Have You Got It Yet? The Story of Syd Barrett and Pink Floyd (2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
dark side or not?
ferguson-618 August 2023
Greetings again from the darkness. "Wish you were here" is one of the songs Pink Floyd wrote in tribute to the band's enigmatic founder, Syd Barrett. These days, fifty-five years after he left the band and seventeen years after his death, Barrett remains a mysterious cult figure in rock lore, enveloped by rumors and conjecture. Co-directors Roddy Bogawa and Storm Thorgerson (graphic designer of such classic album covers as Pink Floyd's "Dark Side of the Moon") attempt to present the facts by talking to a stream of folks who were there.

It might seem odd for a Syd Barrett documentary to be timed to coincide with the 50-year anniversary of Pink Floyd's best-selling album, "The Dark Side of the Moon", since Barrett didn't perform on the album and had been gone from the band for five years. However, since the inspiration for the album's concept and songs were derived from the band's feelings towards Barrett, the timing does make sense. Bassist Roger Waters admits that Pink Floyd would not have existed without Barrett, and that is a crucial element to keep in mind despite the band having so much commercial success in the post-Barrett era.

"Creative genius" is an overused label, but Syd Barrett earned it, despite his short musical career. Enigma and mystery also apply to his story since he was basically kicked out of his own band and later retreated from public life ... along the way displaying unconventional behavior. Did the LSD habit have detrimental effects? Did he suffer from an undiagnosed mental illness? Was he on the spectrum? Did he prefer a simpler, quieter life far from the rock star lifestyle? The directors offer many folks the chance to chime in with their memories and theories. Those interviewed include former band members, Barrett's sister, his girlfriends, numerous childhood friends, influenced musicians, teachers, and psychologists.

Pink Floyd members Roger Waters, Nick Mason, and David Gilmour are respectful in their comments and give credit to Barrett for his influence. Also documented is the infamous day a barely recognizable Barrett dropped into Apple Studios while the band was recording "Wish You Were Here". The photographs are shown and provide the startling contrast between that Barrett and the one we had seen a few years prior. The Syd Barrett described as "fun", "artistic", and "intelligent" was not the one sitting in the studio that day.

Rock legend Pete Townshend describing the psychedelic heavy metal sound of Barrett's band is a highlight of the film, as is the somewhat sad story of the band deciding not to pick up an unpredictable Barrett before a gig ... with the punchline, "why bother?" Another interesting bit of trivia is learning that Barrett named the band via a blues mashup of Pink Anderson and Floyd Council. The reverence displayed by each interviewee solidifies his lasting impact, and the utter confusion surrounding exactly what happened with him. We always hear 'painters must paint', and 'writers must write', and we wonder if Syd Barrett is the exception. Is his a sad story, or one of a man who found the life he preferred? We now know more, though we will never know that.

Available July 12, 2023.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Elusive musician remains elusive
paul2001sw-129 April 2024
Many classic bands took some time to find the line ups that ultimately made them famous. And while no-one is very interested in Pete best (the Beatles' first, and apparently not that talented, drummer), some of these stories are potentially more interesting, such as bands lost their founding members amid their mental disintegration: Brian Jones from the Rolling Stones, Peter Green from Fleetwood Mac, and Syd Barrett from Pink Floyd are the obvious examples. This documentary tells Barrett's story. It's arguably more than just his personal tale, giving us a portrait of life in the Bohemian avant garde of the late 1960s. Unfortunately, while we get a picture of the scene, the personality of Barrett himself remains elusive; and as someone unfamilliar with Pink Floyd's early work, the excerpts we get here suggests it wasn't actually very good; or at least, that the band's later fame isn't really Barrett's legacy. As such, it's a sad story, but ultimately a small one.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Disappointing
smooneyh5 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Disappointing in a single word. For the casual Floyd/Barrett fans, the subject matter - the enigma that is Syd and his music - make it a worthwhile viewing. Storm Thorgerson central role in the commentary and interviews, and the interviews with his previously reluctant girlfriends, are also highlights. The exclusive photos from the infamous Wish You Were Here studio appearance also will be appreciated by Syd heads. All that said, these highlights don't make up for the weaknesses. No mention of the London Free School, so integral to the creation of the entire Chelsea bohemian scene of which Syd became a central figure. The importance of that scene's context to the creation of the Floyd, and of its beat/intellectual/art/mysticism influences on Syd - including his drug use - are discussed, but not in the depth needed. And no mention of the 14-Hour Technicolor Dream. Worse, the timeline of the crucial events of the spring/summer/fall of 1967 are dealt with loosely, not with the tightness needed to convey the landmarks of Syd's personality change. The laziness of failing to align pictures to appropriate segments of the timeline, and even playing "Baby Lemonade" during a discussion of "The Map Cap Laughs" (it was on the second solo album, "Barrett") is difficult to understand. Finally, the actor-conveyed mystical sequences of his life quickly become silly. The "hippies" in them look like something out of the '60s TV show Dragnet. Spending the time and effort to replace this footage with actual general footage from "Swinging London" or from Cambridge would have improved the film. Syd Barrett's life was a sad tragedy. He was a true musical genius whose life and talent spun off incredible lifelong journeys for at least two dozen of his friends, but whose own journey was stunted by a haze of drug use and mental illness. This film comes up short in properly conveying the breadth of that tragedy.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed