Sherlock: A Study in Pink (2010)
Season 1, Episode 1
5/10
Unaired pilot, the copycat...
19 February 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Firstly, why in God's name they made the unaired plot again? The only difference was that this episode contained more scenes other than those from the 0 episode. I had to admit I liked some of them, because they brought explanations to the plot, but why couldn't they made only one episode with all the scenes that the episode should have, it would have made a greater impact.

The problem with the copied scenes from 0 episode wasn't that they were copied, was that they weren't played that brilliantly like in the first episode, and only the fact that were shown twice, made them horrible at times.

Last but not least, Sherlock realizes that the killer should be someone who could go unseen and take people without any suspicions, but then after chasing the taxi, and talking with the killer at his home, he realizes the same thing he realized before, so what's the point? Basically what Sherlock realized was doubled in the same episode because of bad script(and I'm not referring to bad original script but bat copied). I don't know what was the point of all the twist with this taxi, the double realizing of Sherlock and overall the copycat episode. Sorry but this was just boring and bad, and not good enough, my vote is 5/10.
11 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed