When Aaron stumbles upon a gift from an ex that he wishes to keep, Aaron's current girlfriend insists he do whatever it takes to receive the closure needed for her and Aaron's relationship to move forward.
When daydreaming introvert, Christine's car won't start on Christmas Eve she is forced to ask her crush/co-worker Sam for a lift to deliver a large takeout order.
After a heart-wrenching breakup, Cammie reluctantly escapes to her brother's back to school party where she meets Ethan who attempts to cheer her up with a fantasy story that quickly takes on a life of its own.
When a severe snowstorm keeps Sophie's parents from joining her on Thanksgiving, the day is made worse by the unwelcome company of Jack, a boy with whom she has tempestuous history.