Peter and Wendy (TV Movie 2015) Poster

(2015 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Multileveled Narrative Connecting Great Ormond Street Hospital with the Barrie text
l_rawjalaurence24 January 2016
Set in the contemporary era, Diarmuid Lawrence's production opens in Great Ormond Street Hospital, London, where Lucy Rose (Hazel Doupe) is about to undergo a heart operation. Her mother Julie (Laura Fraser) is quite naturally apprehensive about what will happen, but kindly orderly Jerzy (Bjarne Henriksen) consoles her. With little or nothing to read, Lucy asks Jerzy to help her; he takes her to the Hospital's museum and gives her a copy of PETER PAN. Initially dismissing it as "kid's stuff," she eventually volunteers to read the book out loud to a group of children, who end up being captivated by the story.

There follows a largely faithful retelling of Barrie's tale with the added dimension of Lucy's operation to hook our interest. The stories are linked by Stanley Tucci who plays three roles - Captain Hook, Mr. Darling, and Dr. Wylie, the surgeon in charge of the operation. The device works extremely well in emphasizing the connection between the Hospital and Barrie's story (Barrie bequeathed the rights to the tale to the Hospital), as well as emphasizing the importance of the tale to take children's (and the narrator's) minds away from unpleasant realities and create instead a fantasy-world in which people never grow up. Barrie originally told the Pan stories orally as a means to compensate for personal tragedies; Lucy rehearses precisely the same role.

The narrative unfolds at a brisk pace, with the emphasis placed on Peter's (Zak Sutcliffe's) naivété; despite his bravado, he is quite simply a little boy lost, needing Lucy/Wendy's protection on his journey through the Never-Never Land. Tucci plays Hook with lip- smacking relish, but he is shown to be equally naive; his dislike of children owes a lot to his turbulent childhood when he was sent away to school by an unloving family. He needs Wendy as much as Peter.

There is perhaps only one jarring note in an otherwise charming production: Paloma Faith's Tinkerbell is apt to use the kind of bad language that some families might consider inappropriate for their offspring. It is not really necessary, and eventually becomes rather irritating.

Eventually the story ends happily for Peter, Wendy and Lucy. Although we mortals have to grow up, we can nonetheless exercise the power of our imaginations to project ourselves into that world where fantasy and reality are one.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Classic Peter Pan with an added modern layer
magicwand44421 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I have been a fan of nearly everything to do with Peter Pan ever since I was lucky enough to see it on the London stage back in the 60s. My best friends parents took him and I to see it as his 10th birthday treat. It was magical and the wonderful Wendy Craig was playing Peter .The only production of Peter Pan I find disappointing is the Disney version as its too sugary. Peter Pan is in many ways a dark tale and this version has its sorrows but also its joys.In this version Lucy ,a teenage girl,comes to Great Ormond Street for a serious heart operation.She finds herself reading Peter Pan to some younger patients.,First in dreams and then under anaesthetic and at times in the real world she finds herself as Wendy and characters from her world are now in the tale. The other patients have become the lost boys and her surgeon,Mr Wylie, is Captain Hook. The highlight for me was the mixing of Neverland with the hospital itself. The basement exercise pool doubled as the Lagoon and Marooners Rock was a stack of hospital beds and equipment. The final fight scenes were one minute on The Jolly Roger and next on the Hospital ward and then back again. Hazel Doupe is great as Lucy/Wendy, playing it grown up one minute and a lost little girl the next. Stanley Tucci plays Hook with real gusto, him and the other pirates really ham it up without becoming ridiculous . The Wendy/Peter/Tiger Lily love triangle (love rectangle if you include Tinkerbell) is also subtly explored as Peter Pan is characterised from Lucy's world by a boy she has a crush on(blink and you miss the clue). So why only 9 stars.Well its the "I Believe in Faries " bit, Movies and TV have never satisfactorily got it right. On stage Peter breaks 'the fourth wall' and that is almost impossible to duplicate and in this film it happens for no reason.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Quality adaptation
david-radlett23 December 2019
An outstanding example of the way in which a classic story can be adapted with respect and effect. It pays due regard to inclusive values without metaphorically whacking the viewer over the head in a virtue-signalling way. The exact opposite of the recent (2019) BBC adaptation of A Christmas Carol. In short, a novel and enjoyable watch.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Amazing concept
redramos25 April 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I could not believe how unique this movie was. The route they took was honestly something I would have never thought of and something that works out perfectly. Great performances by every single person. Pan is actually a great GREAT casting. Stanley was simply perfect and so were every other casting. His portrayal was honestly perfect.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed