"Silent Witness" One Day: Part 2 (TV Episode 2018) Poster

(TV Series)

(2018)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A duty of care
Tweekums2 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
These comments refer to the whole two part story not just episode two.

As this story opens a young man, Kevin, in care is physically restrained. We then she a woman, who turns out to be his mother, driving along struggling to stay conscious; she swerves to avoid other road uses before crashing in to a lorry and dying. She had been drugged and it isn't long before the senior police officer investigating suspects Kevin despite the fact that his mental condition make the experts at the Lyell doubt his ability to commit such a crime. Back at the care home it is clear that the residents are being abused; the deputy manager is raping Serena, the woman Kevin likes, and another worker is turning a blind eye. Kevin decides to take her away but this ends in tragedy when he is killed by a police marksman who believes he is armed. While all this is going on Thomas is asked to perform a post mortem on a woman with dementia who turns out to have been poisoned... it emerges that her doctor also attends to the residents in the care home... could the cases be linked?

This was a gripping instalment although at times it wasn't an easy watch. We see that despite their conditions Kevin and Serena are in love most people around then can't see it; Toby Sams-Friedman and Rosie Jones did a brilliant job portraying these two characters. Charlie Creed Miles also impresses as Conor Flannery, the abusing deputy manager; this a character who really makes ones skin crawl; one moment he is being charming with the authorities the next he is horrible to the people he is meant to be caring for. Of the regular cast Liz Carr really stands out as Clarissa gets a larger role than usual and ends up in a very vulnerable position that should put most viewers on the edge of their seats. There are some flaws though; it seems unlikely that the police would shoot Kevin without warning him they were armed and a few too many people didn't seem too bothered about the deaths of people who require care. There is less of a mystery than usual but that doesn't matter as the story is tense and there is a moral message about the way people look at those in need that is effective without feeling like a sermon. Overall a really good story.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Worst of the Worst
Hitchcoc19 May 2019
A person who takes advantage both sexually and financially of vulnerable adults is the lowest thing I can think of. The awful conditions of the home in this episode make the skin crawl. Thanks to the intense commitment of Clarissa, this case is never closed. The police detective in charge should have been marched off himself for his close mindedness. He also had a prejudice against people with physical disabilities or mental handicaps. One issue is that Clarissa really put her life in danger and was incredibly careless when she chose to go undercover with no backup. Well done.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Another good episode - and no, Clarissa did not have Down syndrome as a child
serenity_124 May 2023
I am watching the whole Silent Witness series from go to wo, some of them repeats others I'm watching for the first time.

To clarify one of the other reviews, the scene in the dress shop was just a random woman with Down syndrome. Clarissa was in her chair when her mum came back to her - after sticking up for the other woman - and essentially told her she needs to keep fighting for her rights. How the tables have now turned for her mum, with dementia.

Good episode overall How they were treated in the home made me quite sad. That they chose to shoot Kevin at the end of part 1 was heartbreaking.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Liz Carr you are incredible!!
Sleepin_Dragon30 January 2018
I thought the opening episode was pretty amazing, but this second part absolutely had me on the edge of my seat with a sunken feeling in my stomach. The story as I mentioned in the first part made for very uncomfortable viewing, a disturbing storyline, one which tragically has seen relevance in recent times. How wonderful to see the character of Clarissa seemingly gaining in momentum, getting more screen time and getting a bigger, more gritty storyline, not just there to provide lines to Jack, and gives us laughs, Liz Carr was centre stage and boy she delivered. I can't think of a better performance on the hit show then the one from her in this, unbelievable. Charlie Creed Miles is also worthy of a mention, an actor able to be charming or abhorrent with ease, how good was he! The episode is loaded with tension, intensely gripping, simply scintillating viewing. I am fairly sure it will have its critics as it deviated from the usual formula, but having been bored by the recent episodes of ITV's Vera I suggest that show's producers watch this, and get an idea of how gripping a show can be.

I am genuinely blown away, I didn't think they'd have trumped the last two parter, but they have. 10/10
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One for Clarissa and a great one at that
retina_scan18 February 2022
One of the best things about SW of the last few years has been Clarissa's character, because it's always a great risk how you represent people like her - there's always risk of resorting to stereotypes or make all their scenes about their condition, or in an overly sympathetic way that ends up being patronising. But SW has avoided all this so far and she was just oen character among others with her own needs but still very efficient. The only awkward scene was when Thomas first met her, which seemed a bit off-key as a scene anyway and rather unlike his character, as would be later developed. But, on the other hand, they couldn't avoid touching upon her condition at some point in the series, or it would be like the elephant in the room. This two-parter does that and rather brilliantly. A great story, very subtle in its approach, great performances and uncomfortable viewing but great storytelling and thought-provoking drama. One of the best stories in quite a while.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good Story but Implausible!
tcosmas-1803524 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
We know Clarissa is physically challenged however, her depiction in youth seems to imply she had Downes Syndrome. As far as I know, you do not grow out of nor is there a'cure' for this condition. Adult Clarissa DOES NOT appear to have any mental handicap. So, that part of the story seems disingenuous!
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed