When it was first announced that "Generations" was being made with cast members of both TOS & TNG, I was excited. Despite the highly-publicised fact that Captain Kirk was gonna bite the dust in this one, I had high hopes, recalling how the death of Spock was handled in "The Wrath of Khan". Not to mention, with the TNG series finale', "All Good Things...", being soooooooo good, a TNG big-screen outing that combines the casts of both series HAS to be even MORE spectacular!!!
However, what we were treated to was a murky, discombobulated outing that essentially wasted the talents & screen presences of Jimmy Doohan, Walter Koenig, Jonathan Frakes, Mirina Sirtis, Gates McFadden & Michael Dorn. The scenes that featured William Shatner, Patrick Stewart, Brent Spiner, LeVar Burton, & Malcolm McDowell were spotty at best, though Patrick Stewart was given ample time to emote.
The three cast members of TOS (Shatner, Doohan, & Koenig) all did fine jobs (as always!) with what they had to work with, but it's obvious that the roles the latter two wound up with were written for Leonard Nimoy & DeForest Kelley. Chekov as a medic & Scotty as a science officer? Not that they couldn't do it in a pinch, but the dialogue could've at least been re-written to suit the characters. However, it speaks volumes that Nimoy & Kelley turned down the parts once they'd read the script.
The lighting on this film is one of the most frustrating aspects of watching it, from a technical standpoint. Everything appears in ambient lighting, which is something that was rarely done on either TOS or TNG. When Will Riker walks out of Picard's ready room, he walks onto the bridge in almost pitch blackness. HUH?!
Also, what's with each crew member changing uniforms every time they come back from an away mission? START with the new uniforms & let it stand at that!
The biggest complaint I have about this movie is the fact that co-writer Brannon Braga admitted from the get-go that he was not a classic Trek fan & had always wanted to kill off Captain Kirk if the two casts ever met on screen. As I stated earlier, the death of Spock in Trek II was handled tastefully &, as Kirk stated in his eulogy, "his sacrifice (was not) a vain or empty one". Spock's death actually SERVED a purpose. Braga simply wanted to kill Kirk, & it shows in the lack of depth with which it was handled. Classic Trek fan or not, if it hadn't been for Shatner & Co., Braga wouldn't have enjoyed the lucrative coattail-riding career he's had for almost 20 years. He needs to be a lot more respectful of his elders.
The shoddy plotpoints that lead up to Kirk's first "death" in the 23rd century are hackneyed & poorly written. For Starfleet to assign a young, bumbling officer as the captain of their flagship is not only ludicrous, but also ill-conceived. I guess he was trying to make some type of political statement about the military as a large, unthinking collective, but he wound up insulting a, if you'll pardon the bad pun, generation of fans who grew up watching a Star Trek series where Starfleet was adept at assigning officers who could handle crises without looking over their shoulder or having to call home every time. I know this was designed to make Kirk look good & still vital despite his retirement, but it only served to make Starfleet & their newly-chosen crew look like nothing more than a bunch of buffoons & publicity hounds.
The attempts at trying to tie in loose ends from TNG (Lursa & B'Etor) was a hindrance that could've been done without. They had no logical place in this movie; it was a contrivance that Dr Soran just so happened to contact two Klingon sisters (or maybe they contacted him -- who knows, who cares?) who had it in for Picard & could help him with his plight if he helped them with theirs.
The emotion chip scenes with Data, while being far better utilised in ensuing TNG films, were forced, & I don't know if Brent Spiner is to blame for that or the writers. TNG always had a healthy dose of humour in it, but throughout the film, I kept waiting to hear a muted trumpet blaring "waa-waa-WAAAAAAA!" after every one of Data's lines once he'd installed the emotion chip. And the one word of profanity spoken in the movie was spoken by Spiner in a lame attempt by the writers to garner cheap laughs from an already insulted audience.
Bringing in Guinan as a bridge to explain what the Nexus was & what it did was overkill. While it's generally a welcome thing to see Guinan, her scenes were a bit too pat & explanatory (not to mention they were forcibly reiterated when Picard finally confronted Dr Soran face-to-face) & again, a character's presence was wasted by being reduced to, what Ridley Scott termed, "Irving The Explainer". Let's have a little mystery here folks! "Who's this madman destroying stars? Why's he doing it? Guinan, care to espouse for me? Thank you!" As I said, a bit too pat & FAR too pandering a mentality for a Trek film.
Another thing (& this has always irritated me about TNG) that really bothered me about the whole "Picard-going-to-rescue-Kirk-from-the-Nexus-&-save-the-universe-one-last-time" nonsense is that Picard has always been portrayed as a little bit TOO perfect. Kirk, like any other human being, made occasional mistakes, & his foibles made him all the more identifiable with the audience. Not so with Picard; he was always depicted as right, regardless of the situation. Granted, here, Picard had foreknowledge of the Nexus & how it affected those within it while Kirk didn't, but to suggest that Picard would be less susceptible to the wiles of the Nexus than Kirk is ridiculous. Braga really goes out of his way to say "MY captain's better than YOUR captain!" with this one.
(BTW -- I know Ron Moore co-wrote this script with Braga, but the points I bring up are the ones where Braga had his hands in a bit too heavily.)
And, finally, we have the death of Kirk.
Spock died saving the Enterprise from the obsessions of a madman. Kirk died saving a solar system from the obsessions of a madman.
The difference? How it was handled.
Spock's death was poignant to the point of tears. The only reason Kirk's death caused tears is because it was so senseless. Whether it's the original ending where Kirk, after saving the solar system, is shot in the back by Dr Soran, or the theatrical ending where Kirk, after saving the solar system, FALLS OFF A BRIDGE (!!), the death is pointless. "Hey, Jean-Luc... look! I've saved the universe one last time, like we agreed. Now I'm gonna go off & die somewhere."
Puh-LEASE!!
Kirk doesn't even get a decent burial for cryin' out loud! At least Gary Mitchell gave Kirk a tombstone!! Picard dumps his body under a pile of rocks & places his battered Starfleet insignia atop it, then calls his ship to pick him up. How friggin' TOUCHING. I'm all choked up just thinking about it.
TNG was able to redeem itself, very much like the cast of TOS did, in their subsequent films. I regard "Generations" as I do "Star Trek: The Motion Picture"; it was a gawd-AWFUL movie, but it laid the groundwork for some really fine films to get made.
And that's REALLY the only reason this movie should still exist.
16 out of 25 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends