I don't really remember the 1989 version of this comic, probably not a bad thing, but I do remember the 2004 version. While I thought the 2004 version was not a bad film it felt nothing like the comic book character I grew up reading. My biggest mistake was thinking that this film (2008) was going to be like the 2004 one and so I avoided going to see it in the theater. My Mistake!! I recently viewed the film on DVD and was pleased. This film was better than the previous two in almost every way; from lead actor, to story setting, and to villains. The films ending was a bit rushed and weak but all in all a great adaptation.
The opening fight scene was the first indicator that this film was on the right track. The Punisher punished, without remorse or hesitation, those that needed punishing. The actor (Ray Stevenson) who portrayed the Punisher did a great job in portraying the Punishers hard side as well as his softer side, as when dealing with the victims, and seemed to be born to play this role.
My guess is that if you grew up reading the Punisher comics than this film will appeal to you. If you're first encounter with the Punisher was the 2004 film it may not appeal to you. Personally I hope Marvel gives this franchise one more chance and authorizes a sequel.
The opening fight scene was the first indicator that this film was on the right track. The Punisher punished, without remorse or hesitation, those that needed punishing. The actor (Ray Stevenson) who portrayed the Punisher did a great job in portraying the Punishers hard side as well as his softer side, as when dealing with the victims, and seemed to be born to play this role.
My guess is that if you grew up reading the Punisher comics than this film will appeal to you. If you're first encounter with the Punisher was the 2004 film it may not appeal to you. Personally I hope Marvel gives this franchise one more chance and authorizes a sequel.