First let me state that All in the Family is one of my all-time favorite TV shows. Part of its appeal was its willingness to take on controversial topics that simply were not discussed at the time on television. The acting and writing were first rate. And it effectively blended serious topical issues into a comedic format. In short, a brilliant show.
Nonetheless, and despite Norman Lear's track record of pushing the envelope, it was a mistake to make the two-part Edith's 50th Birthday episode, an awkward and disturbing show. It unnecessarily revisited themes already presented in the more sedate season 3 episode "Gloria, the Victim". We already saw the trauma of someone accosted by a stranger and the reluctance of victims to identify and/or hold their attackers responsible. Why do it again in even more traumatic circumstances? Supporters of the episode will suggest that's the point of a show depicting sexual assault; to make the viewer rightly uncomfortable while watching such a horrible event. But for my tastes, this was too much of a departure from traditional All in the Family. And that's really saying something given this show successfully tackled everything from menopause to abortion to race relations.
I've probably seen every episode of All in the Family two dozen times. Not so with Edith's 50th Birthday, which I won't watch again.
Nonetheless, and despite Norman Lear's track record of pushing the envelope, it was a mistake to make the two-part Edith's 50th Birthday episode, an awkward and disturbing show. It unnecessarily revisited themes already presented in the more sedate season 3 episode "Gloria, the Victim". We already saw the trauma of someone accosted by a stranger and the reluctance of victims to identify and/or hold their attackers responsible. Why do it again in even more traumatic circumstances? Supporters of the episode will suggest that's the point of a show depicting sexual assault; to make the viewer rightly uncomfortable while watching such a horrible event. But for my tastes, this was too much of a departure from traditional All in the Family. And that's really saying something given this show successfully tackled everything from menopause to abortion to race relations.
I've probably seen every episode of All in the Family two dozen times. Not so with Edith's 50th Birthday, which I won't watch again.
Tell Your Friends