Reviews

37 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Wonder Woman (2017)
9/10
The Second Best Superhero Origin Story Yet!
5 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
In my humble opinion, comic book movies work best when they don't take themselves too seriously. With the (possible) exception of 'The Dark Knight' and 'X-Men: First Class' , every 'realistic' CBM to date has foundered on the ridiculousness of the basic idea of super beings in garish costumes interacting with the 'real' world. 'Wonder Woman' never makes that mistake. From its opening in the mythical land of the Amazons, through equally 'mythical' versions of London and the Western Front in late 1918 (although I'm almost certain that the photograph that a certain B Wayne finally returns to Diana at the start of the movie was stated as having been taken in 1917 in BvS) to the somewhat clichéd CGI showdown between Diana and Ares at the end, the movie remains true to the spirit of its comic book source.

Keeping things as spoiler free as possible, the Amazons idyll of leather-clad workouts and combat training is rudely interrupted by the arrival of Allied spy Steve Trevor in a crashing Fokker monoplane, hotly pursued by ship-borne German troops. I must confess, I was so distracted by the similarities between this setup and the one in 'The Land that Time Forgot' that I didn't question the mechanics of following an aeroplane in a ship, nor did I notice that the ship either turns around and leaves after the Germans lose a pitched battle against the Amazons, or it spontaneously sinks, as it simply disappears from the movie at this point. Anyway, as a result of personal tragedy, or Steve Trevor's description of 'The War to End Wars', or both, Diana decides that Ares (Greek god of war, and the last of the Greek gods in the movie, for some reason) must be behind the slaughter of millions in this pointless conflict. So she and Trevor head for London, thence to Belgium and a showdown with General Eric Ludendorff (a real life historical personage), who is frantically searching for a new weapon to renew the German offensive before the Armistice can be negotiated (placing the events of the movie in late 1918, presumably after the failure of the 'Michael' offensive and the defeat of Austria/Hungary). Along the way, Diana discovers the true extent of her powers, refuses to conform to the restrictions placed on women by the conventions of the late-nineteenth/early twentieth century and puts Ares back in his box (until the inevitable sequel, presumably).

Suffice to say, Gal Gadot is a perfect Diana, very much cast in the mould of Christopher Reeve's Superman, or Chris Evan's Captain America; her limitations as an actress actually serving the straightforward moral certainty of the comic book heroine she is playing. Chris Pine is terrific as Steve Trevor, (almost) playing him as Captain Kirk suddenly finding that he's become Lois Lane. The supporting cast are uniformly good, although Danny Huston's Ludendorff is probably a little too much of an 'Indiana Jones' style Nazi (or, having quickly scanned his Wikipedia entry...) for a movie set in the First World War! But it's only a minor quibble, just like the anachronistic Native American sidekick, everyone, Germans included, using what look suspiciously like British WWII era gas masks, the portrayal of Douglas Haig as a one-dimensional, indifferent, callous warmonger and the already excessively (IMHO) criticized murky CGI finale, which at least remains true to the medium of comic books. The film ends with Diana's 'mission statement' as Wonder Woman, to save the world through the female principle (or 'love' as the dialogue puts it); no problem with that, it's been identified as a central theme of Wagner's Ring Cycle, after all. But unfortunately, the preceding two hours don't really establish any distinction between Diana's feminine brand of villain clobbering and the masculine variety. But then, it is a comic book movie, after all. View it as that, and enjoy!
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
More of the same, only better!
17 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This particular iteration of the MCU is starting to grow on me, particularly since 'Vol 2' gave me exactly what I required from the sequel: more Nebula, more Baby Groot, funnier jokes (the toilet humour excepted) and more originality (seriously, I spot more rip-offs from other films in GOTG every time I watch it). I also like how the whole thing kind of reminds me of classic 'Star Trek', Chris Pratt being, well, Kirk; Quill's, or Pratt-Kirk's, egotism being on a par with Pine-Kirk's from reboot Trek, but most obviously when flirting with Elizabeth Debecki's Ayesha shortly after the opening credits! Meanwhile, Zoe Saldana riffs on both her role in rebooted Trek while simultaneously serving as this series' Spock character (complete with the requisite green skin),struggling to keep her emotions in check while at the same time being patronizing to her less evolved crewmates.

Anyway, keeping things as spoiler-free as possible, Kurt Russell makes a great Kurt Russell as he portrays Pratt-Kirk's 'celestial' father; reuniting with his earthling progeny for not particularly altruistic reasons (and his name is pretty much a spoiler hidden in plain sight). Ga-hura works out some sibling rivalry issues with her cyborg sis (and I definitely require more from Miss Gillen in the inevitable next installment) by way of a sequence clearly inspired by 'North by Northwest', Rockett steals the 'cow' joke from 'Father Ted' (as well as other more plot-significant things) and participates with Yondu in my favorite sequence in the movie, as Yondu retakes his ship in a very 'Pirates of the Caribbean' fashion. Dave Bautista earns his paycheck as Drax, with some laugh out loud dialogue to go with his impressive physical acting. Baby Groot is, well, go see for yourself but in my humble opinion he steals the show.

The weaknesses (IMHO) of the original are still there though; some pretty uninspired, CGI-heavy action sequences (and was Ego's manifestation of himself throughout the Universe as a blue-grey blob, reminiscent of, well, 'The Blob', really the best they could do visually to realise his plan to reshape the Universe in his own image?), the afore-mentioned toilet humour, Saldana'a woefully limited acting range (which is further exposed by pitting her against Karen Gillen) and over-reliance on shots from other (not necessarily better) movies; for example: if you've already successfully sneaked in a copy of the 'Avengers Assemble' tracking shot in your first movie, why go all-out and simply rip it off in the second?
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Best Superhero Origin Story Yet!
9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Sorry, Nolan. Your Batman origin movie is very good, but this is far better. First and foremost of the reasons why: it doesn't take liberties with the comic book version to facilitate its own plot. Second, Chris Evans is absolutely spot-on casting for the brave, righteous but sickly young man who becomes America's living secret weapon in the fight against the Nazis; despite his limitations as an actor he projects all the qualities the role requires without resorting to a ridiculous growling bellow while in costume. Third, it's set in a period in history we've all come to believe (or would like to believe) when a global conflict really was about 'good vs evil'; 'Captain America' fits perfectly into the role of a hero for that age, giving his subsequent projection into the modern world, with its relativistic moral view of conflict far greater force. Fourth, the character established in this origin movie remains constant in his future appearances in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, unlike the subsequent iterations of Nolan's Batman. It is the constancy of Cap's character that 'assembles' the superhero team in 'Avengers Assemble', unites it in 'Age of Ultron' and ultimately destroys it in 'Civil War'. By contrast, Nolan's Bruce Wayne grows weary of his crusade against crime in 'The Dark Knight' and seeks to pass the task on to Harvey Dent so as to preserve his relationship with Rachel Dawes (all three developments contrary to Batman canon). In 'Rises', the character is portrayed as an imbecile who understands neither the basic principles of tactics nor elementary detective work. Fifth, Tommy Lee Jones. Sixth, its ending isn't shamelessly ripped off from the train fight in 'Spider-Man 2' (a better movie) and the subway train crash sequence from 'Die Hard with a Vengeance' (an equally good film, but with a far better executed 'crash' sequence than 'Begins').Production and costume design are first rate, particularly Cap's 'operational dress', the interiors of the SSR HQ (clearly based on the actual Churchill War Rooms)and the Valkyrie bomber, the 'exteriors' of 1940s New York and the Red Skull's six-wheel automobile. Overall, one of Marvel's best efforts to date, if not the outright best, IMHO.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interstellar (2014)
7/10
Should be titled Star Trek: Interstellar!
22 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Due to the legion (apparently!) of cinematic (and televisual) ignoramuses who insist that each successive Nolan movie is a greater masterpiece than the previous one, the more educated viewer is required to treat popular (and no small amount of critical) opinion on Nolan's films with scepticism. 'Interstellar' is a case in point. Cutting to the chase: (a) An artificial wormhole that leads from our part of the Galaxy to the other side is straight out of 'Deep Space Nine'. (b) Love as 'wormhole' connecting us with events in our past; again straight from the premiere of DS9. Arguably, the stunning DS9 episode 'The Visitor' examines this same idea to even greater effect. (c) A more advanced form of life intervening in the development of a less advanced one, possibly due to the former having evolved from the latter: DS9 again. (d) Using 'technobabble' to reduce the 'inertial mass' of a space station so that it can be moved closer to the wormhole: DS9 again. (e) Baseball is Benjamin Sisko's favorite sport; the game features in multiple episodes of the show. Although the baseball breaking the window of the house on the space station wall is a beautiful touch! To be sure, 'Interstellar' doesn't confine its 'borrowing' to 'Star Trek'; the explanation of how a wormhole works is lifted directly from 'Event Horizon'. The ending is reminiscent of the 60s movie 'The Time Machine'. Bottom line: like most sci-fi movies, it's neither startlingly original nor deeply philosophical. In fact, the TV show it 'borrows' so freely from did a far better job of presenting the idea that 'love...transcends time and space' than Nolan does here (Anne Hathaway giving what must surely rank as one of her worst performances ever, to boot). If that example of how the 'great' Christopher Nolan couldn't rise above the directorial standards of a TV show isn't bad enough, the execution of the movie's 'celestial temple' sequence, where Cooper communicates with Murph across time, must surely demonstrate to anyone but the most fanatical Nolanite how poorly Nolan ranks as an employer of visual storytelling; the presentation of multiple instances in the timeline of the room could have, and with a better director would have, allowed the audience to infer that the spiritual connection between Cooper and his loved ones was acting as the 'bridge' between him and Murph without Cooper having to baldly say so! This could have been achieved (and this is only one example!) by presenting more of the room's timeline through shots of the earlier stages in the daughter's life, with her mother as an infant, as a toddler with Cooper and her older brother, etc. Interestingly, for a film that asserts that 'love...transcends time and space', none of the characters have any photographs of their departed loved ones! Of course, maybe Nolan simply underestimates the intelligence of his audience and therefore feels it necessary to 'tell' them what's going on instead of 'showing' them, ironic considering how Nolanites consider themselves to be on a higher intellectual level than the average moviegoer. This movie goes absolutely nowhere that other sci-fi movies or TV shows haven't already gone before.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Maybe you just don't get it...
14 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
To me, the most perplexing thing about this movie is how a certain segment of the audience can't accept the Snyder/Batfleck version of Batman: older, more fanatical, hostile to the super powered alien who flattened Bruce Wayne's Metropolis business premises and killed members of his 'family', but who seem to have no issue with the Nolan/Bale interpretation of the character in 'Rises'; an imbecilic, mother-fixated physical wreck (and if you haven't even considered what the pearls might symbolise in that movie, please stop reading now!). For me, the BvS Batman is just another version of the iconic comic book hero; the director even appears to point this out by having 'his' Bruce Wayne witness a vision of a Batman in another reality; one in which the Man of Steel is very much an enemy, the 'point man' for an apocalyptic alien invasion. Personally, I appreciated the manner in which Snyder fuses the version of Arthurian legend from the 1981 movie 'Excalibur' with his Batman/Superman match up, even going so far as to set Bruce's batchelor pad on pretty much the same lakeside where Percival returns Excalibur to the water at the end of that movie(to the strains of 'Siegfried's Funeral March'). By paralleling Superman's death with that of King Arthur (both die fighting an 'abomination', Superman's demise mirroring Arthur's), we are left with the notion of Superman's 'return' when he will be most needed, setting up not only the coming JL movie, but also creating a repentant, redemptive character arc for Batman. The movie could have done with more inspired CGI, more widespread suspicion of Superman's motives in the background and more clarity on Luthor's exact motives (I personally think he was probably originally intended to be much more of a religious nut than a scheming billionaire, but I can see why that would have been toned down!). Also, I would have liked for the distinction between the liberal, elitist ultra-modern Metropolis and run-down, urban wasteland Gotham to have been more clearly defined. As for the 'Martha' moment, I didn't subscribe to the 'dumb and dumber' interpretation when I first saw the movie, and I still don't. Would the Batman of the reality of BvS have reacted to Superman's ultimatum (retire or you're dead) and Luthor's set-up the way he did? Certainly. Would he have relented when Superman's mention of his mother's name made sense of the 'bat-monster' dream, making him realise how far he'd fallen? Of course. And again, why was Snyder's treatment of Bruce Wayne's 'mother issues' pilloried by critics while Nolan's portrayal of a Bruce Wayne so mother-fixated that he: (a) ignores the danger of his stolen fingerprints while getting her pearls back and (b) forms no suspicion of 'Miranda' whatsoever despite the chain of coincidences that placed her in a position to hand over the fusion reactor to Bane? Would a dying man (even Superman) actually use his mother's name in that situation? No, but this is a movie. And isn't the use of 'the child of Ra's Al Ghul' to disguise 'Miranda's' true identity in 'Rises' just as contrived? Would Bruce Wayne seek to redeem himself by taking on the challenge of defending the Earth from the dangers to come? Definitely. That's my tuppence worth, anyway. Maybe I'm completely wrong or maybe, like the Nolanites who don't understand that 'Rises' is woefully written and plotted (or worse, blindly refuse to accept the fact) while levelling similar criticism at BvS, you just don't get it.

NB: This review is for the Ultimate Cut.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Welcome Back, Jim Gordon (2015)
Season 1, Episode 13
6/10
Just torture her, already!!!!!!
28 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I am thoroughly SICK of Jada Pinkett Smith's 'acting' in this show. Having been told by Falcone last week that she will suffer for trying to use his mother's memory as a weapon against him, we see her cuffed and strapped down as one of Falcone's pet psychos decides what to do with her. Does she act scared? No. Does she act defiant? Yes, in a ridiculously over the top way. But for the most part, her line readings and expressions give us every reason to believe that she's actually going to ENJOY what's coming, at least until it looks like she's about to lose a kneecap. Then enter Butch, having performed an escape act worthy of the Batman himself, to the rescue! I felt like throwing something at the screen! I've never wanted to see a TV character suffer so much, and all due to the terrible performance of the actor playing her. Master Wayne didn't cover himself in glory this week, either; his pathetic overtures to Cat were truly cringeworthy. I'm going to take it he was crying due to her finally letting out on herself that she didn't see the Waynes's killer, I just can't accept that the future Batman had his heart stomped on by Catwoman when he was a ten-year old. Only Gordon and Bullock gave value for money this week, Jim's relentless pursuit of the corrupt, murdering Flass seems to be finally getting at least some of the honest cops behind him. Although I'm a little disappointed that Flass seems to have been taken out of play so soon, but the ending might indicate that he's already working on a scheme to get out of the mess he's in. I was also disappointed that Fish seems to have lived to fight another day, Miss Pinkett Smith can't leave the show soon enough as far as I'm concerned. Finally, the less said about Nygma, the better!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: The Fallen (2015)
Season 3, Episode 20
8/10
There wasn't really any choice for Oliver
23 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I'm a little underwhelmed by this week's episode. Minus one star for the absence of Miss K Law, minus one star for reverting to pointless 'Oliver in mortal danger' flashbacks (since he's quite obviously still alive in the show's 'present'). I nearly took another star off for Maseo revealing that his son is dead to Diggle, except that I'd long since deduced it. At least Felicity seems to have finally made up her mind (again!) and chosen Oliver, although her plan to drug Oliver and take him home belies her supposed hyper intelligence. Maseo manages to flip-flop again back onto Oliver's side, although Ra's seems to have been in a forgiving mood this week, maybe since he's finally gotten what he wants. The action sequences were of the usual high standard. The real question now (since it's now quite obvious Batman won't be intervening in this 'demonic' selection process, worse luck)is will the show be still called 'Arrow'?
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: What the Little Bird Told Him (2015)
Season 1, Episode 12
8/10
A fish shouldn't tangle with a penguin!
21 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
No Bruce Wayne or Selina this week, maybe they've worked as much as the law will allow for the moment. We did get Gordon making a high-stakes gamble to get his job back, dragging his now fully fledged partner into it as well. The tracking down of the Electrocutioner was somewhat contrived, but his use of electric shock to take down his enemies was well handled; I particularly liked Oswald unintentionally frying himself in his rush to get to Falcone and snap the trap on fish. As for Moroni, I'm beginning to think that his name is a clue to his IQ level, this being the second time in as many weeks that he's ignored the Penguin's questionable behaviour. Then again, he didn't get to be a boss by being stupid, so maybe he's just playing a long game. Unlike the show's resident ACTRESS, who rushes into the endgame of her scheme to remove Falcone from the top spot. She shouldn't have underestimated Oswald though, who proves to be her undoing, just as we should have suspected by her being called 'fish'! Gordon's gamble pays off thanks to Moroni being the bait in his trap, I particularly liked how he uses violence and smarts to make the collar in this episode. I'm still not liking Nygma though, even if he did suggest the insulated shoes; his creepiness around Miss Kringle isn't working for me at all. I still think he should have been a slightly lesser rival to young Bruce Wayne in the intelligence stakes, maybe in a different school.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: Broken Arrow (2015)
Season 3, Episode 19
8/10
Ray learns to be a hero from Oliver
18 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I have to say I really liked this episode, although it automatically loses a star from me because there's no Katrina in it this week. Roy taking the fall for Oliver, then escaping using the old 'nerve paralyser on the knife' trick worked a hell of a lot better than it should have, mostly due to how it was executed, so 'well done' to cast and crew! This episode also finally convinced me that Brandon Routh isn't just channelling Christopher Reeve, he's actually playing Palmer as a super-intelligent Clark Kent! His almost inane babble to the villain, when he should have been assessing the situation and weighing up tactical options actually made me revise my assessment of how easily Oliver put him down in the 'Suicidal Tendencies' episode; he had it coming for going into battle with an amateur's appreciation of how to fight. Luckily for him, Oliver was on hand to finally push him in the right direction, his takedown move worked really well on screen, though I still think the suit is too clumsy and cheap looking. I'm knocking another star off because of that Felicity hussy; she was practically panting for Oliver even while Ray was standing next to them. Ra's fatally injuring Thea (I assume it's an injury) was a masterstroke, since Oliver has only one option to save her. I'm really looking forward to seeing how this works out!
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Rogues' Gallery (2015)
Season 1, Episode 11
7/10
Something of a letdown after last week.
14 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I'm not really sure what I thought of this episode. Jada Pinkett-Smith was ACTING again rather than acting; Barbara is starting to smell of crazy, making me think Jim might be well rid of her; Cat appeared to be sleeping in a cage. The highlights were Cat and Ivy sneaking into Jim's place (who's paying for that penthouse(?); Gordon would have to be on the take to afford it, and surely Barbara isn't paying for a place she's not living in anymore)and Jim and Harvey's interplay as they start working the asylum case together. I was also pleased that Jim didn't end up strapped to a table as an intended victim; he's been getting himself into those kinds of scrapes a little too often lately!Leslie looks promising, looking forward to seeing her character develop. It was great to see Oswald finally start calling himself 'The Penguin', but Moroni having him locked up to remind him of his place was a little unlikely, but then again, Moroni isn't as smart as he thinks he is. Fish's power play is developing, but something tells me it's going to come seriously unstuck, and not just because Pinkett-Smith isn't returning next season!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: Public Enemy (2015)
Season 3, Episode 18
8/10
Do it like this all the time!
9 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
A strong central story, with subplots that hang off the central narrative and flashbacks that contribute to the main plot. This episode is such a contrast to the last one that they could almost be from different shows! Ra's takes his plan to have Oliver succeed him to it's logical extreme; to drive Oliver out of Star City altogether by revealing his secret to Lance, who duly takes the bait hook, line and sinker in his desire to punish the man whom he believes is responsible for the death of one of his daughters, and for leading his other one into the life of a vigilante. His monologue to Oliver in the police van does bear some truth to it though, particularly when viewed from a lawman's perspective. One has to feel sorry for Ray Palmer though, not only does he have to wear that ridiculous suit for his hero escapades, but he takes an arrow for Felicity, then risks death at her hands from his nanotech medical kit only for her to baulk at his declaration of love for her. And as for Felicity! How dare this harlot look down on her mother for the way she dresses when she's bouncing from one hero's bed to another! Nyssa is already feeling protective of Laurel, as we see her step in to keep her out of jail (and welcome back, Miss Law), the plot is thickening nicely there. Roy has been looking to redeem himself all season, so his throwing himself under the bus for Oliver isn't totally unexpected. I'm not too sure he'll be able to keep his story straight enough for it to bring about Oliver's release, and Ra's is still waiting in the shadows anyway. Maybe Oliver has a red phone tucked away somewhere in the back of the Arrow-cave, if he does, maybe it's time he used it!
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: One Door Closes (2015)
Season 2, Episode 15
9/10
Why can't it be this good every week?
7 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I don't normally review this show, but this most recent episode is my favourite in a long while! Lucy Lawless's Hartley brought so much to the scenes where the heavily outnumbered agents retake the ship from HYDRA (or is it meant to be the helicarrier from 'Avengers Assemble'?) that it's truly a shame that she isn't a regular on the show. Edward James Olmos brings sufficient presence to his part as Gonzales that you can understand how dedicated SHIELD members could support his mutiny against Coulson (Gonzales makes it clear to Coulson when they talk that he knew what the chain of command was, he just refused to accept it). There were no real surprises from any of the main characters, they just behaved exactly as expected, and the episode was all the better for it. It will be interesting to see if trust can be rebuilt once Coulson(inevitably) figures out how to regain control. My only gripe with the episode was Skye; although Chloe Bennett earned her paycheck, her arc is becoming boring in the same way Coulson's did last season. Viewers like me have been complaining that there aren't enough superheroes showing up in the show, then we finally get one and she spends her time NOT using her powers!
10 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Lovecraft (2014)
Season 1, Episode 10
9/10
So, Batman isn't in this show?
7 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I was really impressed with this episode. Even Jada Pinkett-Smith did some acting, rather than ACTING! Gordon is still in Bud White mode, his open contempt for the mayor gets this episode an extra star. While the building jump was very poorly done, Bruce and Selina's escapades while on the run were well handled overall, particularly how Bruce helped Selina see that her life on the street had made her a bit too tough, and kudos to the show runners for the way they handled the kiss at the end! Master Mazouz is a little scrawny, I'll admit, but he has all the intensity you'd expect from the boy who will be Batman. But my highest praise must go to Sean Pertwee, his work on the action sequences this week, even if aided by some stunt doubles here and there, took me back to the 1970s when 'my' Doctor, his father Jon, was the incumbent Doctor Who. I'm not sure that the 'assassins of the week' are actual Batman villains, but the gymnast/contortionist who appeared to be deriving kinky pleasure from choking out her victims was a bit much, even if I found myself wishing Bruce Wayne in 'The Dark Knight Rises' had heeded her advice to young Bruce that courage and good sense aren't the same thing!
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Harvey Dent (2014)
Season 1, Episode 9
8/10
Clever in parts
31 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
It lacked the great violence of last week's episode, and I'm still loathing Jada Pinkett-Smith's 'acting', but I'm still watching. I'm in agreement with those who think that far too many of the iconic villains have been introduced way too early, Penguin should basically been given at least a season to himself, with the likes of Nygma or Dent portrayed as being similar ages to Bruce and Selina, allowing their psychoses to be examined properly, rather than shoehorned in. But now that we have the characters, Dent's sudden flash of near-murderous rage would have worked better if we'd seen more of him as 'Mr Nice Guy' to begin with, but his use of the double headed coin as a trick to help others rather than as a cheat for himself was a nice touch. Bruce and Selina interacted well, and we saw Bruce already beginning to explore the path that will ultimately lead to the Batcave and the Bat-suit, while at the same time taking a misstep that allows Selina to explain just how dangerous an undertaking it will be! The swimming pool scene was kind of dumb though, why Bruce had to train fully dressed escapes me. The bomber was portrayed as having initially been an idealist of some sort, so his building a nail bomb to take out the guards at the munitions factory kind of jarred, personally I considered that more violent than last weeks fistfights. Penguin's discovery of Fish's 'weapon' and Ms Mooney's destruction of a large quantity of Falcone's cash reserves were interesting developments,hopefully that story will continue to hold the interest, Barbara is becoming increasingly disappointing as a character; it's one thing to run away from a traumatising experience, it's another thing again to run straight back to a former lover! Lastly, an appeal to the showrunners; I don't want to see pre-teens sucking face, please. On the other hand, DO NOT make Bruce Wayne too inhibited to take Selina up on her offer!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: The Offer (2015)
