So ok this is only 3 minutes long. I expected something very intense and smart. Many things don't make sense about this short film. The whole idea was to surprise the girl about her birthday i think, ok that's nice. Why did her brother try to scare her in the first place? I've never heard of a birthday present like that? Going in the middle of the night in somebody's room while they're sleeping, pretending to be some ghost? That's an awful idea total nonsense. Also when she started hitting her little brother repeatedly why he didn't make any noise? The first reaction when someone hits you is to scream (for help), instead the boy is absolutely silent while getting murdered. Also what's up with the parents? They enter the room, they see their little boy on the floor covered with blood and they don't even react. Most parents would go absolutely nuts by seeing their kids in that kind of situation. So my conclusion is that this short film tries to be smart and original but it's absolute nonsense. My rating is 2/10.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
