7/10
Spolied a bit by the ending
30 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
The highlight of this film is definitely the performance of Scott Thomas as the ex-convict returning to live with her sister and family after 15 years in prison. Her gaunt face is ideal for the character struggling to return to normal life with a family she doesn't know. She in uncomfortable with the loving welcome she gets from her sister. The tension builds as we gradually find out why she went to prison and why she had lost contact with her family.

I thought the film was excellent until the very end when rather far fetched "revelations" spoiled the film a bit for me. The director seemed to want to give the film a "happy" ending that was a bit unnecessary.

In fact the thought struck me that the film seemed perfect for a Hollywood remake with a new happy ending tacked on…and with Michelle Pfeiffer in the main role in a desperate bid for credibility as a dramatic actor! However the original version already has the feel good twist.

Still a good story and excellent performances all round make this film well worth seeing.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed