User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Collaboration
boblipton16 November 2018
Elmer Booth and pal Charles Gorman commit yet another crime, and adopted brother Robert Harron turns them over to the police. Then they escape from prison, vowing vengeance.

It's Christy Cabanne's third movie as director, and D.W. Griffith is credited as the co-director. What does that mean in this context, when Griffith was supervising all of Biograph's production? Did he direct part of the movie and Cabanne the rest? Did he retake some scenes, or did Cabanne? Did Cabanne act as second unit director before the term was coined? Did their bosses decide that it looked better for the trade papers if Griffith was credited as director?

I can't tell anything from looking at the movie. It looks like the standard Biograph product at the time, with fine camerawork and performances. The story is a little corny, but not particularly so for the Victorian-minded Griffith, even if Cabanne was the writer.

There's an almost automatic tendency to downgrade all of Cabanne's efforts, based on his Poverty Row westerns made on non-existent budgets thirty years later. However, well into the sound era, whenever he was given any money, or even a good actor down on his luck, he could turn out something interesting.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It exploits Sunday school virtues
deickemeyer8 November 2017
A picture that will not wholly escape the charge that it exploits Sunday school virtues or virtues that are conventionally and unconvincingly shown. Among its characters, it has a very good adopted brother, a brute of a big brother who drinks, a drunken book writer who turns out to be the hero's helper, and a couple of thugs. The rest are Western village characters. This reviewer cannot say that he enjoyed the picture, but it was made for a certain public that can safely be counted as fair. - The Moving Picture World, September 13, 1913
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed