Mrs Sidhu Investigates is a welcome change.

Great Show and good cast

[Britinmiami · 10/10 · 24 September 2023]

"Mrs. Sidhu Investigates" - A Riveting Addition to British TV Drama in 2023 In the ever-expanding realm of British TV drama, a new star has emerged in the form of "Mrs. Sidhu Investigates." This captivating show, written and presented in 2023, has quickly garnered attention for its compelling narrative and talented cast that brings the story to life. This review delves deeper into what makes this series so enthralling and why it deserves a prominent place in the pantheon of great British dramas.

First and foremost, the standout feature of "Mrs. Sidhu Investigates" is undoubtedly its remarkable cast. From seasoned actors to rising stars, the ensemble brings a level of commendable authenticity and depth to their characters. Leading the pack is the brilliant Mrs. Sidhu herself, portrayed with finesse and charisma by a yet-to-be-discovered gem of the acting world. Her portrayal perfectly balances vulnerability and strength, making her a character that audiences cannot help but root for.

However, it is not just the leading lady (Meera Syal) who shines in this production. The supporting cast members, each with unique quirks and motivations, add layers to the story, keeping viewers invested in every twist and turn. Their chemistry on screen is palpable, creating a sense of camaraderie that draws you into their world.

The narrative of "Mrs. Sidhu Investigates" is a testament to the skillful storytelling at play. The plot unfolds seamlessly, drawing viewers in from the first episode and keeping them engaged. The pacing is well-balanced, allowing for moments of tension and intrigue to build organically. The writing is sharp and clever, with plot twists that keep you guessing and moments of genuine emotion that tug at the heartstrings. The writers have taken great care in crafting an entertaining and thought-provoking story.

Furthermore, the attention to detail in the settings and cinematography of the show is truly commendable. The backdrop of a picturesque British town is brought to life with stunning visuals that add depth to the narrative. From cozy, dimly lit pubs to lush, green countryside vistas, the settings are not just locations but characters in their own right. These descriptive and evocative settings create an immersive experience for the audience, making it feel like they are right there alongside Mrs. Sidhu as she unravels mysteries and delves into the complexities of human nature.

I cannot help but keep my fingers crossed that this program will join the ranks of British TV drama gems like "VERA" and "Happy Valley." The potential for character development and intricate storytelling is immense, and I am excited to see how the series evolves in the future.

In conclusion, "Mrs. Sidhu Investigates" is a captivating addition to British TV drama in 2023. With its talented cast, well-crafted narrative, and immersive settings, it has all the elements that make for a must-watch series. If you are a fan of thrilling mysteries, complex characters, and top-notch storytelling, do not pass up this opportunity to embark on a journey alongside Mrs. Sidhu as she investigates the unknown. This show deserves a spot on your watchlist, and I eagerly await what the future holds for this promising drama.

Cheap as Chai-ps

[owen-watts · 6/10 · 8 February 2024]

I'd been mildly into the original radio version of this, with Meera Syal as a maddeningly meddling caterer, who has a sub-Moonlighting vibe with the detective inspector, played fantastically on the radio by the peerlessly awkward Justin Edwards and here by the perennially grouchy Craig Parkinson. Which actually typifies the change between radio and TV Sidhu quite aptly, the radio is more of a broad comedy whodunnit (and Tez's character is still basically that here), the TV is going for more of a light-but-serious cheap TV whodunnit vibe. It never really settles into a consistent tone. So it's less good all round really but still fairly watchable and has a good range of guest character actors. Better than the average, but could be sillier.

New and Great.

[wispa-04184 · 10/10 · 3 November 2023]

EXCELLENT series. Makes achange to have a new series that is not boring or depressing. Just a wonderful cast with 'GREAT' story lines that give you the chance to guess who, what, where and when without it being to heavy or the 'run of the mill' series that seem to be on television these days.

Huge laughs and fabulous plots that keep you guessing right up until the end. Can't wait for another series with these fresh, new cast.

Mrs Sidhu Investigates gives just the right amount of laughs with believable people who are able to make you laugh and enjoy every part of each episode - only wish there had been more than four.

I want to like it.

[jk-692-236394 · 6/10 · 28 October 2023]

The premise sounds so good. Clever Indian Caterer, ( I was looking forward to the food), which has not been a true feature. She solves mysteries and keeps getting jobs on the day someone is murdered at various locations. That alone is a stretch. Now the thing is, I guess since her husband and father were cops, we are to accept her cleverness and ability to observe and solve these crimes. That plot point is pretty weak. The detective she keeps pairing up with, is quite harsh towards her and truly rejects her time and time again. I do not find them to have a very pleasant chemistry. It feels forced and clunky. His side kick officer seems wasted to me as a character. She obsessively takes notes and is not very well developed so far. The show does not flow. Her son is another character that is not working. He is just unlikable. He is immature and quite frankly I guess if they were going for Gen Z, living at home and being self centered and not helping out unless pushed, they nailed that. I believe in giving shows a chance, so I will keep watching, but I do not find this show that enjoyable. Maybe it will improve and find it's rhythm . Update- the 4th episode was an improvement.

The way to all our hearts

[lisbethinsydney · 10/10 · 25 November 2023]

The warm heart of the peerless Meera Syal is at the centre of this series. It is as much about family and women's place in both Anglo and Indian cultures as it is a murder mystery.

This series is thoughtful, funny and endearing. Mrs Sidhu doles out plenty of good sense alongside her scrumptious-looking, homemade meals and treats, and has a nice line in chai tea and sympathy for getting information.

Gurjeet Singh, a fresh, visually comic actor, is a perfect match as her son. Craig Parkinson's beleaguered old-school police detective is at first irritated but soon begins to fall under her spell. In the scene where they get her son to test a theory by putting his face into a pizza while they time it, we see how they are such a good fit.

Well written and plotted, Mrs Sidhu Investigates makes a satisfying, culturally refreshing change from the usual procedural crime drama. And when "More like this" is offered, there won't be. Mrs Sidhu Investigates is special.

Let's hope they keep it that way.

Oh, and you will start craving Indian food so maybe have some recipes handy.

Nice premise but episode 2 especially has more swearing / sexual language than many mysteries rated 12

[SunnyDaise · 7/10 · 18 October 2023]

I really like the premise of this contemporary Indian Marple / Jessica Fletcher - there's a good cross-generational feel to the show, with many issues being things lots of us are familiar with eg divorce/bereavement, (un)employment, financial troubles etc. Generally the series is rated approximately, being suitable for most viewers but episode 2's dialogue and content is not what I'd expect from a cosy mystery series and even the main characters are quite unlikeable. I actually saw that first and nearly didn't bother with the rest, but fortunately they are better script / storyline / characterisation so I would watch a second season. It would be fun to have some guest stars popping up like Death in Paradise and Madame Blanc does.

COMPLETE SILLY TRIPE MADE FOR YOUR NAN

[daftrancenergy · 1/10 · 30 September 2023]

What kind of meds are people on giving this show a 10? I had high hopes for this show due to the lead and Craig Parkinson. Parkinson's character would actually make a great show but Acorn would rather waste their funding on another silly nan show that is doomed from the beginning.

The concept is completely unbelievable. Mrs. Sidhu pops up in every scene like you are playing Whac-A-Mole. Then she has to espouse some philosophy every time she opens her mouth and is already tiresome in the first 5 minutes. In all of Buddha's teachings he didn't have as much to say as she does on every subject. The cliche here is everything has to relate back to food. So overdone here. This show lacks any subtlety.

The writers try to make jokes but they are so weak they actually detract from the show.

Craig Parkinson is the only thing keeping this dog on life support. He is wonderful on Grace and here also and is the main reason I gave this show a try. Sadly, he can't save this barker.

Acorn keeps making each show dumber and dumber. I know their target audience is older but they write like their audience is in a coma. The Chelsea Detective is awful but Mrs Sidhu is so much worse that Chelsea Detective seems like Poirot (not truly) in comparison. This is right down at the bottom of Acorn shows right along with Harry Wild.

The Peloton like company in this show is totally unbelievable. Why they even have a one woman caterer makes no sense. A caterer wouldn't have time to meddle in everything and of course it just so happens that her friend's daughter works there. So unbelievable.

Cozy and comforting!

[zac-493-479058 · 9/10 · 17 December 2023]

Love this show! Can't wait for more!

Cozy murder mystery, with great writing and acting.

Warm hearted murder mysteries is an odd genre, but Sidhu is amonh the best of the current batch!

The acting is solid, with no noticeable weak links. The characters are all likable and relatable - even some of the murderers! Sidhu herself is lovely, believable, deeply human, and really sells the role. The interplay between her and the police department is hilarious.

Wife and I savored them over a few weeks, but are on tender hooks for more.

Along with Queens of Mystery, Sidhu is one of our favorite of the new mysteries.

We watch it on Acorn TV in Canada.

Murder She Cooked

[ExitSouth · 8/10 · 14 October 2023]

Enjoyable ... but very formulaic... how many murders can she cater? I'd like to see this be renewed ... but they've got to figure out a way to change her character's catering situation. Maybe if she gets some sort of catering job with the police ... I don't know. Maybe she opens up a restaurant near the police station. The acting is fine. The leading lady is charming. The chemistry between the cast members is very good. I'm just afraid their going to run out of plots. Maybe she'll marry the lead detective and "help" him with his cases. Pie In the Sky worked because the lead was a retired detective who opened up a restaurant and still worked part time. I think they cooked themselves into a corner with this one. Here's hoping they figure it out.

Another BBC-level series with 3 keywords: Food, Hindu, and Slough

[BeneCumb · 8/10 · 30 October 2023]

Recent decade or so has brought forth plenty of crime series where characters, their family, relationships and hobbies prevail over the intense crime solving activities. Thus, the amount of funny moments is bigger and "ordinary" viewers can more relate to the events than just having an "outside" watch... Mrs. Sidhu Investigates is definitely one of such series, being not lame thanks to a certain quality standard BBC maintains. As Slough is ethnically a very diverse area, with lots of inhabitants of Asian origin, it is not another (often odd) attempt to follow politically correct approach.

True, I have my doubts how the events and scenes correspond to reality when fighting major crimes in the modern world and if people with something to hide really open up to a caterer, but the narration is smooth, the main performers are distinct and pleasant (Meera Syal and Craig Parkinson in particular), and the inclusion of other actors known from similar series in smaller roles provide additional value.

The final scenes of Episode 4 alluded that other episodes might follow.

Terrific show with great acting

[cjgrogan-97643 · 10/10 · 30 March 2024]

Meera Syal is excellent as Mrs Sidhu bringing charm and wit to this welcome character. The ensemble cast is terrific and writing keeps the pace of the show moving. With so many formulaic English police/detective dramas out there now, this is a fresh take on the genre that often plays off the same character types. Craig Parkinson's DCI Burton is the perfect pairing with Mrs. Sidhu and supporting cast of Naana Agyei Ampadu as DS Mint and Gurjeet Singh as Tez round out an excellent cast. Hoping that they order another series as it would be well deserved. I would highly recommend this show to anyone.

Well, shucks!

[sharonmikus · 6/10 · 10 January 2024]

I really wanted to like this. I love British and Aussie crime shows and this one has clear pluses and minuses. Mrs. Sidhu is lovely and, of course, we are asked to suspend disbelief when it comes to Mrs. Sidhu being in the right (or wrong) place at the right time which is fine. My issue is with her son. The character is just over-the-top annoying and ridiculously immature. I actually stopped watching an episode because I couldn't take him any longer. His flippant and clueless childlike personality is just too much.

If I'm in the mood for something to have on in the background this will fit the bill.

Good Show But Screen Quality Very Unclear and Murky

[canterburybella-680 · 7/10 · 12 December 2023]

First off, I don't understand why this show looks like I'm watching it on a dirty screen. I had to check if my eye glasses needed cleaning. No. It's the low quality of the film stock or digital tape or a filter they've put on, which looks very unclear and bad. So I hope they see that, and clear this up.

Secondly, the show itself is very enjoyable, the chemistry between all the players is entertaining, not overboard, and pretty realistic. The son is very funny, though lazy and useless for the most part, and I'd like to see less of that, and more of him being utilized in the story properly, as a man, not a spoiled little boy stuck in a virtual reality of gaming and expecting his mother to wipe his backside for him.

Mrs. Sidhu and DCI Burton are a perfect match, and their roles are nicely created, written and acted. I'll keep watching, but hope that the viewing quality is improved, where I don't have to feel like I need to put eye drops in for a clearer picture.

Would have been much better without the son

[cathysparta · 7/10 · 21 December 2023]

I went into this with no expectations whatsoever and it was rather enjoyable. It's very much like murder She wrote or Agatha raisin, a woman with no investigative experience gets involved with solving murders. The only real drawback I see to this show is her son. I don't see what his character adds to the show, he just brings it down. He doesn't have a job, is living in his mother's house and the way he speaks to her is atrocious. Every time he appears on the show it's another cringy seen with him berating her for something or ordering her around. If there is another season, hopefully they either get rid of that character or make him more of a human being.

Bland, not spicy

[AMAZINGzingzing · 1/10 · 14 October 2023]

Gordon Ramsay would describe This as a "nothing burger"

And hes correct,

This is forumalic, generic and just dull, dull,dull

I really struggled watching two episodes ,hoping for some excitement or at least some drama/tension/comedy but got nothing

Although meera is a decent actress she isn't good enough to be a lead , they should have replaced her with a better actress.

Craig Parkinson is a brilliant actor and is wasted in this

The rest of the supporting cast are unremarkable and add nothing, none of them have strong character traits

The "comedy* is cringe and desperate, not even remotely funny

The sets look incredible cheap, there is no atmosphere,I have seen better amateur movies on YouTube.

Why are people rating this 10 out of 10? They must be easily pleased

Why is mediocrity like this being celebrated? In the past we had excellent crime series like Maigret rumpole, morse ,even bergerac,

sidhu doesn't compete, and yet people claim to "absolutely love" it ? Sure.

Oh Puhleez, WTF??

[alex20850 · 1/10 · 10 October 2023]

First of all, what are my qualifications?

I have seen ALL of New Tricks three, four maybe even five times. I have seen all but the last detective for Death in Paradise. I have seen all the Father Brown and a lot of other British crime shows.

Where does this fall?

Off the table and whimpering in the leftovers bucket. I gave it good run - watching up to and including the 4th episode. While there were some good techniques used they were just in passing. Everything else was just so silly ridiculous in terms of non-funny slapstick, coincidences, presto-chango miracles they do a weeks worth of work or maybe a months worth in one afternoon.

Dog Eggs

[jockroyal · 1/10 · 25 October 2023]

Utter dog toffee.

Did the local primary school write this nonsense?

A few questions, did she acquire her investigative, enquiring mind from cooking a Biryani or the obvious osmosis from her dead father who was a cop...will we be told?

I was just thinking the other day, it's about time we had an Indian based drama, based around an amateur sleuth with dialogue that wouldn't be out of place in Crossroads (A UK 70'sTV soap).

With all the recently out of work actors, they could have cast the net a little wider instead of sticking with Slough Grammar sixth form drama class.

You'll not be surprised that there are more plot holes than the holes in the hull of the titanic, plenty of strong white female leads and white men who don't have a clue...never seen that arc before.