Outstanding start to season three with two totally different accounts to an attack of a youth umpire. Plaintiff Calvin Green gave a believable description of how he was attacked between games he was umpiring. Always smiling defendant Francisco Bagues' well crafted story attempted to present himself as a "nice guy" even though the facts beg to differ.
The defendant though a smooth talker failed to have any credibility with an account that fell apart when questioned by Judge Judy. The plaintiff was lucky to have his son nearby to get involved or he might of been hurt worse.
Very good job by JJ pulling back letting Green present a truthful account and "nice guy" Bagues bury himself with a suspect illogical version where he's the victim instead downplaying his violent actions.