Season 3, Episode 16
8/10
Slight drop in quality from last week
27 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I'm still really enjoying the current season of Arrow. Ra's Al Ghul had clearly considered Oliver as a potential replacement prior to their duel; the manner in which he despatched him now making perfect sense, as he needed to see if he would 'survive the blade of Ra's Al Ghul'. Having Oliver give 'The Offer' serious consideration also worked well, particularly since Ra's tells him that he can lead the league in any way he sees fit, although that probably wouldn't actually be the case, a point Oliver was no doubt well aware of. I was a little disappointed that no one even mentioned that a certain Dark Knight wouldn't take news that Oliver had become Ra's Al Ghul well, but that's just me, I guess. I have mixed feelings regarding Nyssa's apparently permanent move to Star City; as a fan of Miss Law, I'm delighted to see more of her, but her father's implied prejudice towards her relationship with Sara is a little unsettling and it seems to me that a man who's lived as long as Ra's would have long since accepted that 'it takes all kinds to make a world'. The suggestion that the 'successor' needs to survive severe wounds inflicted by the 'incumbent' actually provides a strong reason why Ra's wouldn't be prepared to consider his daughter as his replacement. Lance's turning against the Arrow is a logical consequence of what he sees as dishonesty on the Arrow's part, but as he knows Laurel now works with 'Team Arrow' it's a matter that he should probably keep within the family; it's not Oliver's call to break such news, particularly if Laurel didn't want him to. Murmur is a suitably creepy new villain, but I've never heard of 'diamond tipped bullets' as a solution to body armour. Action sequences were up to usual standards, but they need a more suitable stunt double for Matt Nagle, the guy in the arrow suit who did the jump is physically smaller than he is! Apart from Ra's prejudice, my only other gripe this week is with the interminable 'bed-hopping' that plagues this show, Felicity's morals appear to be declining by the week! No sooner has she hooked up with Ray, then she's back mooning over Oliver, a menage a trois appears to be developing.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: The Mask (2014)
Season 1, Episode 8
9/10
Batman begins...
24 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Another excellent episode! I'm delighted to see Gordon get his 'Bud White' on this episode, his undisguised contempt for the cops who turned their back on him in the previous episode and the ass kicking he hands out to the 'job seekers' were both a joy to behold. Kudos also to young Master Mazouz; I was a little disappointed that he didn't have enough in the tank to put Tommy Elliott down the first time, but once Batman's righteous anger began to flow at the end of the episode, the ferocity of his attack fully justified his casting as the nascent Dark Knight. Penguin's machinations are grinding away nicely, I'm hoping he has a large part in the downfall of Fish Mooney, who richly deserves what's coming to her! I'm still not sold on Nygma; his playing M.E. this week was more delusions of grandeur than superiority complex. Harvey's return to the light is also shaping up nicely, Logue is playing him with just the right blend of diminishing cynicism. Cat being smart enough to successfully bypass a high spec security system to rob a fur store, yet childish enough to think she could get away with literally daylight robbery could have been dumb, yet it worked thanks to the actress playing the part. I'm very interested to see how she and Bruce Wayne interact.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: Nanda Parbat (2015)
Season 3, Episode 15
9/10
When is Nyssa getting her own show?
19 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Seriously though, Ms Law was one of the best things about this week's episode. The ATOM suit was probably the worst; it looks really cheap and vaguely ridiculous. Yet the more I see of Brandon Routh (literally this week, though he seems to have gained a little weight round the middle) the more I'm convinced that he should still be Superman. Much as I enjoyed the character interactions this week (and please, can Felicity just be left with Ray? All this bed-hopping is getting boring) they were really only preamble to Malcolm's capture and torture at Nanda Parbat and I was so delighted that Malcolm practically cried when Ra's sentenced to him to his long overdue death, the right acting choice from Mr Barrowman for a change! It was probably inevitable that Oliver and Dig would be captured however, but the 'offer' was really well done, even though I knew it was coming, I was still impressed. But shouldn't Oliver be bummed that he's the second choice after Batman?
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Penguin's Umbrella (2014)
Season 1, Episode 7
9/10
Clever title, great episode...but
18 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
At long last, an excellent episode arrives, marred only slightly by Jada Pinkett Smith's execrable 'acting' and by a shoddy plot device. Gordon learned how truly alone he is as the GCPD's single honest cop, although I was pleased to see Bullock stand up to be counted (once he was out of other options, of course!). While Victor Zsasz made a suitably creepy and psychotic debut, I've always considered the character as little more than an aspect of the Joker given a life of its own; hopefully the writers have something interesting planned for him and his leather clad female associates to justify his inclusion in the show. Gordon's plan was a bold move, showing him taking control of the situation even though I'm not sure how it could have worked out for the best. It was logical that Barbara would be Falcone's hostage, although personally I'd have preferred if Zsasz had located her rather than her being portrayed as stupid, coming up with a terrible plan of her own rather than taking her fiancé's advice. Gordon's first links with the MCU being formed in these circumstances was another nice touch. I was a little unhappy with how Bruce was handled in this episode though, he was a little too emotional at Gordon's departure, to my mind. Though the highlight of the episode has to be the revelation that Falcone has been Penguin's 'umbrella' all this time; the manner in which he is shown to be so far ahead of the rest of the city's crime bosses making it clear why he is the one they all need to be afraid of, while at the same time, Gordon is now effectively under Penguin's 'umbrella' himself!
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: The Return (2015)
Season 3, Episode 14
8/10
Oliver really should have seen it coming!
13 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Considering how much of a snake Macolm Merlyn has proved himself to be, Oliver really should have expected that Slade would be at large on the island! Though I enjoyed seeing Manu Bennett making a brief return to the show, adding an extra edge to the fight scenes as well as making a few sharp observations on our hero's psyche. I also enjoyed how the writers threw in a few jokes at the expense of the show's absurdities, making Oliver astounded at just how much Thea learned from Malcolm in 9 months, as well as Maseo's crack about how ineffective a hood and greasepaint streak would be as a disguise! However, having gone to the trouble of poking fun at earlier 'stupids', we then see Oliver recover a pistol from a grave (two absurdities for one really, a pistol most probably wouldn't work having been so poorly stored for that long and, more obviously, why didn't they take some guns with them in the first place?) that we hear functioning perfectly when required later in the episode. What could have been little more than a filler episode managed to develop things plot-wise; Thea refusing to follow the path Merlyn had set out for her, culminating in her rejection of him as her father; Laurel, by contrast, alienating her father through her keeping Sara's death from him; Oliver being increasingly shown as a man of 'heroic' integrity, returning to help a friend in trouble in the flashback, coming clean to Thea about Sara's death. As the episode ends, we see Malcolm still maintaining that refusing to kill will be Oliver's downfall, in fact he even suggests it was how he lost to Ra's the first time. This 'hesitation' idea hasn't really been as fully developed as it most probably should have, considering where the story is going next!
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Spirit of the Goat (2014)
Season 1, Episode 6
8/10
It's about time!
10 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
So, I watched Gotham Ep 6 last night more out of duty than desire; to my surprise I actually enjoyed (almost) every minute of it! We see a younger Harvey Bullock back in his idealistic days, taking down a suitably creepy serial killer, but causing his partner to be invalided off the force in the process. Ten years later ( a la 'True Detective', maybe?) it looks like the killer has managed to return from the dead, but through something resembling detective work, our heroes track him to the same hideout he used previously (the first bum note in the episode; it doesn't even look like the place has even changed in any way over the intervening decade!). It then transpires that the two killers were in fact the victims of a hypnotherapist who was using them as proxies in a campaign to punish Gotham's elite for allowing the city to fall into the hands of organised crime, the death of the Waynes apparently the motivation for the more recent 'Goat' abductions/murders. And to top it off, while Harvey wraps up the case, Gordon is arrested for Oswald's murder, only for 'penguin' to show up at GCPD HQ just as Gordon is about to be booked. This was the first episode I've seen that didn't feature Fish Mooney,and it was all the better for it. Jada Pinkett-Smith's 'acting' is by far the worst thing about the show, so I'm delighted to hear she won't be returning for season 2. The treatment of vigilantes in the show so far presents them as a menace, rather than a blessing, which no doubt will influence Gordon's attitude to the arrival of the Dark Knight in the future. Nygma's interest in Miss Kringle is too creepy; some of his behaviour borders on sexual harassment, some of it practically stalking, none of it evidence of a massive superiority complex. Selina Kyle needs to be doing more than skulking around in the background; it's high time she and Bruce met properly. Overall, a vast improvement in this episode, let's hope it stays like this.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: Canaries (2015)
Season 3, Episode 13
9/10
Cracking episode!
5 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
After the stupidity of last week's 'Uprising', this week we get a 'why can't they all be this good?' sort of episode! Laurel confronts her issues about her sister's demise through being injected with Vertigo (twice!)and in resolving them, seems to have found her feet as a crime-fighter. Oliver finally tells Thea the truth, to find that she is overjoyed that her brother is actually the city's hero, rather than an ex-billionaire wastrel (one of the best scenes in the show so far, in my humble opinion). It was also interesting to see Oliver's former 'team' demonstrate that they're not just there to take orders anymore; the way they had to adapt to his apparent death having changed the way they see themselves, while at the same time Oliver's leadership in creating a team that could carry on once their leader had apparently fallen was another very good touch. Thea's disappointing performance when actually fighting for her life for the first time post-training struck a duff note, however, since it had never been suggested before now that her fears were inhibiting her; it would have been better if her lack of killer instinct (which has been mentioned several times) had resulted in her being overpowered even though she had gained the upper hand. Also, if Capt Lance can figure out who every other member of 'Team Arrow' is, how come he still can't add two and two and come up with Oliver?
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Viper (2014)
Season 1, Episode 5
7/10
An improvement on last week.
