7/10
great fun to watch with a couple caveats
30 March 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Well worth watching -- all the more because it's based on what actually happened in real life during World War II.

A couple issues bothered me, though. At one point, the Clifton Webb character goes, with his assistant, to wait for the spy at the bank. It wasn't clear to me what they would have done if the spy had actually shown up at the bank. This is never explained.

Later, when the spy reveals his address to ascertain whether the identity of the dead man is true or not, the initial reaction of British intelligence is to try to pick up the spy.

But the Clifton Webb character should have prepared for this in advance. Think of it this way -- a German spy comes to verify the authenticity of the dead man. If you try to engage with him in any way that might arouse suspicion, you've essentially blow the whole operation and given the game away. Best thing to do is to give him a wide berth until the Sicily invasion has commenced.

Eventually, the Clifton Webb character realizes this, but only just in the nick of time.

On reflection, my guess is that the real character, that Clifton Webb was portraying, probably did foresee the wisdom of not engaging with the spy and also kept British intelligence from interfering way in advance. In other words, the way it happens in the movie was done mostly for dramatic effect.

For me these two points didn't ring true.

Other than that, it was fun and exciting to watch.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed