OK,I had read all the novels, up until Brian Herbert took over to write house harkonnen,and always his dad inspired the original series first four Books to be a reflection of the regimes and different cultures on our planet,you know the pretty blue one, maybe a thousand years from now,and themes of AI danger,wars,mentats,mass production,and trade wars of that particular era. In short a mirror.
Part one superlative,cinematic, a big improvement to lynch's original.
However I can't give a 10 to this eagerly awaited part two edition,as the director has changed the original book version somewhat, but all the actors did perform exemplary with what they were given.
I didn't like the ending, and the inference of what was to come,after the defeat,it looked like a setup prelude to Messiah,the principle evil characters were dispatched, in a different way to the book,and the benegesserit order,supplanted by Jessica's fremen converts following didn't have the dramatic impact and in the book years passed before the uprising,Paul's character had some important training to go through,and had to prove that he had the heart of a warrior. Also the film portrayed North and South deserts,where there was some division between religious factions and warriors.
Also a Big reveal, that the fremen could ride the worms,and before him taking a trip to survive in the desert,and taking the water of life.
At this point Stilgar became a bit watered down,and Gurney the smuggler reunited with Paul.....all done within 10 minutes on film.
Chani having a hissy fit at the end jarred somewhat. It was accepted that Muad dib would take power and rule for political purposes,and that was implicit in the books,he had already seen his own death in the future. Chani also had three children by him eventually in the books.
Christopher Walken,a great actor and thespian,wasted, not given enough coverage,thinly revealed ,not really portrayed as an all powerful Emperor.
Timothy Chalamet was probably the only convincing original Paul Atreides,along with the psychotic feyd rautha by Austin Butler.
Apparently Chala Mala bing bong is going to do a Bob Dylan biopic...Please...Don't mess that up,while I'm still on the planet..
I still have the original vinyls,it's Alright Ma..I'm only sighing....
What was missing in both films was the power of the landsraad, and guild navigators reliant on spice for utilising foldspace.
4 out of 9 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends