Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Pure cinematic intoxication!
11 May 2005
Director Alan J. Pakula's film, a departure from his conspiracy and suspense dramas, is an adaptation of William Styron's best-selling novel of the same name. The story itself is based on his experiences as a southerner living in Brooklyn in 1947.

Pakula essentially preserves the structure of Styron's novel as it begins with the arrival of Stingo, an aspiring young writer, in post - WWII Brooklyn. After settling into a boarding house, he meets a unique couple that offers him alternating support and heartbreak.

He befriends the Jewish biologist, Nathan (Kevin Kline), and his girlfriend, Sophie Zawistowska (Meryl Streep), a Polish refugee and Auschwitz survivor. But their relationship is clouded by Nathan's violent behaviour, his uncontrollable jealousy, and Sophie's unexpressed but troubling memories of war. Her stories about her life during the war begin to unravel, exposing her as a liar and adding a tone of mystery to the relationship between Nathan, Stingo, and herself.

The film culminates in a flashback, reflecting the horrors of the war and the true cause of Sophie's insufferable pain and the bitter choice she had to make…

Streep deservedly won an Oscar and a Golden Globe for Best Actress, bringing on the tears, playing both a naive girl and a worldly woman, transforming herself into a Holocaust victim and survivor. Speaking flawlessly in a Polish accent and acceptable German, she basically became Sophie Zawistowska.

And while Streep is undoubtedly the star, both Kevin Kline and Peter MacNicol deserve credit for making 'Sophie's Choice' work as well as it does.

While overall this is Stingo's coming of age story, at its central core we get drawn into Sophie's saga. Pakula uses an Emily Dickinson poem to frame her story:

Ample make this bed.Make this bed with awe; In it wait till judgment break excellent and fair. Be its mattress straight, be its pillow round; Let no sunrise' yellow noise interrupt this ground.

The reference to the bed is the key to understanding Sophie's persona. She relies on Nathan's physical love, even as he abuses her, to cope with her Auschwitz ghosts.

Nestor Almendros' delicately lit cinematography, with its complex levels of saturation and subtle impositions of shadow, has often been meticulously replicated. The flesh tones are perfect, the image is solid and the colours, when in full bloom, are exquisitely formed. Equally effective is the use of music created by Marvin Hamlisch. Two themes are effectively intertwined throughout the story – both melancholic.

Though the film deals with the Holocaust, it doesn't graphically show Nazi horrors, but rather refers to them abstractly, making it more effective. 'Sophie's Choice' provides the emotional core of the horror and shows what devastating experiences the survivors must deal with. For Pakula, the film was an artistic highpoint and his most deeply felt work. Undoubtedly, 'Sophie's Choice' remains his most powerful, highly distinctive drama.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Talk to Her (2002)
7/10
An evocative, lush masterpiece!
11 May 2005
Internationally acclaimed Spanish filmmaker Pedro Almodovar, known for his daring forays into the weird and unexpected, is back with the aptly titled 'Talk To Her,' arguably his most accomplished feature.

Most beguiling amalgamation of Almodovar's pet themes, this is about two men, about the loneliness and long convalescence of the wounds provoked by passion. The film carries the offbeat tone of his earlier work, while channelling the richness and textures of modern Spain.

Easily categorized as a drama, Almodovar plays with structures with elements of flashbacks and ambiguous story lines about the film's central characters.

The film begins with two men, who don't know each other, sitting next to each other, watching a ballet. Both are moved by the story and movement. One of them is Benigno (Javier Camera), a nurse, who is taking care of a beautiful, young ballet dancer, Alicia (Leonor Watling). Alicia has now been in a coma for four years. Benigno is in love with her and talks to her about the ballet, while massaging and washing her body.

The other man is an Argentinean travel writer, Marco (Dario Grandinetti), who is currently working on an assignment on a female bullfighter, Lydia (Rosario Flores). Through flashbacks, we learn how Marco became enchanted with Lydia and her vocation as a matador. However, when Lydia is attacked by a bull and falls into coma, Marco blames his blooming relationship with Lydia as the cause of her fatal lack of concentration. And it is at the clinic that Marco discovers Alicia and meets Benigo. Thus, is the beginning of an intense friendship, as linear as a roller coaster. During the time suspended within the walls of the clinic, the life of these four characters flows in all directions, leading all of them to an unexpected destiny…

Nominated for 2 Categories, the movie won an Oscar for Best Writing, Screenplay Written Directly for the Screen - Pedro Almodovar and the Golden Globe Award for Best Foreign Language Film - Spain.

In the roles of the two central characters, Javier Camera and Dario Grandinetti are brilliant, straight men at their most vulnerable and torturous. The brilliance of the film is in its script, as Almodovar brings flaws and human enlightenment to the characters. While as a director, knows when to build up moments of suspense, comedy, and melodrama. The art direction by Antxon Gomez is exquisitely ravishing, especially the ballet scenes with lovely set decoration by Federico G. Cambero.

Another lovely aspect of the film is the score by Alberto Iglesias, who brings in traditional, Spanish flamenco-style music to the forefront.

Along the way, paying tribute to the age of Silent films, 'Talk To Her' is a movie of technical skill and rare depth of intellect and feeling!
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed