I'm not a fan of romantic comedies, but I'm always open minded enough to give any film a chance. Hilary Swank is a very good actress, and this is the only reason I'm giving this film 2 stars instead of 1. Gerard Butler is generally a good actor as well, however... Yes, we get you're Irish, mate, but the accent and all of that.. so exaggerated and unnecessary. It's as if the screenplay read: "just be the Irishest Irishman who ever Irished." Ridiculously cheesy story, too many plot holes. This is a film that was destined to be a "blockbuster" because it address the issues of cancer and unfulfillable longing, aspects anyone could relate to... Except it's done in a very cheap and primitive manner.
Review of P.S. I Love You
