Frank is back...I was just wondering of something to happen to the lacklustre proceedings of this series..there it is..the most selfless and intriguing character has risen from ashes and invoked a spark in the series..the characters of Juliana and Joe are irritating and confusing to say at least..and this season Smith's role has also gone miserablly half-baked and cliché..hope the writers don't damage Frank's character too..
6 Reviews
Characters are sent in new, interesting directions
TheDonaldofDoom5 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I'm guessing Tagomi isn't dead. He's too much of a major character to kill off and this is too intelligent a show to kill a character for no reason other than shock value. Plus, if they were going to kill him we'd have seen it at the end of the episode. My guess is he'll either warp into an alternate timeline or Joe will decide not to kill him. By the way, that scene in which he was at the painter's house showed him opening up to an extent that we haven't seen before, but it was also tense to watch. I was just waiting for Joe to take a shot.
Juliana's part in the plot is the weakest at this point. Her role in the alternate timelines plot is simply cast aside as we see her and Joe's affection. I'm sure something will come of it, but is it really realistic to suspend the race to understand alternate timelines for this? I'm sure the alternate timelines plot will end up throwing them in interesting situations at some point, but it hasn't happened yet.
Then there's Ed's story and Nicole's story, which are both set to become a whole lot more interesting. Even though it's been building up to this already, it initially seems a bit much to have two gay couples portrayed in one episode. However, they both have different narrative purposes. For Ed, kissing a man is one of many expressions of the freedom he has in the neutral zone that has been suppressed in Japanese territory. The way he carelessly offers to pay more money for an item is also an expression of that freedom. When he and Robert are robbed, that's one more chain link breaking, one less reason to go back to Japanese territory. It's a real interesting arc that the show has now set Ed on, his search for meaning in a land thst isn't ruled by an oppressive government. His presence in the show is justified again. Meanwhile, Nicole is in a dangerous place to be a lesbian. Her relationship with this woman is almost like an act against the Reich that she makes propaganda films for. I think she's being sent in a narrative direction that will ultimately lead to her losing faith in the Reich. In her private scenes, you can see she thinks more about the regime than she lets on in public. And speaking of the propaganda, the way the Reich is planning to erase American history is sinister and fascinating, especially when compared to Japan which seems planned to take a lighter touch towards the Americans.
John Smith's story doesn't get as much focus this time, except for a brilliant and disturbing dream sequence in which his guilt at being an enforcer of an evil regime is shown. We also finally get to see Frank and the resistance. We learn about their plans and also about their precarious dilemma: the more they encourage people to resist, the more responsible they are for the consequences those people suffer.
This is my favourite episode so far this season for how it developed the characters, and how it hints that it will tackle more issues, such as the persecution of homosexuals and Jews. 8.9/10
Juliana's part in the plot is the weakest at this point. Her role in the alternate timelines plot is simply cast aside as we see her and Joe's affection. I'm sure something will come of it, but is it really realistic to suspend the race to understand alternate timelines for this? I'm sure the alternate timelines plot will end up throwing them in interesting situations at some point, but it hasn't happened yet.
Then there's Ed's story and Nicole's story, which are both set to become a whole lot more interesting. Even though it's been building up to this already, it initially seems a bit much to have two gay couples portrayed in one episode. However, they both have different narrative purposes. For Ed, kissing a man is one of many expressions of the freedom he has in the neutral zone that has been suppressed in Japanese territory. The way he carelessly offers to pay more money for an item is also an expression of that freedom. When he and Robert are robbed, that's one more chain link breaking, one less reason to go back to Japanese territory. It's a real interesting arc that the show has now set Ed on, his search for meaning in a land thst isn't ruled by an oppressive government. His presence in the show is justified again. Meanwhile, Nicole is in a dangerous place to be a lesbian. Her relationship with this woman is almost like an act against the Reich that she makes propaganda films for. I think she's being sent in a narrative direction that will ultimately lead to her losing faith in the Reich. In her private scenes, you can see she thinks more about the regime than she lets on in public. And speaking of the propaganda, the way the Reich is planning to erase American history is sinister and fascinating, especially when compared to Japan which seems planned to take a lighter touch towards the Americans.
John Smith's story doesn't get as much focus this time, except for a brilliant and disturbing dream sequence in which his guilt at being an enforcer of an evil regime is shown. We also finally get to see Frank and the resistance. We learn about their plans and also about their precarious dilemma: the more they encourage people to resist, the more responsible they are for the consequences those people suffer.
This is my favourite episode so far this season for how it developed the characters, and how it hints that it will tackle more issues, such as the persecution of homosexuals and Jews. 8.9/10
Seriously? When ppl ask you to pull over I guess you pull over
BruceWayne320 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I can't stand when writers get lazy. In this episode Robert and Edward are driving a bus, when a group of looters pull up next to them demanding they pull over. They voluntarily pull over, even tho they have a gun. Seriously? Who in their right mind would pull over? Such bad writing. Stop being lazy.
NRG
christopherjwall7 December 2018
It is my opinion that if all the actors put more energy into their conversations and spoke just a little bit quicker and louder the length of most episodes would be halved and I might stay awake. And, get stronger light bulbs please!
Lazy boring writing.
mecong-378-29270112 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
It starts with using a Soviet tank for a German, besides having millions of German tanks at their hands in the USA. Nuts.
Juliana turns into a maneater, after being almost celibate before. And especially with Joe. Makes total sense. Who now has become Himmler's lovechild from the Lebensborn collection when in reality being his father's son, he would either be dead or in a monkeyhouse.
The ever existing gay storyline has to come in, with DJ just recently coming out. Boring! There is no reason for it at all.
I could go on, but the writing gets worse and worse. And now it's the worst.
Juliana turns into a maneater, after being almost celibate before. And especially with Joe. Makes total sense. Who now has become Himmler's lovechild from the Lebensborn collection when in reality being his father's son, he would either be dead or in a monkeyhouse.
The ever existing gay storyline has to come in, with DJ just recently coming out. Boring! There is no reason for it at all.
I could go on, but the writing gets worse and worse. And now it's the worst.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