4 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
An interesting episode overall, some good developments in several story lines. The links between Wayne Enterprises and Gotham's underworld are starting to become visible as Master Wayne starts to develop his detection skills; the manner in which Alfred is finally converted to his cause being well handled, though I'm not sure I like the idea that Venom is in fact a Wayne Enterprises product, nor that it will have existed for over a decade by the time the Batman begins his crusade. Selina's all-too brief appearance this episode was one of the highlights, the skills she will employ as Catwoman already well developed; it's high time she and Bruce encountered each other! The police work this week was a little less by-the-numbers, nice to see the cops do some detective work rather than have things spelled out for them. I still think placing Edward Nygma in the GCPD crime lab was a terrible idea, but there's still time to fix this by making him E Nygma senior! Jada Pinkett Smith's 'acting' seems to get worse from week to week, as a major plot driver, this is a very bad thing! As for her 'weapon' against Falcone, if he's too dumb to figure out that he's being lured into a honey trap, maybe he IS ready to be overthrown. I'm looking forward to next week's episode, but I'm still not completely sold yet.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: Uprising (2015)
Season 3, Episode 12
6/10
Probably the worst episode of the season so far.
27 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Having given viewers an alternative version of 'The Dark Knight Rises' at the end of season 2, 'Uprising' gives us a cheap recreation of the dumb climax of that movie, complete with people who forget they have guns and use their fists instead! Having been bulletproof in his first appearance, Vinnie Jones's 'Brick' is now vulnerable to knuckles, and loses a fist fight with John Barrowman (yes, I know he's Malcolm Merlyn, but I find the idea of Mr Jones getting his ass kicked by Capt Jack Harkness risible somehow!)! How come he shrugs off a bullet to the head, yet goes down from a few punches? The Malcolm flashback sequences might have been less laughable if they hadn't given Malcolm that awful haircut, but the 'showdown' with the man he believed killed his wife felt rushed and perfunctory, maybe it should have been built up to over a few episodes. Oliver's return was also poorly done, borrowing from TDKR to give the city some kind of spectacular message that the Arrow was back would actually have been a good idea here. But by far the dumbest plot twist was Oliver's decision to have Merlyn train him to fight Ra's Al Ghul. The idea that he would turn to the man who set him up to be killed by the head of the League of Assassins, who in fact set him up to be killed because he couldn't beat him himself, makes absolutely no sense whatever, not to mention the reversal of principles involved that alienate him from Felicity. So, overall I considered this episode disappointing, and in the ways it borrowed from TDKR actually kind of stupid.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Arrow: Midnight City (2015)
Season 3, Episode 11
8/10
So he was just implausibly lucky, then...
20 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I think I would have actually preferred if Oliver had been revived using the Lazarus pit, rather than simply surviving what has turned out to be a botched execution! This, combined with his escape from the league of assassins search team, makes the whole set-up by Malcolm redundant, including Sara's murder by a doped-up Thea (how much dope would that have actually needed? She can't even figure out that Oliver is Arrow!). So, unless the writers intended for Laurel to become Canary all along, then a fairly major character has been killed off for nothing more than shock value (and it was a pretty effective shock). That said, I like Laurel as Canary, though I guess she'll be learning the whole vigilante thing the hard way, if her experiences this week are anything to go by. It looks like the producers may have decided to stop putting the characters in cliffhangers in the flashbacks too, our 'heroes' never looked like they were in any real danger in the nightclub scene in this episode. Vinnie Jones's character needs some kind of background explanation of why he seems to be bulletproof, yet takes an arrow to the shoulder this week. I'm curious as to how the league of assassins is actually keeping a very close eye on Thea, and presumably Merlyn, while at the same time Ra's Al Ghul managed to be suckered by Merlyn's ploy to shift the blame to Oliver. And now I'm back to that, if Ra's wanted Oliver's dead body that badly, why didn't he kill him properly without kicking him off a cliff?
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotham: Arkham (2014)
Season 1, Episode 4
7/10
The hit-man steals someone's identity, then tells clients what that identity is?
16 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
My mouth actually dropped open when this moment of monumentally STUPID plotting occurred; our heroes(?) go to where the hit-man works, having tracked him through his stolen identity! So, having gone to the trouble of killing someone and assuming their life, he gives the game away by hiring himself out as a killer under his assumed name? The cops in this city aren't just corrupt, they're criminally stupid to boot. The hit-man having the initials of the three cops on security at the Mayor's house written down is one of the most ridiculously obvious plot devices ever. I still personally don't like the Waynes' killer being some kind of hit-man, but at least their deaths are being shown as part of a bigger scheme to allow organised crime to increase it's stranglehold on Gotham, something that would serve to motivate the young Bruce in his desire to wage war on Falcone, Moroni, et al. As for young Master Wayne, despite what some have said elsewhere, I find it very easy to see this traumatised boy becoming the Batman; his parents were no doubt already concerned at his brooding and intense behaviour before that fateful night! Much as I want to keep watching, and much as I hate to say this, the police work needs to actually become detection rather than exposition if the show is to hold my interest much longer!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

Recently Viewed