In a real life "Mamma Mia!" story, Chara tries to figure out which of three men her mom slept with is her biological father. After 19 years, Melesa learns if her biological father is the man who raised her-- or his best friend. Possible twins Lauren and Kristen seem like complete opposites-- so are they truly identical twins?
After more than 20 years of wondering, Sarie hopes to make her fairytale dream come true and prove Terry is her father. Twins Andrew and Troy share an unbreakable bond that is challenged when they are approached by a stranger claiming to be their brother. Giana and Aaron do not look alike in any way, but think they are long-lost siblings.
Two sperm donor kids hope to prove they share the same sperm donor. After finding each other through a media blitz, possible siblings Betsy and Toby will be devastated if the DNA results prove they are not related. Charnae learns her mother's well-kept secret: the man who raised Charnae might not be her father.