Review of Spendthrift

Spendthrift (1936)
8/10
A buried treasure of a film
6 November 2022
Townsend "Towny" Middleton (Henry Fonda) finds out that he, who inherited twenty million dollars from his parents, is broke. He has his old money name and all of the trapping of wealth - mansion, polo ponies, art - but no cash. He sells his polo ponies so he can take his racehorse Black Mamba to the Kentucky Derby, possibly winning the cash prize there. Along for the ride is his personal secretary/close friend Bill McGuire (Ed Brophy) and Black Mamba's trainer Boots (Pat Paterson). While at the derby Towny meets Sally Barnaby (Mary Brian), and the two fall in love. Towny explains to her that he is broke, but she doesn't seem to be listening. Is it that love is stronger than poverty, or is it that greed is usually deaf? Watch and find out.

This is an awkward attempt at screwball comedy, although I liked it a great deal on the whole. It is more like a satire and social commentary on the idle rich and greed versus generosity. Henry Fonda's Towny is not so much a spendthrift as he is a rather clueless young man drifting through life until his sudden penniless state makes him grow up in a hurry. Towny is like an early stab at Fonda's role in "The Lady Eve" as the same kind of fellow, with Ed Brophy behaving like an early prototype of William Demarest's Muggsy in that same movie.

The supporting cast really makes this film - George Barbier as Towny's perpetually angry uncle, Ed Brophy as Towny's protector who may have a limited vocabulary but is quite the wheeler dealer, and Pat Paterson as the trainer of Towny's horses who is also nursing an unrequited love for the guy. Paterson left acting a couple of years after this film, having married Charles Boyer a few years before. The two had a long happy marriage ending in 1978 with Paterson's death.

I would highly recommend this, but have patience with it. It takes a few minutes to get rolling.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed