"Red Dwarf" Samsara (TV Episode 2016) Poster

(TV Series)

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Bad karma
Tweekums25 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This episode sees the crew of the Red Dwarf finding an escape pod from a ship that crashed long ago; its two crew members are woken from stasis and one of them tries to warn of something but are cut off. When the pod is brought aboard the two people are now dead; turned to dust. Hoping they might salvage something useful the crew head to their ship which is deep underwater on an ocean moon. The crew are long dead but the positions of their skeletons suggests that some were murdered and others were involved in an orgy! Strange things soon start to happen; Cat takes some coins from a charity box to feed a one-armed bandit and promptly wins the jackpot. Lister returns the coins to the box and immediately suffers an accident; Cat goes to help him and suddenly a knife falls from the room and impales his foot… it would appear that no good deed goes unpunished. We later learn that this is due to the ship's Karma Drive; a device designed to reward good deeds and punish bad deeds; unfortunately it has been reversed by the two people from the escape pod for reasons that are explained in a series of flashbacks.

After a good opening episode season eleven continues to impress… if anything this episode is even better than the first. The story was imaginative in a classic Red dwarf manner and packed with laughs. The way good behaviour was punished and bad rewarded was done in a funny way and it wasn't too obvious that this was what was happening rather than just bad luck. This meant that the revelation of the karma drive was still interesting. The way the skeletons were positioned was pretty funny and the fact that they were only skeletons meant it wasn't too rude although some parents might think it is a bit much for younger children. The cast do a fine job; I particularly liked the scenes between Craig Charles and Danny John-Jules as Lister and Cat; it made an enjoyable change from Lister and Rimmer… not that their early scene wasn't also funny. Overall another funny episode.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Samsara
MrFilmAndTelevisionShow2 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
They've explored a similar plot thread before, where being bad is punished. But this was a different take, and a decent one at that, every bad action is rewarded, every good action punished. The comedy was good but like the pervious episode while they have absolutely maintained the Red Dwarf feel they are missing something that the original series' had, though my finger cannot be placed upon what it is.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent plot but I struggled with the humour
snoozejonc7 January 2021
The crew receive a cryptic message from a woman on board an escape pod.

I enjoyed the structure of the plot and thought sci-fi concept was okay, but the humour missed the mark with me.

The jumping timeline works very well as the story unfolds and makes everything quite interesting. The concept of the karma-drive was reasonably good but it reminded me of the justice field a bit too much.

Where I struggled most was the humour. Most of the the jokes didn't work for me and I found that the extended banter between Lister and Cat lost its zip pretty quickly. Probably the most overused joke on the show aside from Lister's slobbish ways and the shape of Kryten's head is the Cat's intelligence. This scene attempts to do the joke to of death and for me it pretty much died with the multiple explanations of the stasis leak in series 2. As always I like to point out that comedy is highly subjective so if the humour appeals to you, you will likely enjoy it more than I did.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Samsara
Prismark1029 September 2016
After a bigger budget and funny first episode, the second episode 'Samsara' did not quiet do it for me.

It was less funny but well structured. We do get enough time with our foursome such as Lister and Rimmer playing Mineopoly with Lister cheating. Later on Cat and Rimmer chat about Archimedes and evolution of cats and apes.

Then again cheating is at the heart of this episode. The crew find an escape pod but the two human passengers being suddenly turned to dust. When they explore a nearby crashed ship they see skeletons and have to figure out what caused the deaths.

We see flashbacks of two crew members Barker and Green having an illicit affair which went against the ship's karma drive machine that was designed to reward good behaviour and punish bad.

Kryten realises that the crew are in danger as somehow the karma drive was reprogrammed to reward bad behaviour.

The episode had Kryten explaining what was going on a lot, which left less time for the knockabout larking, yet there were still a few good laughs here.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed