"Silent Witness" Commodity: Part 2 (TV Episode 2014) Poster

(TV Series)

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Introducing Leo's replacement
Tweekums3 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
This two part story opens with a man returning home after a business trip and discovering the bodies of his wife and autistic son. The police seem to think that woman poisoned her son before committing suicide… despite the fact that there is no sign of a gun she apparently shot herself with. In an apparently unrelated case a woman's disfigured body is found on a rubbish barge; it is clear that somebody wanted to prevent her identification but they didn't count one her identification from the ID codes on her breast implants.

While all this is going on we see footballer Isaac Dreyfus whose career appears to be in trouble after he offended Muslims on Twitter. His manager is trying to find a new team for him but things get tougher when a DVD is sent in showing Dreyfus having sex with a woman who is not his wife… the sender demands a large sum of money saying s/he has further footage that show Dreyfus beating the woman. He denies ever hitting her but things don't look good when it turns out that the dead woman on the barge was Dreyfus's au pair/lover and he denies knowing her.

Away from the investigation the team at The Lyle Centre have to deal with the arrival of new boss Thomas Chamberlain; he manages to antagonise everybody almost as soon as he meets them… Leo Dalton he is not.

I deliberately wrote the above précis after only watching the first episode to avoid giving any definite hints as to who really did it. Dreyfus was clearly being set as the 'suspect so obvious he couldn't have done it'… the character; a French Jew named Dreyfus seemed an obvious reference to the famous 'Dreyfus Affair'. For the most part this story was fairly gripping; both cases were intriguing although the inevitable linking came as no surprise; it would have been a bigger surprise if they had no connection. There were plenty of suspects for the viewer to guess from (in my case incorrectly!) and even possible involvement from Mossad agents… all in all a good mystery. The introduction of Chamberlain was rather fun Richard Lintern's performance was good and I look forward to seeing more of the character in future stories.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A squeaky chair.
Sleepin_Dragon24 October 2018
It's a very controversial story, dealing with some taboo subjects. The opening part had several strands, all of which converge together in this part. Personally I think it's a great episode, it's baffling, energetic, and literally explosive. The only element I didn't particularly like was the pointless romance between the two detectives, which just seemed not to fit somewhow. Thomas was more likeable in this episode, and the chair gesture was a nice touch, but as I said previously he was a character that was initially hard to like. What this episode does though is finally launch Clarissa, true she started a year ago, but wasn't exactly given huge screen time, instead Jack hogged the limelight. Liz Carr is an absolute joy to watch, I adore her cutting remarks and humour, she truly is wonderful in this, so sarcastic.

Very good indeed, I thought Emilia Fox stood out here. 8/10
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Nice Work on International Intrigue
Hitchcoc25 April 2019
I will watch this again. It involves so many twists and turns. Almost like a John LeCarre novel, you need to stop from time to time to figure out who is who. We are into entities like the Israeli Secret Service. When it comes to spying and retribution, sometimes smokescreens are put up to draw us away from the obvious. The new person is quite interesting. He is trying to find a way to fit in. He is incredibly competent, but on this team, he has to pass the human test.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Silent Witness, Series 17, Commodity
cindybee255 January 2014
FANTASTIC programme. Silent Witness is one of the best shows on television - long may it continue! However, it would be appreciated if the BBC and other television companies would put in the locations of filming for a matter of interest.

Does anyone know where Commodity (Silent Witness, Series 17 Part 2 on 3 January 2014) was filmed - in the second part of Commodity, it looked like Hanstead Woods, which is part of Bricket Wood Common. After the ransom drop, it looked like the car went along Station Road (from Bricket Wood Station) past the end of School Lane then under the bridge towards Mount Pleasant Lane and the M1 exit. Can anyone confirm if I am right?
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed