Greedy Humpty Dumpty (1936) User Reviews

really old but classic

[yeahhyeahyeah · 8/10 · 3 September 2007]

I'm only 16 years old but for some strange reason when I was really young we had a collection of cartoons from earlier decades, including this movie.

I have no idea why we had them, but anyway my brother and I used to watch this short, along with numerous others (I don't know their names I just remember the plots) almost every single day. For some reason it didn't scare me.

It was great, even though I vaguely remember it. Kind of twisted, probably not great for little kids. It teaches a good lesson though! You're never going to find me building weak infrastructure..

The Incredible Egg Monster!

[Mister-UHF · 6/10 · 19 July 2003]

Although the copy of this cartoon that I saw recently on the Classic Arts Showcase (ARTS) was somewhat faded, it did show the artistic and technical skill for which the Fleischers were justly famous. It also shows the weird streak that runs through many of their films.

In this cartoon, Humpty Dumpty is not just the chatty fellow who fell off the wall, but a tyrannical king who has an insatiable appetite for gold, constantly bellows a sinister laugh, and turns cruel at the drop of a hat. He reminds me a lot of Tybo the Carrot Monster from the "Lost In Space" episode "The Great Vegetable Rebellion."

Little wonder that the Fleischers later produced "Superman" cartoons with larger than life villains and outlandish situations.

Memorable but somewhat disturbing for a young child

[jonesack · 6/10 · 23 March 2021]

This is more of a comment than a review. I vividly remember this as 5 or 6 year old in the 50's. For me then, it was compelling and also somewhat scary and surrealistic. The message certainly got across though!

Memorable

[sbibb1 · 10 July 2004]

Growing up as a kid in the 80s, "Greedy Humpty Dumpty" was one of the more memorable cartoons for me. This cartoon was, and still is available on VHS and DVD by numerous companies as it is Public Domain. Humpty Dumpty is the king and when he learns that there is gold in the sun he decides he wants it. He forces all the people who live in his kingdom (who are all characters from other famous fairy tales) to build him a golden tower that will reach the sun. When the tower is built Humpty Dumpty is too greedy and crashes to earth and shatters. Some segments of this cartoon were filmed with the rotoscoping process, in which live actors were filmed, and then those films were traced by animators to get realistic movement for the characters. This cartoon has very memorable songs.

Greed is the name of the game!

[Foreverisacastironmess123 · 7/10 · 29 July 2013]

Interesting little animation loosely based on one of the most odd and mysterious fairytale characters. Well, in this take on the 'story', they make Humpty the king, and he's sure not a very nice one! I'd say it was the right thing to make ol' Dumpty a cruel and ill-tempered tyrant as to me the character already is kind of offbeat and creepy you begin with! I mean, he's just an egg-man who sits there, falls off and splats. And the way he looks in this as he cackles and waves his little limbs around is rather grotesque! I like the neat little touch just before the yolk-filled despot covets the freaking sun itself, where he's surrounded by his vast riches and his little stack of coins topple over, foreshadowing the ending. I love how amazing and beautiful the little effect is when Dumpty imagines the sun as gleaming solid gold for a moment. The actions of the storybook characters are kinda basic but I loved the sequence where the tower is built, I think it still looks great to this day, the way they construct it upwards in a spiral. It's quite outlandish and bizarre when Humpty finally does reach and cracks open the sun, releasing a lightning stick-figure which proceeds to spank him, which is *so* a mannerism that you'd only ever get in a Fleischer animation! He is smited good by the sun, and even as his eggy carcass crashes back down to earth his greediness is still evident as he grabs out at a passing gold brick, forgetting for a second that he's still thousands of feet in the air! My favourite part is the brilliant animation of the gold tower as it sways precariously from side to side, being pummelled by bolts of lightning and losing massive chunks of itself with each sway. The scope of the tower is rather epic for a minute there! It was clever how well they integrated the nursery rhyme and the Tower of Babel story. I was a little annoyed for a second at the end because it looked as if they were going to give the tale a happier ending but no, he was still shattered, I got the feeling that the other storybook folks "wouldn't" be putting Humpty together again this time! This thoroughly entertaining and very good Fleicher offering was highly charming, imaginative, well-animated and all-round fun! 7 crazy egg kings out of ten for me! 🍳

A Memorable Color Classic from Max Fleischer

[ja_kitty_71 · 10/10 · 27 August 2007]

I love animation from Fleischer Studios, along with Disney, Rankin/Bass, Hanna-Barbera, and Studio Ghibli, and this is a great short. It is also one of my favorites from Fleischer's "Color Classics" series. I love it when all the Mother Goose characters warn King Dumpty that his greed will cause him big trouble. I always remember it. I also love the clever rhyming that was used too: "If you value your lives and also your health, do as I bid, for I want more wealth!"

You know, I have heard some negativity about the "Color Classics." But personally, I think the "Color Classics" are great cartoons.

The Generation X Kids Need This Shock Treatment!

[casperinarizona · 10/10 · 5 August 2006]

I remember watching "Greedy Humpty Dumpty" on TV back during the 50's. This cartoon disturbed me and I never forgot it. I just purchased the Max Fleischer cartoon collection on DVD and finally saw "Greedy Humpty Dumpty" in color this time. When that bolt of lightning spanks Humpty Dumpty, kids will just freak out. Some parents may end up taking their kids to a child psychiatrist. I feel that out of control kids need to be propped up in front of a TV and compelled to see this disturbing cartoon. They'll be shell-shocked and they will no longer sass back their parents.

Thank you, Humpty Dumpty!

Eek.

[scottishrose · 1/10 · 9 January 2006]

I saw this cartoon accidentally on television one night when I couldn't get to sleep. It didn't help in the slightest. I found myself staring up at the ceiling, trying to forget that face. I could quite happily never see this cartoon again, simply because of that face.

Now, don't get me wrong - I love fairy tales and nursery rhymes as much as anyone. But this twisted and terrifying rendition simply is disturbing. It is mainly the cruel laughter, and the exaggerated features that terrify me, and I still have nightmares because of it. Please, I urge you not to allow your children to see this. It is far, FAR too scary. Please, I pray you, keep it away.

Golden greed

[TheLittleSongbird · 10/10 · 24 October 2019]

'Greedy Humpty Dumpty' did have quite a lot of things that fascinated me into it. Firstly, my lifelong love of animation, which encompasses all styles, all decades, most studios regardless of budget. Second, have always love it from nursery rhyme characters feature anywhere, and there have been frequent examples of them lending so well to animation. That it was made by Fleischer Studios in one of their better periods too was an interest point.

Am very happy to say that 'Greedy Humpty Dumpty' didn't disappoint me at all. Consider it actually one of Fleischer's best late-30s cartoons, as said already one of the studio's better and more consistent periods as seen in the Popeye cartoons. Also by far one of the best of the "Color Classics" cartoons, a very variable series with the 40s efforts being representative of "the fall of Fleischer", and one of the few that actually was a classic and not really anything against it. Rewatching it was one of the things that has aimed to distract me from recovering from the complications of a viral infection that has had me hospitalised all way.

It is one of the few "Color Classics" cartoons where the story didn't work against it. By all means, it is thin and covers familiar ground somewhat with it not being one of the newest of concepts, but in 'Greedy Humpty Dumpty's' case it was overlookable. Because there was so much energy, so many imaginative touches and an atmosphere that was really quite entrancing. Plus its take on the nursery rhyme characters was interesting.

Visually, 'Greedy Humpty Dumpty' is exceptionally well made as was always the case for Fleischer. Not just because the vibrancy of the colours literally pops out at you and the attention to background detail is so rich and imaginative, but there is also the clever use of the innovative technique (back then) of rotoscoping, which still looks great and blends so well with the traditional animation and is neither overused or abused. The music is a major bonus too, full of character and lushness while the songs, which prove crucial in moving the story forward, stick in the mind for a long time. As do the remarkably smart lyrics.

There are other things that stick in the mind. The building of the golden tower is wonderfully done and just loved the use of nursery rhyme/Mother Goose characters here in this sequence and throughout the cartoon. 'Greedy Humpty Dumpty's' interpretation of Humpty Dumpty himself is an interesting one, seeing him as a tyrant will be a shock though. The cartoon is full of energy, amuses and also has a wonderful strangeness that elevates it beyond potentially cutesy level. The lesson is a good and important one, and successfully avoids preachiness.

Overall, classic. 10/10

Creepy Humpty Dumpty is more like it

[Mary-18 · 27 July 2001]

As a child, I watched a LOT of cartoons, but the ones that both fascinated and disturbed me the most were the Depression-era films of Dave and Max Fleischer. This cartoon is extremely well made, with clever songs and great attention to detail. The segment about building the tower to the sun is absolutely wonderful--all the characters from different fairy tales pitch in. But like many films of this genre, it's just too scary for little kids, and there's something strangely unsettling about King Humpty Dumpty himself - it could be his exaggerated features or the thought of him whipping Little Bo Peep--I'm just not sure.