Reviews

6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Dramatic Cream of 2001's Crop
11 February 2002
Set and filmed in Maine, this family drama is adapted from a short story by the late Massachusetts writer Andre Dubus. His tales are peopled by characters whose conflicted lives are beset by thoughts, emotions, and acts of deception, self-delusion, and desperation.

For instance, one man in this film is highly regarded in his public life as a healer of the community; yet in his private life he tacitly encourages a relationship that jeopardizes the very life of his son. Here, too, is a woman of gentle manner, who is a school choral director. But even as she coaxes sublime music from her students' throats, the sweetest sound her mind can imagine is that of a gunshot taking her neighbors' life. And we meet a young man whose Ivy League intellect may not be enough to save him from the smoldering powder keg that he has chosen as his lifestyle.

Nuanced performances are compellingly delivered here by Sissy Spacek, Tom Wilkinson, and Marisa Tomei. (Wilkinson, a British actor unfamiliar to most American filmgoers, has also distinguished himself is such period peaces and comedies as "Sense and Sensibility," "Wilde," "The Patriot," "Shakespeare in Love," and "The Full Monty.")

The set design and lens work overseen by fledgling director Todd Field are also first-rate. He does not clutter scenes with superfluous objects, movements, music, or dialogue. Moreover, he pays close attention to camera angles and allows our eyes and ears to linger on simple details that tell us much: a woman's careworn mouth, a rough architectural sketch pinned to a wall, town banter at a midsummer afternoon's barbecue.

Later in this movie, the screen is lit by two or three scenes that are devoid of dialogue, and that begin and fade away so quickly that their passage can be measured in scant seconds, not minutes. Metaphorically, these brief, fade-to-black sequences suggest the slowing-down beats of a tired or expiring heart. The film closes with visuals that stand in stark and haunting contrast to those that opened the production. These powerful images seem etched into the screen, and likely will remain etched in your mind long after you've left the theater. This was my favorite motion picture of 2001.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Eye Candy Is Not Enough
8 April 1999
For me, this film came across as an anesthetized version of the vibrant, poignant cinematic experience that I'd wished for. Again and again through this movie, one character or another in the Willis family is confronted by an emotional trauma whose climax and resolution are either ineffectively muted or left to be played out off-screen. This is a film in which nobody ever seems truly racked with sadness, anger, or laughter. In an early scene, Mr. Willis tells his publisher of the rawness and bloodiness of war; such ragged-edge scenes as he discusses with the publisher would have vastly improved this movie, tearing it away from the and artsy, too-tidy series of separately titled chapters that it was structured into. (The scene of the mother flinging sand into the teacher's face was one welcome departure from this.) Also, the development of romance between Channe and the football player is a real yawner; as soon as he flings down his helmet, it's apparent that he'll wiggle his way into her heart, as he's cut from the same iconoclastic mold as her beloved "Daddy." Lastly, Channe and her brother are portrayed through much of the film as spoiled, listless whiners. Not the most interesting characters you'd want to spend a couple of hours with. Only the luscious photography and a serviceable performance from Barbara Hershey raise this to a two and one-half (out of four) star rating.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This is truly an unjustly ignored sleeper.
17 March 1999
This is a poignant film that few moviegoers are familiar with. It is redolent of such recent works as Manny & Lo (featuring Scarlett Johanssen, the girl from Horse Whisperer) and Lawn Dogs (a decidedly darker vehicle, starring Sam Rockwell). Don't pass this one by, if you have a heart.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Kind Lady (1951)
Most Chilling Film I've Ever Seen
5 March 1999
I saw this black-and-white chiller on tv when I was a boy, some 35 years ago. Yet I recall scenes from it as though I saw it only last week. Imagine a group of seemingly well-bred people, patrons of the arts, befriending you--but then locking you in your house as they move in, and then hearing them tell visitors that you are delusional and being cared for by them. The scene in which the elderly victim is continually taunted while being forced to pose for the painting of her portrait--a rendering that, when completed, is seen to have grotesquely distorted her likeness to resemble that of a haggard, insane woman--is particularly spine-chilling. Without exaggeration, this is a gripping drama whose suspense few (if indeed any) can match. I only hope that someday it appears on video, so that I can purchase it for my library.
36 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Don't Miss This Dark Comedy!
1 March 1999
Apparently, it is impossible to buy a copy of this superb dark comedy, which is available for rent from some video stores under the title "Over Her Dead Body." This is a shame, because I am a devotee of dark comedies, and this is my all-time favorite, bar none. The hi-jinks mix with pathos in a most rib-tickling way in this film. Truly, if you don't laugh at loud at least a few times during this movie, you'd better check to see whether you, yourself, may be saddled with a dead body (your own)!
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Rushmore (1998)
Quirkiness does not equal genius.
16 February 1999
If you want to see a well-crafted quirky film, see "A Box of Moonlight" or "Love Serenade." If you want to see a movie made up of one pointless scene (with underdeveloped characters) piled on top of the previous scene, see "Rushmore." All Bill Murray does, basically, is stand around with a pained look on his face, and say hardly anything for two hours. And when it comes to Jason Schwartzman's performance, I've seen more variety of facial expression on the cold, stony faces on Mount Rushmore. Definitely this is a case of "The Emperor's New Clothes": many viewers are seeing something (a decent film) that just isn't there.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed