Review of The Breach

The Breach (1970)
8/10
Chabrol's attack on the bourgeoisie disguised as a thriller
14 May 2005
Warning: Spoilers
The plot: Charles (Jean-Claude Drouot) is a tentative writer with a drug problem who goes berserk and attacks his own wife Hélène (Stéphane Audran) and their baby boy in a rage fit (in yet another of those amazing Chabrol opening sequences!). Hélène files for divorce and custody of their child, but Charles' wealthy father Régnier (Michel Bouquet) is ready to fight dirty for the boy's custody: Régnier promises money and a job to shady Paul Thomas (Jean-Pierre Cassel) if he can find out nasty things about Hélène. As Paul tries hard but fails to find skeletons in Hélène's closet, he begins to scheme foul plans to do her in. But things go terribly wrong.

"La Rupture" (1970) is a study about misleading appearances and the destructive power of money and of social conventions. In the film, conventions play a very important part: Hélène used to be a stripper so people assume she's something of a whore, which she wasn't and isn't. Régnier is a rich and respectable bourgeois, but ready to play dirty to have things his own way. Paul is seductive, funny and good-looking, so everybody likes him -- even Hélène -- though he is rotten to the core.

The film belongs to a very rich period in Claude Chabrol's career, including "Les Biches" (1968), "Une Femme Infidèle" (1969) and "Le Boucher" (1970), all of them Hitchcockian in surface but much darker, more violent and tragic, rather closer to Fritz Lang in core, acid criticism and virulent spirit. These four films portray Chabrol's perennial (self)-criticism on the French bourgeoisie, while dealing with apparently "normal" characters going berserk (Jean-Claude Drouot here, Jacqueline Sassard in "Les Biches", Jean Yanne in "Le Boucher", Michel Bouquet in "Une Femme Infidèle"). They all star his then-wife, beautiful, fascinating Stéphane Audran, here in a terrific performance, whose detached acting style, world-weary heavy-lidded eyes, fabulous legs, peerless cheekbones and deceptively cold sexiness is only comparable to the 1930s Dietrich.

In "La Rupture", not everything in the plot strives to be "believable" - this is not the standard Hollywood thriller! It's rather a tragedy with surrealistic overtones and a very black sense of humor. To fully enjoy it, one must forget about "plot logic" and marvel at the rich character study, particularly of the main trio (Hélène, Régnier, Paul) but also the supporting characters depicting the "evil ways" of human nature (Régnier's wife; the three MacBethian "witches" who live at the pension; the understanding lawyer; the pension landlady and her alcoholic husband played by the great Jean Carmet; Paul's nymphomaniac girlfriend etc). What is refreshing with "La Rupture", as in Chabrol's best movies, is that things never happen the way we expect them to - there's always a welcome offbeat element waiting around the corner.

Don't watch this film if you only like thrillers with Cartesian logic, lots of action and gunshots; but do watch this if you like to see an experienced, talented filmmaker in full power of his craft who, though dealing with a below par material (the novel on which the film is based), manages to make a virulent attack on social conventions while thoroughly entertaining you. PS: The final scene may be too symbolic, psychedelic and "loose" for some tastes -- but that was 1970, folks!
32 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed