The Bellman (1945) Poster

(1945)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Wonderful atmosphere but rather dull
MogwaiMovieReviews5 March 2022
Similar mood (and setting) as 1951's "The Red Inn", but without the humour, which it could have probably used. The photography is frequently dazzling and the dynamic editing and expressionistic camera angles are employed well but the story and characters are bland and uninteresting and none of the dialogue is memorable in any way. Still of interest for its amosphere and look, as well as the creepy evocation of everyday backwater supernatural belief hanging over it, but it adds up to nothing and is forgotten almost before the credits roll.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The bellman
AAdaSC21 December 2016
I didn't realize this job existed but Lucien Coëdel is the bellman. He rings the bell from a shack in the middle of nowhere in a snow covered zone in France which is prone to blizzards. His role is similar to that of a lighthouse keeper alerting passing strangers who may be in trouble to a safety zone. Only, he's not normal. A murder is committed outside his shack and whilst other villagers are accused the film follows a love triangle that seriously needs to be resolved.

The film scores for being different as it is set in and around a snowy French village. Two women have a love rivalry that makes things interesting and the bellman is always a bit unpredictable. However, the film is a bit slow and I lost interest. There are no surprises here which is a shame and the outcome is fairly obvious and a bit cheesy.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Do not break the spell.
dbdumonteil8 September 2007
Spellbinding,fascinating film,in a wintry snowy atmosphere which Christian-Jaque's camera perfectly captures.Wonderful pictures:the dead body in the snow raising a hand;the dark horse,galloping in the mountains,as if this animal were demanding justice for his murdered master;the fete ,with the dance complete with quaint instruments ... The whole movie is a feast for the eye .The soundtrack essentially consists of the old French folk song "Aux Marches du Palais " (which Serge Bourguignon would use again in "Cybèle Et Les Dimanches de Ville D'Avray" aka "Sundays and Cybèle" ) which is played again and again,and even sung in full by Renée Faure.

If the film is visually a splendor,I do not think that Prévert's screenplay is perfect .It sometimes drags on and the first dialog between Ledoux and Coedel is rather talky;so is Pigaut's and Faure's interminable love scene.Renée Faure is not attractive enough to portray a romantic peasant girl successfully.She is overshadowed,every step of the way ,by sensational Madeleine Robinson ,one of the greatest actresses France has ever had.Robinson and Pigaut had already teamed up in Claude Autant-Lara's classic "Douce" (1942) and the scenes where they are together (particularly the ball)takes the film out on a level of stratospheric intensity that simply rises above the rest and makes the

Faure/Pigaut scenes bland by comparison.

Like this?Try these:

"Goupi Mains Rouges" Jacques Becker 1943

"L'Assassinat du Père Noel" Christian -Jaque 1941

"Barry" Richard Pottier 1949
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"The first one to coo must bleed."
morrison-dylan-fan6 May 2016
Warning: Spoilers
After watching the superb 1941 film Who Killed Santa Claus?,I decided to take a look at a DVD sellers page for other titles by co- director Christian-Jaque.Getting near the end of the first page,I spotted a film which sounded like a companion piece to Who Killed,that led to me getting ready to meet the Bellmen.

The plot:

Called "Bellmen" by everyone in reference to his job, Jean-Baptiste tries to pass the time by talking to fellow bellmen Fabret.As Fabret talks about his daughter Catherine,Jean-Baptiste spots a man riding by. Sneaking out,Jean-Baptiste grabs a stone and kills the man.Running out, Fabret discovers the dead body,and Jean-Baptiste pulling a bag of cash from the dead man's clothes.As the dead man's blacks horse disappears into the horizon, Jean-Baptiste and Fabret cut a deal.Returning to town for the first time in three days in order to care for his Catherine,Fabret finds himself unable to escape the black horse of death.

View on the film:

Returning to the small town setting just a year after France was liberated from Nazi rule,co-writer/(along with Jacques Prévert) director Christian-Jaque & cinematographer Louis Page bask the title in a chilling Gothic Film Noir atmosphere,where the horse of the apocalypse rides into town with death. Circling the village with snow covered stones and graceful tracking shots breathing in the rustic Horror Noir mood,Jaque and Page ring the bells with the Bellmen in gliding stylised shots,as razor sharp overlapping shots sink Jean-Baptiste and Pierre into a fiery pit of Film Noir hell.

Bringing their adaptation of Claude Boncompain's novel out of the clouds,the screenplay by Jaque & Prévert blends rich Gothic Melodrama with horrific Film Noir doom.Injecting the superb dialogue with a sharp playfulness,the writers gradually entangle Catherine's romantic troubles with her dads fears of Baptiste's killing being dug out of the snow.Keeping Baptiste round the bell tower,the writers open up the in-fighting of the townspeople,whilst slowly spilling the dread from Baptiste and the horse of death over the village.

Caked in a thick black beard, Fernand Ledoux gives a fantastic performance as Fabret,with Ledoux bringing a method to Fabret's madness,as the loss of his wife and illness of Catherine weigh down on his shoulders,as the snow covers Fabret's hands with dirty money.Casting a long shadow over the town, Lucien Coëdel gives a brittle performance as Baptiste,whose rugged shell Coëdel cracks to unveil a ruthlessly mischievous Film Noir loner,who along with tightly keeping Fabret on track,also has his eyes secretly set on Catherine.Running against the hard gazes of Baptiste and Fabret,the stunning Renée Faure (who made her debut as another Catherine in Who Killed Santa) gives an excellent performance as Catherine,thanks to Faure sparkling in her criss-cross romantic exchanges with cad Pierre (a great Roger Pigaut) and also displaying a real bite in Catherine's fight against rival lover Marthe, (a splendidly stern Madeleine Robinson)as the Bellmen bell tolls.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An unknown ww2 french film
lucdum17 March 1999
Sortilèges is an excellent film made by Christian-Jaque, a french director known by his comedies, on a marvellous scenario from Jacques Prévert. it shows that the french poet he was made very good films without Marcel Carné, the director he is too much associated. The film is very dark (as its B&W) and takes place in a little village lost in the mountain. The contrast between the murder and the snow is very symbolical. Besides the french love story between two young fellows, the character of the Bellman (Lucien Coëdel) has a very interessant psychology. Unfortunately, the film is nowadays totally forgotten and I doubt that people could see it easily... but a piracle may always happen ! In this case, I hope that my point of view will be shared and that Sortilèges will cross the Atlantic to be appreciated !
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Little Madeleine
writers_reign16 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
At first glance you could be forgiven for assuming that Christian Jacque was revisiting L'Assassinat de Pere Noel which he made for Continental three years earlier; remote setting, wintry landscapes, etc but actally there is much more on offer, not least Madeleine Robinsion who, as a previous poster has rightly said, was one of the finest French actresses of her generation; it was her misfortune to appear in films that were aimed at domestic rather than international markets so that unlike Danielle Darrieux, Edwige Feuilliere, Micheline Presle, Arletty, etc, all of whom were, of course, equally gifted but contrived to be seen and/or work outside France, Robinson remains one of the best-kept secrets in French cinema. A script by Jacques Prevert doesn't exactly impair a film either if anybody asks you and here he is right on top of his game; add some stunning images, a horse against the snow, etc, and we're talking another winner.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Spellbinding Noir
rob-82-30276316 June 2011
Warning: Spoilers
A very dark and spellbinding film of jealousy and murder set in a little village lost in the French Alps. At first glance you could be forgiven for assuming that director Christian-Jacque (UN REVENANT) was revisiting L'ASSASSINAT DE PERE NOEL which he made for Continental three years earlier; remote setting and wintry landscapes, but actually there is much more to offer, not least Madeleine Robinsion who was one of the finest French actresses of her generation. With a top rate script by Jacques Prevert and camera work of stunning images: a dead body in the snow raising a hand, a black horse galloping mount less as if it were demanding justice for his murdered master and a rural fete complete with quaint musicians and their rustic instruments; The whole movie is a feast for the eyes. The soundtrack essentially consists of the old French folk song "Aux Marches du Palais" which is played throughout the film.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
a Christian-Jaque jewell
happytrigger-64-3905175 October 2020
I must thank Mr Bertrand Tavernier as he recommended this incredible "Sortilèges" directed by the great Christian-Jaque. Visually constantly inventive with Louis Page as the cinematographer, there are a lot of creepy sequences, and the actors are deeply involved in the madness of their characters, especially Fernand Ledoux and Lucien Coëdel (and don't miss Sinoël). There are a lot of camera movements in all the important and sometimes frightening sequences. There are only a few scenes a little weak, but they are instantly forgotten by all the brilliant rest. Shot in Mont Dore in Auvergne. Curiously, just after this masterpiece, I saw an english jewell directed by Jack Lee Thomson (with Sharon Tate), "Eye of the devil". Both movies have some similarities.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed