- originally my review was rather scathing,
That has been mostly left as it was first written.
However, an updated review is necessary based on the series conclusion.
A conclusion, which was far better than the middle of this show:
(original) What a shame, but in all honesty why would any "OG" SW fans believe their expectations could be met at this point.
Disney-SW, simply put, is just a mess - quite possibly a nonredeemable mess.
This Obi-Wan series is often cringe-worthy.
- Poor acting (the best acting comes from a 10-year old actress (she does show much promise as an actress)), awfully lame effects - (Reva's parkour scene is sad and embarrassing; Flea-Leia chase scene - what-on-earth were the writers/directors/producers thinking here???), sophomoric writing, a plot thinner than the purpose behind Book of Boba.
And McGreror appears to be of the mindset: "oh just give me the darn check already", completely phoned-in.
There are very few positives to take away:
scenes of Alderaan, the Jedi-temple (clone-wars), etc are quite beautiful.
And Egderton and Varma do admirably well in their limited roles.
Disney-SW is some shyster current-America politician, duping it's constituents with promises of a return to the "Glory-days", while destroying the very fabric of what made the franchise great.
Chronologically, It feels like they:
a. Purchased a nostalgic franchise, flush w/ devoted fans - for billions of dollars
b. Discarded the playbook provided by Lucas, which would maintain said profitable fan-base, ensuring a ROI that would almost certainly exceed financial expectations
c. Created new, sub-par content that alienates a once devoted enormous fan-base, in hopes of netting new viewers from a decidedly smaller pool. Occasionally toying with older viewers through glimpses of promised nostalgia, that not only don't live up to any "hype", but desecrate the memories of those nostalgically characters in the process.
Does (most) everything kk touch turn to guano?
Answer: YES.
Sadly, it likely would've been better if disney had never acquired SW at all.
*(update) Majority of this review still feels applicable to most of the episodes in Obi-Wan series, and for most disney-starwars content. But, there is room for praise here as well.
While the last couple of episodes might regurgitate some key SW content from earlier animated series, there is quite a bit for the viewer to enjoy.
The interactions between a former Master & Apprentice, who consider themselves like brothers, whether in the present or flashback scenes - are strong and well-acted.
There is some content, especially in the season finale that is right up there with the best SW scenes ever made. And the writers/directors do an admirable redeeming a mostly unlikeable character in Reva.
McGregor turns in an emotionally strong performance in the final episode. Hayden, as always, delivers with a fantastic portrayal of a character dealing with strong inner-turmoil and in utter agony.
Based on the 1st episode & last 2 episodes of this series, I'm rating this 7* and would recommend SW viewers give it a chance.
12 out of 22 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends