Frank Darabont as a director has only made 4 films. The most highly rated are "The Shawshank redempion" (1994) and "The green mile" (1999). At first glance these films have much in common. Both adapted from a book written by Stephen King, both situated in a prison and both about the friendship between a white and a black man.
In fact the films are far more different than you are inclined to think. "The green mile" is more shocking as it is on death row. The story of "The green mile" also involves a supernatural element that "The Shawshank ... " as a more pure character study is missing.
The character that contributes the most to the dfference between the two movies is the character of the black man. In "The Shawshank ... " Morgan Freeman plays the wise experienced inmate Ellis Redding. In "The green mile" Michael Duncan plays the somewhat ambigious John Coffey. On the hand he is a simpleton, reminding me of Lennie from "Of mice and men" (John Steinbeck). On the other hand he is "a force of nature" (I can't thnk of another discription that would not give away too much of the plot) whose initials only are very telling.
Personally I prefer "The Shawshank redemption", which is more of a psycholigical drama. This is not to say that "The green mile" is only plot driven. With a running time of more than 3 hours Darabont takes his time to make individuals of his characters.
In "The green mile" the guards are on average much more friendly than in "The Shawshank ... ". There is one exception by the name of Percy Wetmore (Doug Hutchison). I think in preparing for his role Doug has taken a good look at Donald Sutherland as Attila in "Novecento" (1976, Bernardo Bertolucci).
In fact the films are far more different than you are inclined to think. "The green mile" is more shocking as it is on death row. The story of "The green mile" also involves a supernatural element that "The Shawshank ... " as a more pure character study is missing.
The character that contributes the most to the dfference between the two movies is the character of the black man. In "The Shawshank ... " Morgan Freeman plays the wise experienced inmate Ellis Redding. In "The green mile" Michael Duncan plays the somewhat ambigious John Coffey. On the hand he is a simpleton, reminding me of Lennie from "Of mice and men" (John Steinbeck). On the other hand he is "a force of nature" (I can't thnk of another discription that would not give away too much of the plot) whose initials only are very telling.
Personally I prefer "The Shawshank redemption", which is more of a psycholigical drama. This is not to say that "The green mile" is only plot driven. With a running time of more than 3 hours Darabont takes his time to make individuals of his characters.
In "The green mile" the guards are on average much more friendly than in "The Shawshank ... ". There is one exception by the name of Percy Wetmore (Doug Hutchison). I think in preparing for his role Doug has taken a good look at Donald Sutherland as Attila in "Novecento" (1976, Bernardo Bertolucci).